Major League Baseball’s trade deadline is more than a month away, the rumor mill is already churning, and it isn’t hard to guess who will buy and who will sell.

The Pirates, though, are loitering in the gray area for the third year in a row. They are eight games out of first place and 5 1/2 games out of a wild-card spot, with many teams ahead of them. They aren’t really contenders at this point, but a hot streak would put them back in the chase.

Jon Morosi of MLB.com wrote Thursday that the next 10-15 games are going to determine the Pirates’ plan leading up to the deadline. According to Morosi, if the Pirates slip a little further, they will be sellers. He notes that they are 8-17 in their last 25 games, the worst record in the National League over that span.

The Pirates’ logical trade candidates are veterans who either make a lot of money or are approaching free agency: Josh Harrison, Ivan Nova, Francisco Cervelli, Jordy Mercer and David Freese. All could have some value to a contender looking to fill a hole. One other candidate is Felipe Vazquez. His value has taken a serious hit in the past three weeks, but he is still a young closer with an excellent arm under control at a team-friendly price through 2023.

Advertise with us

Morosi also mentioned Corey Dickerson as a possible trade piece. He will be a free agent after next season, the Pirates aren’t likely to offer him an extension and he would command a decent return. His value won’t be higher than it is right now.

This all makes sense logically and would help the Pirates in the future. It would also be an absolute public relations disaster. Fans are already on edge and staying away from PNC Park, but if this team sells — and thus gives up on the season — there will be all-out mutiny among a group tired of hearing about prospects, controllable years, and financial flexibility.

Those fans would not be wrong. The Pirates’ front office spent the entire offseason smugly telling the world they are trying to win in 2019, claiming they improved by trading Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen and saying their critics weren’t seeing the big picture. Now, it’s time to stop talking a big game.

The Pirates look destined to finish somewhere between, say, 78 and 82 wins. At this point, they are painfully mediocre, but still only need a few moves to position themselves for 86-87 wins. With some good luck, that total could be higher.

That’s why, if they really want to do right by their fans, they need to buy one more solid veteran pitcher and some bullpen help. That would mean they might have to part with a few prospects, but so what? Hoarding them like a precious commodity hasn’t worked particularly well.

Advertise with us

This would be uncharacteristic of the Pirates, but it would be the right decision to make. They can’t always operate to appease their fans, but if ever there were a time, it’s now.

The Pirates can and probably will, as Morosi suggests, be sellers and position themselves for the future. The only thing it will seemingly ensure, though, is that PNC Park is empty when the moves pay off down the road.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise.