Make the right move as the NHL trade deadline closes in, and a general manager can transform his club from a contender to a champion.

Witness what Ron Francis, Ulf Samuelsson and Grant Jennings did for the Penguins when GM Craig Patrick brought them in from Hartford in 1991, or the way that acquiring Butch Goring from Los Angeles in 1980 triggered a run of four consecutive Stanley Cups for the New York Islanders.

Of course, no trade comes with a guarantee, and an ill-considered one can sabotage a franchise’s future for little, or no, short-term gain.

Fully and accurately evaluating personnel moves often takes years, but here are some quick assessments of how some teams improved themselves — or failed to do so—as the deadline at 3 p.m. Monday was closing in:

Advertise with us

WINNERS

New Jersey — GM Ray Shero didn’t turn the Devils into instant Cup challengers when he picked up wingers Michael Grabner and Patrick Maroon, but he did enhance their chances of slipping into the playoffs. And he did it at a relatively low price. A right-handed defenseman who can play on the top two pairings would have come in handy.

New York Rangers — GM Jeff Gorton snuffed his team’s flickering playoff hopes by acting on his promise from a few weeks ago to take his team through a major teardown and rebuild. New York’s lineup has been gutted by the departure of guys like D Ryan McDonagh, C J.T. Miller, RW Rick Nash, D Nick Holden and Grabner, but the Rangers got a nice return in just about instance. Of course, those well-conceived moves will only matter if the Rangers are able develop the prospects and wisely invest the draft choices they acquired.

Tampa Bay — The Lightning was a popular choice to represent the Eastern Conference in the Stanley Cup final before it struck the biggest deal of the deadline, acquiring McDonagh and Miller from the Rangers, and GM Steve Yzerman upgraded his major-league roster while losing just one player, center Vladimir Namestnikov, from it. Tampa Bay looks to be even more of a threat to the Penguins’ chances of winning a third consecutive Stanley Cup than it was at the start of business Monday.

Winnipeg — The Jets, who are hovering near the top of the Western Conference, pulled off perhaps the biggest surprise of the day, getting C Paul Stastny from St. Louis without touching his current roster. He strengthens a strong collection of centers and adds a dimension to Winnipeg’s offense with his playmaking. Picking up depth defenseman Joe Morrow from Montreal likely won’t have much of an impact, but the Jets don’t have a crisis on their blue line.

Advertise with us

LOSERS

Buffalo — Jason Botterill’s initial deadline experience as a GM is one he probably won’t look back on fondly. The market for free agent-to-be LW Evander Kane shriveled to the point where Botterill had to settle for getting a 2019 conditional draft selection, a 2020 conditional draft selection and prospect winger Danny O’Regan from San Jose for him. Even worse, Botterill didn’t move impending free agents like LW Benoit Pouliot, D Josh Gorges and G Chad Johnson, among others.

Colorado — Apparently, we shouldn’t read too much into the Avalanche sitting in 11th place in the Western Conference. Management obviously didn’t feel the need to do anything of real consequence at the deadline, even with guys like Blake Comeau, Gabriel Bourque and Barberio about to qualify for unrestricted free agency.

Montreal — The Canadiens settled on Toronto as a new home for veteran C Tomas Plekanec, but never turned up an acceptable taker for LW Max Pacioretty, the team captain who was openly shopped despite being under contract for another season.

MIXED RESULTS

Advertise with us

Boston — The Bruins moved aggressively to bolster their lineup for a run at the Cup, adding RW Rick Nash, C Tommy Wingels and D Nick Holden and signing free-agent C Brian Gionta. Nash is a potential game-breaker, but can be invisible as often as he is productive, and Gionta, who captained the U.S. Olympic team, has been out of the NHL since last season. Holden and Wingels are solid pickups, but hardly difference-makers.

Columbus — The Blue Jackets approached the deadline looking for a top-six forward and a veteran center, and addressed those needs by acquiring LW Thomas Vanek fom Vancouver and C Mark Letestu from Edmonton. Both should contribute, although neither projects as a game-changer. Penguins alum Ian Cole was a solid pickup on defense, but Columbus failed to deal D Jack Johnson, who should have been a fairly valuable bargaining chip and who has asked to be traded.

Detroit — GM Ken Holland got a very nice return from Vegas for winger Tomas Tatar and a couple of draft choices from Philadelphia for goalie Petr Mrazek, but the Red Wings failed to find a new home for D Mike Green, whose contract is about to expire and who was long regarded as the most marketable asset with whom they were looking to part.

Ottawa — Derick Brassard netted a nice package from the Penguins and it’s hard to criticize Senators GM Pierre Dorion for not moving all-world D Erik Karlsson if he didn’t feel like he received a satisfactory offer — Karlsson’s contract isn’t up yet — but Ottawa had a lot more assets it could have moved if it really wanted to embark on a major overhaul.

Penguins — Adding Brassard allowed GM Jim Rutherford to assure his team again will have the best group of centers in the NHL, but sending Cole to the Senators (who dealt him to Columbus Monday) weakened an already thin defense corps. What’s more, the Penguins didn’t get the right-handed faceoff man they wanted or a veteran goalie to back up Matt Murray in case he would miss significant time during the playoffs because of injury, although that hasn’t happened since way back in 2017.

Advertise with us

Vegas — Golden Knights GM George McPhee paid a pretty steep price — a first-, a second- and a third-round draft choice — to get Tatar, but could afford to because of all the picks he’d stockpiled during the past year. Picking up a capable penalty-killer to help the 16th-rated unit in the league wouldn’t have been a bad idea.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.