FORWARDS - Grade: C-
Depth and balance are important, but the Penguins have to start getting more production from their big-name offensive talents – Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel – if they hope to win the series. Kessel has one goal in the past eight games, while Crosby and Malkin combined for zero shots in Game 3. They’re being outperformed by rookie winger Jake Guentzel, who has four goals in the series and a league-best 13 in the playoffs. Losing center Nick Bonino hurt, but his replacement, Carl Hagelin, played well on the fourth line alongside Matt Cullen and Patric Hornqvist before the unit was disbanded.
DEFENSEMEN - Grade: D+
There are times when the Penguins’ defense corps looks like the patchwork group that it is, and Game 3 was one of those. Expectations for the unit have to be kept reasonable, but it’s not unrealistic to think that the Penguins could be getting more out of Trevor Daley and Justin Schultz, and most of their colleagues. These defensemen don’t have to be difference-makers [in a positive way], but they can’t flirt with being a liability, either. Especially when the Penguins’ forwards aren’t performing to their potential.
Penguins comment on Game 3 loss
GOALIE - Grade: C
Matt Murray allowed the Penguins to reach the first intermission with a lead by stopping all 12 shots Nashville threw at him during the first 20 minutes but, like his teammates, had a miserable second period, as the Predators put three of 16 shots past him. Fair or not, Murray has to take his game to a high level and keep it there if the Penguins’ big-ticket offensive players aren’t going to produce the way they should. He’s hardly the reason the Penguins lost Game 3, but he didn’t do nearly enough to prevent the defeat, either.
Read More
SPECIAL TEAMS - Grade: F
Power plays are cyclical, running hot and cold with little warning, but it’s almost inconceivable that a power play whose No. 1 unit features as much talent as the Penguins’ would be so ineffective. It scored on a five-on-three early in Game 1, but has gone 0-for-12 since, while generating a total of three shots on goal. That’s totally unacceptable, especially when the power play seems to lack any sense of urgency. Maybe losing a series will drive home the value of getting pucks and bodies to the net. And the penalty-kill was 1-for-3 [0-for-2 when it mattered even a little] to complete the special-teams debacle of Game 3.
COACHING - Grade: C-
Mike Sullivan and his staff altered a couple of defense pairings before the game and reconfigured some forward combinations for the third period, but none of the changes had a significant impact on the outcome. And while the coaches presumably aren’t insisting that members of the power play refrain from putting pucks on the net, it’s their responsibility to make sure players execute what they’ve been told. And, if those players refuse to do so, to replace them – no matter who those individuals happen to be.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.