The Penguins don’t need to win tonight in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Finals against Ottawa in order to keep their hopes of repeating alive. It just would behoove them not to lose. It is hard to come from down 3-1 and it is even harder when to do it at less than full strength.

To be clear, it isn’t impossible to come back from winning a series after trailing 3-1, as it has happened 28 times in NHL history. The Penguins have done it before and twice in the past eight years have been on the losing end.

Mike Sullivan sets a tone of seeming to push all the right buttons and refusing to let the Penguins accept anything less than their best. So if any team could come back from being down 3-1 - especially with two of the final three games at home - it is this group of Penguins. They are still the defending champs and obviously won’t go down without a fight.

That being said, asking THIS group of Penguins to do so might be asking them to do the near impossible. The Penguins are injured and their defensive corps is running on fumes. They are missing some of their most important players, and even the players who have returned don’t look 100 percent healthy.

Advertise with us

This isn’t the same team that won the Stanley Cup last season.

I understand the next-man-up mentality, and the Penguins have been excellent at patching holes so far. But a ship can only spring so many leaks before it is bound to sink. That’s why tonight’s game is so critical to the Penguins’ chances. If they win tonight it changes the series completely, as they’d only have to win two more games. It would give them, at least, a little margin for error.

If they were healthy, I’d still bet on the Penguins to win the series even if they lost tonight. But without Patric Hornqvist and Bryan Rust, the offense is missing two key players with important and specific roles. Carl Hagelin is back from his injury but he clearly isn’t fully healthy and lacks the burst of speed that makes him so dangerous.

The offense, though, at least has the star power to overcome those injuries. The same can’t be said about the defense.

Sullivan has had to mix and match defensive parings throughout most of the playoffs. That’s why the defense has been spotty at times and flat-out bad at others. It has all mostly been masked by the brilliance of goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury.

Advertise with us

The Penguins began the playoffs without their best defenseman, Kris Letang. They have since lost replacement Justin Schultz. Trevor Daley has had two procedures on his knee in recent months and like Hagelin, he’s not 100 percent. That means the Penguins have had to rely on Ron Hainsey, Chad Ruhwedel, Ian Cole and Brian Dumoulin far too much. Cole has started to show his age and they’ve had to bring Mark Streit into the mix, which didn’t end well.

Sidney Crosby hasn’t been the same player since he suffered a concussion in Game 2 of the Eastern Conference semifinal against Washington. Crosby has looked a little off his game in this series, though I’m not a doctor and line shuffling could be a factor.

That’s why I think this team is running on fumes right now, which has manifested in this series against Ottawa. I’m not taking credit away from the Senators, either. They have outplayed the Penguins and they deserve to be up 2-1, if not 3-0, at this point. That’s precisely why the Penguins need to even the series tonight and give themselves a realistic shot at advancing.

The Senators are much better than many people thought they were — I know, I know genius me picked a sweep. The Penguins can’t lose the series tonight, that much is certain. They will always have a chance until officially eliminated.

But this isn’t last year’s Penguins. It is a weaker, short-handed version of that team and thus playing for its life. It is simply asking way too much of this group to beat the Senators three times in a row with no margin for error.