With the first football season of six classifications now complete, it’s time for “I’m Just Sayin …”
Having six classifications undoubtedly watered down the product of Pennsylvania high school football this season. But that should not take anything away from the surreal season of Steel Valley.
When you mention greatest teams in WPIAL history, the Ironmen belong in the conversation — on their own level.
Let me explain. First off, please stop with the belief that Steel Valley was the best team in the WPIAL this year in any classification. The Ironmen were tremendous, but they played in 2A. This is not a knock against Steel Valley, but it’s a different world in 4A — and especially 5A and 6A.
Steel Valley, and other smaller-class teams, had some players who would do well in any classification. But all you had to do to realize the difference in classes is, say, watch the Beaver Falls-Middletown PIAA Class 3A final, and then watch the Central Catholic-St. Joseph’s 6A final a few hours later. No comparison. There were some good skill-position players in smaller classes, but just the size of players and speed of the game is so different in the largest classification.
Now back to Steel Valley. The Ironmen belong in the conversation of greatest WPIAL teams because it should be about what a team does at its own level. In recent years, Clairton had a few great teams during its historic 66-game winning streak. The 2007 Jeannette team with Terrelle Pryor is one of the WPIAL’s greatest. because of what they did at their own levels.
Judge the 2016 Steel Valley Ironmen for what they did at their own level. Using that as a barometer, this team belongs in the WPIAL Hall of Fame someday. The Ironmen won every game by mercy rule. That’s crazy. That had never been done before by any Pennsylvania team since the rule was instituted in 1998. But Steel Valley won every game in the regular season and postseason by 34 points or more. The WPIAL playoffs started in 1971. Since then, no team had ever won every game by 34.
So, may this Steel Valley team live in WPIAL lore. It deserves it.
• One more thing about Steel Valley. Many have said Clairton’s Lamont Wade is good enough to start, or at least see considerable playing time, at a college next year. So is Steel Valley’s Paris Ford. He has committed to Pitt to play defensive back. Some of Pitt’s secondary starters are seniors. Ford is undoubtedly talented enough to make a difference next season.
• One of my favorite stories of the year was the Matsooks at Beaver Falls. Dan Matsook won WPIAL and PIAA titles at Rochester. This season, he was along for the WPIAL and PIAA championship rides that his son, Ryan, took the Beaver Falls Tigers. Dan was the line coach for Beaver Falls. How cool is that? You win WPIAL and state titles with your dad as an assistant?
• Duquesne University has Brett Brumbaugh, the WPIAL’s all-time leading passer. But I believe Keystone Oaks QB Alex Smith has a great future for the Dukes. Smith has committed to Duquesne. Smith was under-recruited.
• Record-breaking running back Zane Dudek of Armstrong has a scholarship offer from an FBS school (Kent State). But it says here Dudek will still go to an Ivy League or Patriot League school.
• The critics of teams from Catholic, charter and private schools are out again. Six of the 12 finalists in the PIAA championships were from either Catholic or charters, including five of the six in the three largest classes. While the complaints might have some merit, it’s not going to change because the PIAA has no interest in having separate championships for public and parochial/charter schools. And it’s not a situation unique to Pennsylvania. Yes, some states do have separate championships, but look at Ohio and Michigan. About half of their state finalists were from Catholic or private schools.
• Best game of the year was West Allegheny vs. McKeesport in the WPIAL 5A championship. I’ll give second place to Ringgold vs. West Mifflin in the regular season. Ringgold trailed, 26-14, but scored two touchdowns in the final eight seconds to win, 29-26. The most unforgettable game was Beaver’s 77-49 victory against Keystone Oaks.
• The most unforgettable plays were Najhier West’s 60-yard touchdown run in a PIAA championship for Steel Valley, and McKeesport’s “Hail Mary lateral” on the final play of a playoff game against Gateway. Heck, both grabbed national attention. West’s play was No. 2 on ESPN SportsCenter’s top 10 plays last Saturday. A dunk by Duke’s Grayson Allen was No. 1. And McKeesport’s play made MaxPreps.com’s top 10 plays of November.
• The more things change, the more they stay the same — at least in WPIAL football. Looking at players coming back, here are early predictions for the top-rated teams heading into the 2017 season: Pine-Richland (6A), West Allegheny (5A), Thomas Jefferson or South Fayette (4A), Aliquippa (3A), Steel Valley (2A) and Clairton (1A).
• Where are all the great coaches going? Legendary George Novak retired after this season. Look for Upper St. Clair’s Jim Render, Aliquippa’s Mike Zmijanac and West Allegheny’s Bob Palko to hang it up in the next year or two at the most. In the past few years, the WPIAL also lost big winners in Blackhawk’s Joe Hamilton, McKeesport’s George Smith, North Hills’ Jack McCurry, Bishop Canevin’s Bob Jacoby and Springdale’s Chuck Wagner.
Their retirements were understandable, but the WPIAL coaching fraternity has certainly taken a hit in recent years.
• Time for basketball.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.