MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — In town hall meetings and speeches to TCU’s board of trustees, Chris Del Conte kept coming back to the same message: This is going to take time.
For years, the Horned Frogs had built a reputation as one of the top mid-major football programs in Football Bowl Subdivision, but with a move to the Big 12 Conference in 2012, the school’s athletic director foresaw turbulence and the need for a little patience.
“We felt it was going to be a five-year transition to where we would be competing for championships in all of our sports,” Del Conte said.
From those modest expectations came wild success. Now in its fourth season in its new league, this Christian university in Fort Worth, Texas, is one of FBS’ premier teams and is ranked in the top five in both major polls one season after narrowly missing out on an invitation to the College Football Playoff.
For West Virginia, its opponent tonight, the Horned Frogs’ accomplishments are a source of hope that it can reach the same heights and a cause for frustration because it hasn’t come close to that yet.
The two schools entered the Big 12 in 2012 as powerful forces from lesser conferences: TCU went 77-13 in the Mountain West from 2005-11; West Virginia went 70-20 in the Big East in that span. The transition to a new, more competitive league was difficult for both programs, as they each went 7-6 in their first season and 4-8 the following year.
But while the Horned Frogs have thrived since then — winning 19 of their past 20 — the Mountaineers are mired in mediocrity, having gone 16-21 in conference games the past four seasons, including an 0-3 mark this year.
The toughest aspect of the transition for West Virginia was building depth, a challenge it believes it has met. On its way to a Big East championship in 2011, coach Dana Holgorsen said the Mountaineers played only about 40 players a game. Once they got to the Big 12, with tougher opponents and a faster pace of play, they struggled when their first-team players weren’t on the field.
Now they average about 55 players per game, Holgorsen said, and if an injury occurs or a player needs a break, they have quality backups to insert.
“It takes time to build a program,” safeties coach and special teams coordinator Joe DeForest said. “How long did it take Virginia Tech to build their program? How long did it take Baylor to build their program? I was at Rice when Baylor was Baylor. They stuck to the plan.”
Part of the reason TCU has won big, though, is because of inherent advantages that West Virginia simply doesn’t have in its recruiting base.
In the past five recruiting classes — from 2012-16 — 103 players ranked in the Rivals.com top 250 have come from towns within a three-hour drive of TCU’s campus in the heart of the talent-rich Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex. Only 35 such prospects have been within a similar drive of West Virginia’s, none of whom were from West Virginia.
“It’s such a disadvantage geographically for a program like West Virginia, unless they get hot and they perfect that system,” said Mike Farrell, national recruiting director for Rivals. “And I will say [Baylor coach Art] Briles and [TCU coach Gary] Patterson have a better system than Holgorsen does. I think that’s pretty clear.”
The perfect marriage of one of those local recruits — quarterback Trevone Boykin — with a spread offense also accelerated the Horned Frogs’ growth, transforming them from the 89th scoring offense in 2013 to one of the FBS’ most explosive groups.
For as long and arduous as program-building can be, TCU’s breakthrough a year ago proved that fortunes can reverse quickly and unexpectedly. Holgorsen believes his program, whose three games with TCU since 2012 have been decided by a combined five points, is on that path.
“I think that shows how close we are,” he said.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.