Today’s poll: Should Pitt and Penn State play yearly in all major sports?

No: Different conferences, different needs (44%)

Yes: State pride is at stake (56%)

Jerry Micco: Hello everybody and welcome to the weekly sports of all sorts chat. I'll be back in a few minutes to get things rolling, but in the meantime, feel free to submit early questions and vote in our poll. See you soon!

Advertise with us

Comment From Jay Paterno

Jerry, related to your poll question did Narduzzi take a shot at Penn State when he referenced the lack of output from Hackenberg's talents and do you think Narduzzi is a better Coach than James Franklin?

Jerry Micco: I think Narduzzi, like Franklin, is a competitive guy. Did he fire a shot? Maybe a shot over the bow, but I didn't see it as him trying to belittle PSU, Hackenberg or the coaches. He got his point across, though. When Franklin said he'd, "dominate the state," he was of course talking about recruiting. But those are big words and you have to expect that in-state schools are going to come after you for that. As for who is a better coach, the body of work is so small for both it's hard to tell. Franklin is 12-8 in a year and a half, and Narduzzi is 5-1. I think both are good coaches in their own way, but only time will really tell.

Comment From Sports Joey

I've noticed that interest in the MLB playoffs, at least among people I know, went down to nil after the Pirates were eliminated. Do you think that holds true in other markets?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: I think unless you're a hard-core baseball fan, unless you are in the cities that are participating, most people keep a fleeting interest when their team is out of the running. For example, I watched the Pens game last night, then turned on the Cubs-Mets. And I have an interest in the NLCS as we are a National League city. I think people care about the baseball playoffs, but not nearly as much if your team isn't in it.

Comment From Larry

What major moves do you think the Riverhounds need to make this offseason?

Jerry Micco: You tell me. Really?

Comment From Chunkles

Advertise with us

Its often said in Pittsburgh if you dont like Mike Tomlin, your racist! NOPE! I cannot stand him for his arrogance. He said he had no intention of replacing Vick until he pulled his hamstring! WHAT? Then he goes for a two point conversion. WHY? Yes it was Ben's specialty BUT Ben is not in there to run it and points were at a minimum for three quarters! I know, they won and are 4-2 BUT it isnt because the coach is a genius! He is a pompous azz!

Jerry Micco: When's the next fan club meeting? You don't have to like him, but you have to say an 86-46 regular-season record is worthy of him being confident in any decision he makes. Most fan bases would kill for that record from their coach.

Comment From Concussed

Sorry in advance for the long question/scenario. While I was watching Vick being taken out of the game on a relatively mild play, does this open up a can of worms in important games or high profile players? Can you imagine Brady or Roethliberger in a key situation in the playoffs being targeted in the playoffs with a hit that put them under the protocol? I also wonder if the refs would not show some preferential treatment to certain #12s and give them the benefit of the doubt with the game on the line. Thoughts?

Jerry Micco: Not only is it a referee's duty, I think it's their moral duty, to take a player out they suspect is showing concussion symptoms. The NFL has a poor record on handling concussions. I'm not going to throw a wrench in when they are trying to do the right thing.

Advertise with us

Comment From Guest

What is the formula to winning a World Series, bunch of young great pitchers, slugging baseball team, contact hitters and speed? Pirates don't seem to posses these formulas

Jerry Micco: Getting hot at the right time. Giants did it last year. Mets and Royals doing that this year. The Pirates need more pitching (starters). They have the bats...pretty much. But some of their young stars, especially Jamison Taillon, were set back by TJ surgery. Tyler Glasnow is coming along, but needs more time in AAA. The Pirates, for a team that won 98 games, are going to need to make many decisions for the 2016 season.

Comment From Sarcastic Sword

Jerry I can't see anybody beating the Patriots this year, even with a healthy Ben/Beachum/Pouncey we couldn't, can the Bengals beat them or will Mercury Morris champagne go unpopped finally?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: The Patriots will lose to someone. Maybe Cincinnati; maybe a late-season loss because they'll win the division early and they'll sit some starters. But someone will beat them. I do not see that team, with that defense, going unbeaten.

Comment From Sports Joey

People complained about a 1-game Wild Card not being fair next to a 162-game season, but for that matter, best-of-five and even best-of-seven, isn't that much better. We're seeing that whichever team gets hot is who makes the run, as you say. Unless you want to award the championship to the first place finisher, that's just how it has to be. Would you agree?

Jerry Micco: I'm relatively happy with the MLB playoff set up. One tweak, well it's more than a tweak, I'd make is after the WC game is played, re-seed the four teams and the best records have the home-field advantage. People argue that it does not reward a division winner, but it does. They don't have to do a 1-game playoff. I think my argument would fall on deaf ears, but that's the change I'd make.

Jerry Micco: Clarification: When I said James Franklin was 12-8 as a head coach, I was only including his Penn State record to date. If you add in his three years at Vanderbilt, he's 36-23.

Advertise with us

Comment From Concussed

I agree that a player has to come out if their head is subject to a hit that places them under the protocol, no exceptions. Do you foresee a situation where the protocol is used preferentially/ignored if it's, let's say, the 4th quarter with 30 seconds left, no timeouts, and the Patriots trail by 4 with the ball on the defenses 35 yard line and Brady gets a borderline hit like Vick took on Sunday? There would be an uproar if he stays in or is taken out....

Jerry Micco: I'd think that the referee in that case would still have to determine if the player was able to continue to play and it would be safe for him to do so. yes, your scenario could play out, and I'm sure there would be an uproar. There are doctors on the sidelines, too, and they could get involved if necessary.

Comment From Guest

Jerry, I can't understand how 'fans' were calling for Landry Jones but we were told by the 'experts' he's horrible but then he outperforms Vick easily, what gives there?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: I would never, ever thought Landry Jones could do what he did on Sunday. He was terrible his first two years here. He was mediocre this preseason though he must've had 70 percent of the snaps. The reason they got Vick was because the coaches and front office didn't think Jones was the next guy up. But I think he'll get his chance to start this week in KC. And the Chiefs, who somehow are 1-5, have terrific pass rushers.

Comment From Guest

Jerry will Ryan shazier play this week?

Jerry Micco: Mike Tomlin said yesterday that he believed both Shazier and Jarvis Jones would play on Sunday. But they haven't practiced yet.

Comment From Sports Joey

Advertise with us

Which do you find more entertaining to watch, college or pro football?

Jerry Micco: I love all levels of football. But the NFL is the gold standard. It's the best football played by the best players. But that doesn't mean I haven't sat on my ample rump and watched college ball from noon-midnight on a few Saturday's. My wife is always pleased when that happens, by the way.

Jerry Micco: I can't believe it: Not one person is voting in the poll?

Comment From Guest

Jerry, Pitt/PSU rivalry is dead because the younger generation lost it's relevance because it went dormant. College football is now all about Conference rivalries. Agree?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: When I was a student at PSU back in the mid/late 70s, that rivalry was one of the best in the country. Great teams and Pitt would win a national title during that period. Tony Dorsett, to me, was the best college football player I've ever seen. And the games meant something back then. Both were Eastern independents, and often were the team opposite the conference tie-in at the Orange, Cotton and Sugar bowls. I don't think it's completely dead. I think when they play in 2016, it'll be heavily attended and hotly contested. But it's not what it was way back when.

Comment From Sports Joey

Let's be clear though, Landry Jones didn't exactly light it up out there. He threw some ugly passes and half of his production came on one somewhat flukey 88-yard play. He just looked like Joe Montana after how brutal Vick was playing.

Jerry Micco: I was trying to be positive, but yes, he had some poor throws. But here's the bottom line: He got the job done when he needed to do that. Like Vick the week before in San Diego, one long pass was most of his passing yards, but it got the Steelers rolling and eventually winning that game. The Steelers have to do whatever works to win while Ben is out. The defense has certainly been great during that stretch.

Comment From Rod Buskas

Advertise with us

Jerry your thoughts on RMU hockey this season? Frozen Four?

Jerry Micco: Good team, probably the best in their conference. Nice program out there for Derek Schooley. I think he's a terrific coach. Frozen Four? They aren't in that rare air yet.

Comment From Danny Ford

Jerry can anyone beat Clemson in the ACC or do they run the table straight to the BCS playoff?

Jerry Micco: There are many years when I think Clemson is one of the best teams in the nation. Many. Then they blow an ACC game or get wiped out in a bowl game (See: WVU/Orange Bowl). But any school that had the likes of DeAndre Hopkins, Martavis Bryant and Sammy Watkins at WR and didn't play better is mind-boggling. In college ball it's all about great QBs and WRs. Clemson has had its share recently.

Advertise with us

Comment From Guest

Jerry can the Steelers expect to go far this season without Pouncey and Beachum? Seems like a theme with the OL injuries every season

Jerry Micco: I think the OL is playing well, but of course would be better with Pouncey and Beachum playing on it. That said, Wallace has played pretty well in Pouncey's absence. And I guess we'll see how good Alejandro Villanueva is as a left tackle. Gilbert and DeCastro are great together on the right side. Foster has had a pretty good season at LG. Maybe they can make up for the backups that are now starters.

Comment From Dr Roy Chipman

Jerry is Jamie Dixon too clean to ever have a Final Four team at Pitt?

Advertise with us

Jerry Micco: Has nothing to do with being clean or dirty. Duke has won its share of titles and unless there's evidence I don't know about, it's a clean program. Jamie Dixon is fully transitioning Pitt into an ACC type team. They will be bigger up front and have more athletic guys. Will it be enough to compete with Duke, Carolina, Notre Dame, Syracuse, etc.? We'll see.

Comment From Sports Joey

What do you make of the struggles of Christian Hackenberg? Not as talented as the hype, coaching, or something else?

Jerry Micco: Maybe a little bit of both. Coaching change and offensive coordinator change is always tough to go through. That was really a problem in 2014. I think that while there hasn't been a lot of improvement in 2015, the offense is a bit better. The OL, which is hardly a long suit, is a bit better. I think Hackenberg is a talented guy, but I think like most QBs, the table has to be set and he has to feel comfortable. I don't know how comfortable he is in the offense. That's part coaching and part philosophy.

Comment From Guest

Advertise with us

ESPN set to have massive layoffs, what does that say about that why people like me don't even watch ESPN programming anymore?

Jerry Micco: You hate to see people lose their jobs, but the cable industry is going through a lot of changes. Fewer people, particularly younger audiences, are watching cable and opting for web-based programming. Not everyone, but many are migrating that way. ESPN has seen a drop in viewship, yet it's rights payments to televise the NBA and other sports, are going up. As revenue declines, you have to make tough decisions.

Comment From Guest

Speaking of Tony Dorsett, my earliest memories were of my Father used to take us to Pitt Stadium and watch him run wild in 1976 in a half jersey through Army

Jerry Micco: My earliest memories of Dorsett were my sophomore and junior years on the New Castle football team. I never got into either Hopewell game, but they beat us both years by the same score, 21-12. In the first game at Hopewell, we clamped down on him in the first half. And either the first or 2nd play of the second half, a guy lined up wrong, and he went 70 yards. We're still chasing him. The next year at New Castle, we are in another tight game and we are somewhat controlling him. Then as a safety, and a great one at that, he picks off a pass deep middle and returns it 75 yards for a TD. Yep, I still remember. Would have been 1971 and 1972 seasons.

Advertise with us

Comment From The Ranger

Jerry who's under Center this sunday for the Steelers?

Jerry Micco: Goodness I'd think Landry Jones.

Jerry Micco: OK folks time to get back to some other things on my desk. Thanks so much for taking the time to talk with me today. I always enjoy the hour. I'll see you at noon next Wednesday and we'll do this all over again. Have a great week everybody! Follow me on Twitter: @PG_JerryMicco