It has been more than 14 years since Pitt and Penn State last played each other in a football game, and more than 500 days until they do so again.
Given that long break in the series, it might be appropriate to call Pennsylvania's two top football programs "former rivals." But the recruiting trail tells a different story.
While the past five years have put a damper on any Pitt-Penn State recruiting rivalry -- with the Panthers failing to find coaching stability and the Nittany Lions dealing with NCAA sanctions and coaching changes of their own -- both programs are in position to stoke the flames now.
Pitt has a roster full of young talent and an incoming coach in Pat Narduzzi who, at least initially, seems like he could buck the trend of coaches leaving town after all-too-short tenures.
Penn State, meanwhile, is free of NCAA sanctions, and coach James Franklin has a full allotment of scholarships to fill out the Nittany Lions roster.
Both coaches have emphasized the importances of in-state recruiting, and 10 of the top 15 college football prospects in Pennsylvania, as ranked by recruiting service Rivals.com, opted to sign with Pitt or Penn State.
Read More
Franklin and Narduzzi, too, have no problem making their recruiting battles a little more public than they've been in the past. Both staffs are active on Twitter and social media, so there has been more than a little public sniping back and forth as the recruiting wars heated up.
With no game between the two teams until Sept. 10, 2016, these recruiting battles will have to make up the extent of the Pitt-Penn State rivalry until then. But if this year was any indication, it should still be pretty intriguing.
'Premier program'
Since Narduzzi was hired by Pitt Dec. 26, he and his staff haven't been afraid to go right at Penn State's perceived superiority within the state.
After all, Narduzzi came to Pitt from Michigan State, a program that for most of its history has had to operate in the University of Michigan's shadow.
Spartans coach Mark Dantonio, with Narduzzi at his side, flipped that script over the past few seasons, guiding the Spartans to a couple of Big Ten titles and six wins in seven years against their supposed "big brother."
If Narduzzi is going to challenge Penn State, that starts on the recruiting trail, specifically within the state. So it's no surprise it took him just 33 seconds into his signing day news conference Wednesday to mention Pitt landed the No. 1 player in Pennsylvania.
"We want to keep the best right here at home," he said afterward.
Making Pitt a destination for Pennsylvania's top talent was not necessarily an area of strength under former Pitt coach Paul Chryst. Despite Penn State going through NCAA sanctions and coaching transitions, the Panthers never managed to land more than three of Rivals' top 10 Pennsylvania recruits in Chryst's three years.
During that stretch, Pitt lost elite local talent such as defensive back Montae Nicholson to Michigan State, running back Shai McKenzie to Virginia Tech and defensive back Dravon Henry to West Virginia.
Now, with the Nittany Lions' sanctions lifted and Franklin seemingly a long-term fit as head coach, it appears the biggest challenge to Pitt keeping the best Western Pennsylvania talent at home is the school about three hours to the east.
On Jan. 21, the day Pitt landed its first two verbal commitments under Narduzzi, offensive line coach John Peterson tweeted a graphic showing an outline of the state, topped by a Pitt logo and the words "THE PREMIER PROGRAM IN THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA."
Narduzzi denied that it was a reference to any one school, but it's unlikely Peterson was referring to Temple.
"Our guys are passionate about Pittsburgh," Narduzzi said. "I don't think there's been anything on Twitter where we've put anybody down. We're talking about what we have and being respectful, I think. I don't know what's happened on the other side."
Narduzzi also denied that his staff uses negative recruiting tactics when talking with prospects. But he said it's a part of the recruiting world these days.
"When you're out there recruiting, it's wild the things you hear," he said. "We're out on the road speaking factually about what we are here at the University of Pittsburgh."
'Dominate the state'
From Franklin's opening news conference as Penn State's head coach more than a year ago, he has pledged to "dominate the state" of Pennsylvania when it comes to recruiting.
Before Franklin's arrival, Penn State had signed just two players ranked in Rivals' top 10 in Pennsylvania, dating back to former coach Joe Paterno's ouster in 2011.
This year, Franklin's first full cycle of recruiting for Penn State, he made good on that promise of dominance, with 11 signees from Pennsylvania and seven of the state's top 10 prospects.
"You make [something] a priority, you're going to do well," Franklin said. "You make it a priority to keep the best players in this region home, you're going to do that, and I think we can do better going forward."
Most years, the key to recruiting Pennsylvania is recruiting the state's western parts, the areas in and around Pittsburgh. In other words, the areas now occupied by Narduzzi and company.
As Pitt challenges Penn State's superiority in the region and the state, the Nittany Lions don't appear to be shirking off the Panthers as a "little brother," but rather embracing the off-field rivalry against the state's second-most-prominent program.
In advertising and politics, nothing legitimizes a challenger more than recognition from the opponent. As Pitt makes a public show of challenging Penn State, the Nittany Lions seem to have no problem acknowledging that Pitt is a legitimate contender to their Pennsylvania recruiting throne.
For now, though, the Nittany Lions appear fairly comfortable atop their perch, and don't mind subtly reminding Narduzzi and his staff when given the chance.
After Penn State flipped recruits Nick Bowers and Kevin Givens from Pitt in the week before signing day -- an apparent show of dominance if there ever was one -- Nittany Lions wide receivers coach Josh Gattis couldn't help but twist the knife a bit by tweeting, "When negative recruiting goes wrong ... Don't awake a giant by throwing stones."
Gattis and Franklin both denied that it was a direct shot at Pitt, but it's not hard to read between the lines.
"We've got a competitive staff, and they believe in doing things the right way and representing this school the right way," Franklin said. "But the competitive juices get flowing sometimes and sometimes you feel like you need to strike back."
He said, he said
More tweets by Pitt and Penn State coaches are making veiled references to the opposing school:
"Pitt coaches were out protecting our turf today. Now time for a big weekend on campus. #OntheProwl #H2P"
--@CoachDuzzPittFB, Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi
6:21 p.m. Jan. 16
"Fun to hear what other coaches are saying about the noise we are making....! #H2P"
--@CoachTimSalem, Pitt TE coach Tim Salem
9:39 p.m. Jan. 26
"#WeAre...Better #107kStrong #PSUnrivaled"
--@coachjfranklin, Penn State coach James Franklin
9:45 a.m. Jan 25
"From Erie to Philadelphia....From Washington to Susquehanna....and EVERYWHERE in between... #WeAre....PENN STATE."
--@CoachHand, Penn State OL coach Herb Hand
12:40 p.m. Tuesday
Audrey Snyder contributed. Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.