Noting the fast-diminishing utility of any further debate about the end of last Sunday's Super Bowl, New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick tried to recast the entire discussion this week as a kind of sordid, illegitimate theater.
Criticism of Seattle's play-calling in the final minute, Belichick implied in a radio interview on WEEI in Boston, was not only wrong; it was completely devoid of standing.
Such criticism, never mind that its rhetorical mass would block out several of the planets, is not "anywhere close," in Belichick's view, "to being deserved or founded."
Such criticism, he went on, is "totally out of line," and (here's your money quote) such criticism is "by a lot of people who I don't think are anywhere near qualified to be commenting on it."
Well, this is interesting on just too many levels.
Would the coach suggest that only people who are "qualified" to speak on a subject dare traffic in public commentary, analysis and criticism?
What would become of cable news?
Surely he's not talking about sports columnists. Our qualifications have forever been self-evident, meaning, well, evident to ourselves. But it's not just columnists. If Belichick were credentialing "qualified" critics, the press box at the Super Bowl would have been empty. Also, the broadcast booths, the studio sets and the sidelines would have been 100 percent reporter-free. As to the consumers who actually pay to get in, their opinions are likely viewed by the Patriots coach as more of the simple bleating of the uninformed. If that sounds presumptuous, it's probably because I'm nowhere near qualified to interpret him.
You don't have to be a chicken to know a rotten egg, but Belichick would say that yes, you do. Not only should you be a chicken, but you should probably be a chicken with a Ph.D and 40 years of experience at film study who has been to nine Super Bowls.
But in fairness, his wasn't the only voice raised this week to defend Seahawks coach Pete Carroll, so his critics did not take just that one verbal bullet.
"Those people that said, 'Oh, it's the worst call ever,' they're idiots," Dallas Mavericks owner Mark Cuban told ESPN Dallas from an entirely different sport. "Never take advice from someone who doesn't have to live with the consequences, so what I say is worth what it's worth, but they've never been in a situation where you've got to make a call where everything, literally everything, is on the line. If you're afraid to go with what's gotten you there, you're not long for this league."
Unlike the Mavericks owner, Belichick didn't call anyone an idiot and, notice this as well, he didn't actually endorse the call on Seattle's final offensive play. Cuban, however, said he liked "the randomness of the plays" the Seahawks called.
"I don't know if they gave the reason why they called that particular play," Cuban said, "but there's a reason. I'll go with the logic of that reason versus conventional wisdom every day, because the guys who follow conventional wisdom are the ones looking for jobs right now."
By the way, Mark Cuban? Probably nowhere near qualified to comment on this.
But you know what? He should be, just as you should be and I should be, and all of us would be if it weren't for coaches, who have spent most of the past 100 years complicating this game to such an extent that only they can understand it, or at least pretend to, and they very much like it that way because it has become very profitable.
I'd tell you that only in coaching could you get away with this, but there is, after all, law school.
In the case of last Sunday's decisive play, every player on the field knew in his football soul that the Super Bowl should be decided on his contribution to getting Seattle running back Marshawn Lynch into the end zone, or on his contribution to preventing it.
The coaches took that away from the players because the coaches have never seen a situation that can't be complicated. The Patriots list 16 coaches including Belichick; the Seahawks have 23 -- 11 of them for the offense. At any given moment last Sunday, there were almost twice as many coaches in the building as players on the field.
As the world knows, with the championship a yard away, the Seahawks chose to throw instead of run, and that throw was intercepted.
Gil Brandt, who spent nearly 30 years scouting for and helping Tex Schramm and Tom Landry build the Dallas Cowboys from the ground up, compared the play call to a blackjack player hitting 20.
Would Gil Brandt be qualified?
In Kent, Wash., the family of one Michael Vedvik found the 53-year old dead of an apparent heart attack Monday. In his obit in the Spokane Spokesman-Review, they wrote, "We blame the Seahawks lousy play call for his untimely demise."
Somehow I find them fully qualified.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.