Today’s poll question: Should Mike Tomlin keep Dick LeBeau?
No ( 35% )
Yes ( 65% )
Comment From Touchdown Joey
I've talked to more than a few fans who have not really engaged with following the Pens so far this year. A few years ago, enthusiasm for the Penguins seemed to be at a crest, especially with fans of the millenial generation. Do you think that is still holding, or have to playoff failures since 09 drained some of the energy?
Jerry Micco: Perhaps some of the energy has drained, but part of it is the Steelers having a good late run and making the playoffs. Besides, a lot of non-hardcore hockey fans won't check in until January. It's a long season and it's only half-way through. But make no mistake, people still care a lot about the Penguins, as our website traffic indicates.
Comment From The Chief
Jerry, Happy New Year; hope you and your had a great Holiday Season. Who played their last game as a Steeler this past Saturday?
Jerry Micco: Hello Chief, same to you! Well, played or was on the team? Ike Taylor, Brett Keisel, Troy Polamalu, Cam Thomas. There will be others, I'm sure. Marginal guys have to battle for jobs all the time.
Comment From James_Wilmerding
Jerry, quite simply, do the Steelers win that playoff game if Legarrete Blount was still on the team? And do you think secretly MT regrets that decision?
Jerry Micco: No guarantee they win with Blount. Yes, the Ravens would have to pay more attention to the run game with him, but he's not Le'Veon Bell. What they may regret is not picking up a guy like Ben Tate when they unloaded Blount. I don't think Tomlin regrets the decision, though.
Comment From steve
Is Big Ben worth a 6 yr 20M p/yr contract? Last 4 yrs no playoff wins, loses to Raiders, Jets, Tampa..??
Jerry Micco: If you think there is a better QB out there, then you don't pay Ben. He'a a top 5 or 6 guy, so you need to get someone who can potentially reach that level. Not easy to find, and if they pay him $20 million/year, it would be the going rate. Though they may only want to do 3 or 4 years, not 5.
Comment From Jim
With two wild card teams in last year's World Series, with the 8th place LA kings winning two of the last three Stanley Cups, and with wild card teams and low seated teams winning the Super Bowl, and NCAA Tournaments, are we moving towards a time where the regular season ticket holder decides not to renew?
Jerry Micco: I think more than what you have deftly shown in your question is whether the ticket, parking and concession prices to attend pro sports events won't drive people away. With at-home technology as good as it is, and the ability to replay what you want, the pro leagues need to do some serious studying to see what impact this is having. I know the NFL is concerned because Roger Goodell said this before last year's Super Bowl.
Jerry Micco: @Steel City Mike: Didn't get your question answered yesterday, huh?
Comment From The Chief
Jerry, your thoughts on the David Perron trade. It basically was Phillip Samuelson and a 2015 #1 pick for Perron.
Jerry Micco: Proven goal-scorer who can certainly help. I liked the trade and found it refreshing that Rutherford pulled the string well before the trade deadline.
Comment From James_Reno
I know every team needs a franchise QB and Ben had a great season statistically but if he gets a 100 million dollar contract won't most of that be for past performance? Any chance at all the Steelers let him walk?
Jerry Micco: Isn't every veteran contract based on past performance? No chance he walks.
Comment From Rob
The thirty some odd Bowl games had few people at the games but television ratings were good, are we getting to the point of just having these games played in a Hollywood studio for later broadcast?
Jerry Micco: If they can find a studio to fit a 120-yard field, who knows. A ton of these games are for TV, and TV pays for them. They want holiday programming and the games tend to get good audience as you point out.
Comment From The Chief
Jerry your thoughts on the non interference call in the DFW-DTW game. Should pass interference be worthy of a coaches challenge?
Jerry Micco: I thought it was a lousy call, but don't think it should be subject to review. Some things are just judgment calls and you have to live with them.
Comment From E.J.
This was the first year in quite some time that all three Pittsburgh teams made the playoffs in the same year. All three also went one and done, with the Pirates losing to San Fran in the wild card and the Pens exiting after being up 3-1. So all three teams are playing well, which I'm excited about. But, which team do you feel is best prepared to take it to the next level and actually have a good/great post season?
Jerry Micco: The Penguins actually won their first-round series with Columbus last year, then lost to the Rangers. I think they are going to have a deeper run this year. And watch the Pirates. If their pitching holds up, they have a chance to win the division. I know that sounds crazy, but they could be very good this season.
Comment From Guest
I read Collier's article today, what kind of relationship does MT have with the PG sports writers? Is it contentious or more light hearted?
Jerry Micco: I think it's a professional relationship. I don't think many coaches/managers, whoever, love having us around asking a lot of questions. Doesn't mean they dislike us personally or mistreat us in any way, but it's somewhat adversarial. But since they see the same media people day in and day out, it behooves the coaches -- and us -- to have a high level of professionalism at all times.
Comment From Zack
Why isn't Colbert getting more heat for the lousy personnell decisions, FA signings, and suspect drafting past round 2, and maybe round 1 if Jarvis is a bust?
Jerry Micco: I think he's taken some heat. Jones is hardly a bust, I disagree. If he gets no better next year, then you can say that. He lost most of the season this year with a broken wrist. Every GM has his bad drafts and bad draft choices. And they have their nice picks, too. Antonio Brown was a terrific pick. So were Bell and DeCastro. Deep in the draft, it's true, the Steelers have faltered. I don't think Colbert gets a pass on that.
Comment From The Chief
Is Jameis Winston the next Jamarcus Russell ?
Jerry Micco: I think he'll be better as a QB than Russell. Off the field, no comment.
Comment From James_Malibu
Jerry who was the biggest jerk of a Manager/Coach you ever covered in your career?
Jerry Micco: A high school coach while I was sports editor in Newport News, Va., whose team was a powerhouse and he tried to bully everyone who he didn't like. I had 2 conversations with him, neither one pleasant, and came away with the sad thought that he was teaching young people how to act.
Comment From Tship
Hi Jerry, Short term view is the Steelers over achieved this year and we can be happy with that, however looking to the future with so many contracts coming up and the jury still out on a lot of the younger players, I can;t decide which way the arrow is pointing on this team. I;m afraid it could be down, is this just Steeler fan paranoia?
Jerry Micco: Unless some younger guys continue to improve and the defense gets better, they won't win 11 games next year. The schedule is much tougher as they play the AFC and NFC West. But if they can go 4-2 again in the division and at least split against the Wests, then maybe they approach 11 wins.
Comment From Rob
Which of the 2014 free agent signings will be in a Steelers uniform in 2015?
Jerry Micco: Mike Mitchell for sure. Maybe Arthur Moats. Long shot for Darrius Heyward-Bey.
Comment From NapleDave
Hi Jerry & Happy New Year! Ben under contract for one year, can they then franchise him for another? Thanks
Jerry Micco: Yes they can, and that's not completely out of the question.
Comment From The Chief
Do you forsee all the NFL home teams winning this coming weekend ?
Jerry Micco: I do. New England will have its hands full with Baltimore and Green Bay will get a fight from Dallas. To me, those are the best two games of the weekend.
Comment From The Chief
Your thoughts on this years Baseball HOF class, do the PED guys ever get in?
Jerry Micco: I think all four guys are deserving. As for the PED group, in time they might. I'm always conflicted by this because when he wasn't juicing, Barry Bonds was a terrific player who had numbers similar to Ken Griffey, Jr. He was a great player (Bonds) and played at a high level well before he juiced, which of course has never been proven. Guys like Sosa, McGwire, to me, are not even mentioned except for those juicing days.
Comment From Guest
I just think the Steelers failure to win a playoff game in 4 years is because of the philosophy to draft OL and LB's with the first pick. I think Decastro is average, I'll call Jones and Shazier reaches, let alone Mike Adams, Marcus Gilbert.
Jerry Micco: Well, you'll find the best OTs taken in the first 15 picks nearly every year. And if you can get a good rush LB in the 3/4, you have to take him. You need 4 on the field most of the time. DeCastro is far from average and was considered for the Pro Bowl this season. He's going to make that game many times in his career. Pouncey is a very good pick. Gilbert isn't dominant, but gets the job done. Jones and Shazier, at least according to draft experts, were drafted about where they should have been. We, and other outlets, reported that Dallas was ready to take Shazier next if the Steelers did not. You have to give some guys a couple years before you label them busts.
Comment From Ralph The Plumber
Mr Smizik seems to think the Pirates roster is set, can NH make one more big splash in the free agent market still like a 1B or another starting pitcher?
Jerry Micco: I think Bob's pretty much on point with that assessment. Doesn't mean a bull pen tweak or another starting pitcher may not be in order. But by and large, they are done. Alvarez and Corey Hart will handle first base. Signing Liriano and Burnett solidifies the starting staff.
Comment From Brian
Love the chats Jerry, but that last comment from "Guest" did me in. I have a migraine now. Keep up the good work, and a bottle of aspirin (or something stronger) nearby!
Jerry Micco: In the old days of newspapering, I'd have a bottle of whiskey in my desk. I think I have butterscotch candy in there somewhere.
Comment From Guest
If taking OL and LB's in the 1st round is a good philosophy then why did the OL get pushed around Sat night and the LB's put no pressure on Flacco.
Jerry Micco: I think you take the best players on where you draft. I think last year was the lowest they had drafted since taking Pouncey, who has turned out to be an All-Pro player. And most NFL teams will tell you that if you can't win on the OL or DL, you likely won't win the game. That same OL scored what, 40-something on the Ravens the game before? Not having Bell made the Steelers one dimentional. As for the pass rush, it has not been good for a couple years now. And it needs work.
Comment From The Chief
Jerry should we make anything out of the Geno-Adams scrum? Also believe Adams will make one heck of a head coach someday.
Jerry Micco: I don't think there's a lot to be made out of it. Not every teammate enjoys his other teammate. Guys sometimes get heated in practice. I think if there was more to it, then the Penguins coaches will work that out between the players. Adams might make a good coach. Not ready to say he will flat-out, though.
Comment From Ralph LA
Is the heat on LeBeau warranted? He can only play the cards that he was handed. Were there shortcomings that can be attributed to coaching?
Jerry Micco: There is some truth to what you say. But also, LeBeau has a say in some personnel decisions including guys they sign and draft. Not the final say, but he watches film. And the defense, maybe, needs to hear a different voice and maybe different schemes. Dick LeBeau is a very good DC. But sometimes in the name of change, good people are let go.
Comment From Rob
Is the reality of things the Steelers had a good season but it is tough to swallow because they got manhandled by the Ravens at home in the playoffs or the playoff game exposed weaknesses we all knew were there and didn't want to admit or both?
Jerry Micco: You knew the defense has had its problems all season long, and the offense would not be the same without Bell. Those things were known going in. They needed to win the turnover battle (they didn't) and they had to keep Ben clean (they didn't). And they didn't pressure Flacco nearly enough. When i rewatched the game, every time there was heat on Flacco, he was not accurate. But you give the Ravens credit: they played a very good game in a tough environment. And they are a very good road playoff team.
Comment From Guest
Any chance the Steelers force LeBeau to retire and MT brings in his friend Perry Fewell as Def Coordinator? That's what I'm hearing
Jerry Micco: Can't say I've heard anything like that. But Fewell was let go today by the Giants.
Comment From The Chief
Jerry, where do you stand on having a Penguins Chat and when will the Pirates chat start up?
Jerry Micco: We're working on the Penguins chat. The Pirates chat will start Feb. 19. Bill Brink, who just happened to be in the office today, told me the date. He may do one next week after minicamp, too. Stay tuned.
Comment From James_Big Sur
Were you in Oakland when Mike Shanahan was out there? Al Davis must be rolling over in his grave at the thought of his son hiring Shanny
Jerry Micco: Shanahan coached the LA Raiders in the 80s, so no, I was not there when he was coaching. I was in the Bay Area and the Raiders were there, but they were led by Jon Gruden for a big hunk of my time out there.
Comment From The Chief
If the Rams move back to LA, do you forsee any NFL Franchise moving to St Louis?
Jerry Micco: No, unless Jacksonville wants to take a shot there. If the Rams return to LA, that will be twice that St. Louis has lost an NFL franchise. Doesn't seem to be a place the NFL would want to try again. And while I hate to see cities lose teams, LA should have an NFL team.
Comment From The Chief
Jerry, just curious have you ever thought about writing a book?
Jerry Micco: No, not really. I don't know that I have that discipline. And since I did not spend a lot of time as a reporter in my career, I don't know that it would be interesting enough to read. I don't write all that much, so I don't know that I've got a book in me. If I did write one, it would be on growing up in an Italian family in Western Pa. Not about sports, though sports certainly would be a part of it.
Comment From Guest
Who ya got Ohio St or Oregon?
Jerry Micco: Hard to pick against Ohio State after an impressive Sugar Bowl, but I will. I think Oregon wins it.
Comment From Ryphia
I've been asking around about this and have not gotten a definitive answer: wouldn't the Steelers be subject to fines and/or other penalties after Mitchell disclosed he had a significant injury all year and was not on the Steelers injury report every week? I thought including injured players on there was mandatory - especially since he missed several Wednesday practices. Has Mitchell put the Steelers in an awkward situation?
Jerry Micco: Mine won't be definitive, either. I don't think they are subject to any fines and it could be Mitchell was never listed because there was no doubt he's play. I'm not exactly sure why the NFL even does an injury report. Well I have my opinion on it (Vegas), but other than that, who cares who is going to play?
Comment From LA Matt
Although he has been a terrific coach and an even better person, I agree that it is time for the D to hear a different voice and make some changes! I have long believe that if his defense is that complex and takes that long to learn that future all-pros (e.g., Polamalu, Heyward, etc...) have to "sit out" a year to learn it, it is too complex! When you only can sign your draft choices up for a few years in their initial contracts, you can't afford eto have them sit out to learn a complex defensive system.
Jerry Micco: Yes, it will be an interesting storyline to follow. Dick LeBeau will always be beloved in this town and for good reason. He's pure class on and off the field. But in this business, sometimes you have to change things up. Shoot, in every business you have to do that.
Comment From LA Matt
After yesterday's game at BC, even with the win, looks like a long season for Dixon and the Panthers?
Jerry Micco: I still think Pitt is a top six ACC team. I may be wrong, but I think they'll get better as the seasons rolls along. Won't be easy, but I think they'll squeeze into the tournament.
Comment From LA Matt
Have you ever seen such a debacle as the last four minutes of the Pitt-Houston game? If I did not see it with my own eyes, I would have never thought it possible.
Jerry Micco: I couldn't believe it. Though people I know who are Pitt fans told me, "How could you not think it would happen?" I could see if they were playing a really good team and just got waxed, but Houston was not very good. All you can do is learn from that and carry it with you as an experience you'll never want to have happen again. Pat Narduzzi was a very good hire. He'll get them back on track this spring.
Jerry Micco: OK folks, time to run off to do some other stuff. As always, thanks for taking the time to talk to me today. I appreciate all the great questions. I'll be back next Wednesday at noon and we'll do it all over again. Until then, have a great week everybody! Follow me on Twitter: @PG_JerryMicco




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.