Seneca Valley boys' basketball coach Victor Giannotta was a bag man a few nights ago.

He brought a shopping bag with him to the WPIAL playoff pairings meeting Tuesday night. At the meeting, the WPIAL also awards plaques to section champions.

Question of the week

Is the Chartiers Valley boys' basketball team the best in the WPIAL, regardless of classification?

Advertise with us

Want to cast your ballot? Vote now!

Last week's question and results

Should the NCAA have a week-long early signing period in November for football, like the one for basketball?

Yes: 72 percent

No: 28 percent

Advertise with us

Total votes: 248

"I brought the bag because I don't want the plaque to get wet in the rain," Giannotta said. His initiative shows that a WPIAL basketball section championship still means something. But the value of a section title has changed dramatically over the past few decades.

Until 1978, a team couldn't make the WPIAL playoffs unless it won a section title. A team had to finish first in the section in order to have a shot at the WPIAL championship. But under that system, some extremely talented teams missed the postseason by finishing second or lower in their sections.

The 2009 WPIAL boys' and girls' basketball playoffs begin tonight, and a look at the field shows how the playoffs have changed over the years. In the boys' tournament, there are 77 teams spread throughout four enrollment classifications, and 24 have won or tied for a section title. That means 69 percent of the teams finished second or lower in their sections (the top four teams from each section qualified).

It means there is a decent chance a team that has not won its section championship could win the WPIAL title. It has happened 28 times before. The first to do it was Geibel in 1980. Last year, neither Blackhawk nor Central Catholic won its section championship, but both won WPIAL titles.

Advertise with us

Two years ago, West Allegheny tied for fourth place in its section, was the No. 16 seed for the Class AAA playoffs but won a WPIAL title.

Oh, how WPIAL basketball has changed! Forty-two years ago, Jarrett Durham was a talented senior on an Aliquippa team that had a 19-3 regular-season record but didn't go to the playoffs because the Quips finished second to Ambridge in section play. Ambridge went on to an undefeated season, winning WPIAL and PIAA titles in the process and is considered possibly the best team in WPIAL history.

Now consider that this year's playoff field includes Montour, which has a 7-14 record, and Steel Valley, which is 6-12.

"I think we lost to Ambridge twice by six and 10 points, but we didn't go to the [WPIAL] playoffs," said Durham.

He went on to play at Duquesne and is now an associate athletic director there. The 1967 Aliquippa team also included Durham's brother, Dwight Kenner, who played at Kent State, and John Lindsey, who played at Memphis.

Advertise with us

"Maybe our best player was Chris Peacock, who went to a junior college [for academic reasons]," Durham said. "But I would've loved to have the opportunity to get in the playoffs like a lot of teams do now. I would've loved to have the opportunity to play Ambridge a third time. Or get in the state playoffs that year and play Schenley and Kenny Durrett, whom we had read about all year. ... But we didn't win our section title."

Finishing strong

In 1978, the WPIAL started accepting more than section champions for the playoffs. Since that time, a non-section boys' champion has won a WPIAL title 28 times. Here are the teams that have done it:

Geibel (1980), New Castle (1982), Rochester (1983), Beaver Falls (1984, '94), Latrobe (1985), Blackhawk (1986), Penn Hills (1987, 2000), Neshannock (1987), Clairton (1990, '91, 2006), Sto-Rox (1991, '92), Farrell (1992), Duquesne (1993), Highlands (1995).

Cornell (2000), Brownsville (2001), Chartiers Valley (2001), Union (2003), Mt. Lebanon (2006), Moon (2006), Bethel Park (2007), West Allegheny (2007), Blackhawk (2008), Central Catholic (2008).

Advertise with us

Thirty years ago, there were only three classifications and the playoff field included only 38 teams. Forty years ago, there were only two classifications and 21 teams were in the playoffs.

For several years in the 1970s, almost the entire tournament was played at the Civic Arena. Now, the games are played at high school venues until the championship games, which will be played this year at the Palumbo Center.

But the biggest change in the WPIAL playoffs over the years has been the addition of teams that didn't win their section titles.

"When I was a junior, we tied Farrell for the section and had to have a one-game playoff and we lost. We couldn't beat Sam Iacino," Durham said. "So we didn't go to the playoffs that year, either."

Point Park basketball coach Bob Rager was a junior on Munhall's 1967-68 team that went 20-2 but didn't make the WPIAL playoffs because it finished second to Duquesne in the section.

Advertise with us

"I think there was more emphasis placed on winning the section back then," Rager said. "The competition was really intense for the section, and there were some great rivalries.

"But I think it kind of works both ways. I think the intensity in section back then was good. But now, more teams get to the playoffs and more kids get to play more games. Is that bad? I don't think so. I think it's good for more kids to get a chance to get into playoff games because the best thing for kids is to play more games.

"The negative side is a team can come into the playoffs now with a 9-15 record and upset someone. But did that 9-15 team really have the right to do that by the way they played in the regular season?"

Durham is glad that teams besides the section champion go to the playoffs nowadays.

"But I think taking four from each section is a little too many," Durham said. "Maybe take two. If you take two, you're talking about good, quality teams who have had a good year."

Advertise with us

Chartiers Valley coach Tim McConnell has won 11 section titles in his 16 years as coach and believes section championships still carry plenty of meaning.

"You go to most gyms and you'll see banners on the wall for section championships, so absolutely it still means something," he said. "It shows you're the best at something. You get a plaque. It's a pride thing."

But McConnell also doesn't mind four teams making the playoffs from each section. In 2001, his team finished tied for third in its section but came on to win the WPIAL Class AAAA title.

"Taking four from each section is OK," he said. "It's not like football. Basketball you can play two playoff games a week, so taking four from each section doesn't make the playoffs too long."

Washington coach Ron Faust knows a thing or two about winning section titles. He has won 16 in his 28 years with the Little Prexies but believes the value of section titles is different at every school. Eleven WPIAL schools have never won a section title.

Advertise with us

"I was just telling our kids that in our gymnasium we have banners indicating WPIAL championships and state championships," Faust said. "But we don't have anything up for sections. I think what happened was during our real glory years here [1980s], we got so used to winning those sections that we just didn't honor them much.

"I think people need to understand that winning one of those sections is not always easy. ... The thing that gets me is I'll see people walking around wearing T-shirts that say they've made the playoffs so many years. But in some sections, as long as you're breathing, you almost make the playoffs. I'm not sure what credibility there is in just making the playoffs in some sections."