Bats, already reeling and in some cases endangered due to deadly white-nose syndrome, are facing new stresses from shale gas development companies that could impact their long-term survival.
Nine shale gas companies have asked the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service for a 50-year “incidental take permit” that would allow them to impact already decimated bat populations while drilling gas and oil wells, operating compressor stations and installing pipelines throughout Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia.

PG graphic: Bat populations plummet
(Click image for larger version)
If approved, the take permit would be the longest and largest in area ever issued in the eastern U.S., and would streamline application of federal Endangered Species Act and Fish and Wildlife Service regulations protecting five bat species: the endangered Indiana bat, the threatened northern long-eared bat, the little brown bat, the eastern small-footed bat, and the tri-colored bat.
According to 2015 Pennsylvania Game Commission survey data, each of those species has experienced double-digit population declines of between 99.5 percent and 36.8 percent since 2008, when white-nose syndrome — caused by a mysterious fungus that awakens bats from hibernation early and leaves white smudges around their noses — swept through the state.
Although the energy companies say approval of the take permit and an accompanying multi-state “habitat conservation plan” would provide for more coordinated long-term planning to minimize bat mortality, environmental organizations say the proposed permit amounts to piling on for bat species already knocked down and nearly out.
“This would be a huge deal because we are dealing with species in a precipitous decline,” said Jared Margolis, an attorney with the Center for Biological Diversity, a national nonprofit conservation organization headquartered in Tucson, Ariz. “I don’t see how it could be biologically defensible. Even without the drilling and energy development we don’t know if these species will survive.”
The Fish and Wildlife Service has only just begun to act on the take permit request, holding five public “scoping” meetings this week to gather information and ideas about how to focus a required environmental impact study. The first of those meetings is at the Chartiers Township Community Center, tonight, and the scoping comment period ends Dec. 27.
Mylea Bayless, senior director for U.S. and Canada conservation at Bat Conservation International, said her organization intends to submit written comments and provide continuing feedback to ensure any permit provides full protections for the bats.
“We are concerned about those populations and there are actions by the industry we will want to take a close look at and provide recommendations to reduce their impacts,” Ms. Bayless said.
Gas well drilling, operation of compressor stations and construction of pipelines in rural areas can produce noise, light pollution and fragment forested areas used by bat maternity colonies and as roosting sites. The Endangered Species Act protects listed endangered or threatened species by prohibiting or restricting habitat disruption, but take permits can relax those restrictions.
Linda Robertson, a spokeswoman for EQT, one of the nine firms requesting the permit, released a statement saying the habitat conservation plan would provide “more efficient and concise guidelines” for Endangered Species Act compliance.
“The primary goal is to minimize and mitigate any potential adverse impacts to the species,” the statement said. “With clearly established and predictable protocol, we will be better prepared to factor in the conservation of these bats during the planning process for long-term natural gas development.”
Joe Horvath, a spokesman for The Williams Companies Inc., another member of the energy company coalition, released a statement saying the proposed permit and plan would provide certainty, minimize delays due to regulatory review, and allow companies to perform predetermined mitigation measures to minimize impacts to the bats.
“This is win-win, as it gives the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service the ability to provide more adequate review coverage for projects. For industry applicants electing to exercise this HCP, it provides more predictability around timing and necessary mitigation efforts through the threatened and endangered species impact review process,” the statement said.
Pamela Shellenberger, a USFW biologist, said the service is in discussions with the companies to narrow the area and time frame for the conservation plan and take permit, but allowed that it presents an opportunity for more comprehensive planning and mitigation.
“Fifty years is certainly a long permit time for the proposed activities,” Ms. Shellenberger said. “The companies want that because their facilities and infrastructure will last that long, but there’s also a lot of uncertainty about the technology advances we’ll see and their impact.
“They’ve also asked for the entirety of each state and we’re trying to narrow that down, and hopefully minimize the impact on those species.”
But Vernon Haltom, with Coal River Mountain Watch, an environmental organization in West Virginia, took a harder line, saying the companies’ proposal “seeks to eliminate protections for these species for generations.”
“To approve the permit flies in the face of common sense,” he said. “The regulations are in place to protect species that need all the help they can get.”
Other members of the company coalition seeking the incidental taking permit are: Antero Resources Corporation; Ascent Resources, LLC; Chesapeake Energy Corporation; EnLink Midstream L.P.; MarkWest Energy Partners, L.P., MPLX L.P; Marathon Petroleum Corporation; Rice Energy, Inc.; Southwestern Energy Company.
Tonight’s scoping meeting is scheduled for 5 to 7 p.m. at the Chartiers Township Community Center, 2013 Community Center Drive, Houston, PA 15342
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.