An array of stricter environmental regulations for Pennsylvania shale gas drilling will take effect today, opening a new phase of legal challenges to the rules after a punishing five-year effort to get them published.

The state Department of Environmental Protection’s new regulations update requirements for above-ground operations at oil and gas well sites for the first time since 2001 and reflect heightened scrutiny of the industry since Marcellus Shale drilling revolutionized natural gas production in Pennsylvania.

In a statement, Acting DEP Secretary Patrick McDonnell said the rules “create some of the most protective regulations in the nation and ensure safe development of this important resource.”

Oil and gas trade groups have already signaled that they plan to file lawsuits to challenge some of the standards, which they consider excessively burdensome and expensive without substantially improving environmental protection.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association executive director Dan Weaver said the industry “has been consistent in identifying significant legal problems with these regulations, yet the department has refused to change even the most glaring and obvious errors and overreaches.”

Major changes include new procedures for shale gas companies to screen for protected public resources and underground hazards around their proposed well sites before drilling; new waste handling and spill cleanup standards; the elimination of most pits and new construction standards for large fluid holding ponds.

Some of the changes were made to implement the state’s 2012 oil and gas law, known as Act 13, and others fill gaps that regulators found as they enforced older standards that predated the technologies used in modern shale drilling and hydraulic fracturing.

Updates to Chapter 78a, as the shale gas regulations are now called, were posted online Friday and published in today’s edition of the Pennsylvania Bulletin.

Marcellus Shale Coalition president David Spigelmyer said his organization is still reviewing the final publication, but he said the regulations “will cost Pennsylvania job creators nearly $2 billion annually while many of the most costly requirements provide little-to-no environmental benefits.” He said coalition members will continue to satisfy or exceed the requirements established by Act 13.

Advertise with us

DEP’s cost analysis came in much lower and estimated that the rules could cost the industry as much as $73.5 million initially and as much as $31 million annually after that.

The package of rules is half of what the department originally proposed. Gov. Tom Wolf signed a bill in June to drop planned updates to regulations for the state’s traditional oil and gas industry, which generally has smaller operations at shallower wells. Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, signed the bill as a compromise to stop a push by the Legislature to block publication of the shale rules as well.

That skirmish ended John Quigley’s tenure as DEP secretary in May, after he sent environmental groups a coarse email chastising them for not defending the rules more forcefully.

Despite industry efforts to block it, the Department of Environmental Protection maintained a section in the final version of Chapter 78a that allows regulators to put conditions on shale gas permits to minimize disruptions to public resources like parks, playgrounds and habitats for protected species.

Wexford-based PIOGA contends that a 2013 state Supreme Court decision eliminated that section of the law. In an appeal filed last week, the trade group asked the high court to stop DEP from enforcing it.

Advertise with us

The Legislature is considering bills and amendments that would ease some of the new standards by requiring less frequent waste reporting, less stringent construction standards for freshwater holding ponds and more time for well site restoration without companies needing to ask DEP for an extension.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.