When the idea of turning the old Connelley Trade School building into a space where universities and companies can partner in research was first bandied about, Greg Reed immediately thought about the IRS.
Mr. Reed, who studies electric power systems at the University of Pittsburgh, works in a building built with tax-exempt bonds, and that comes at a price.
It means he can’t get paid by a company to work on its problems in his lab. He can’t help to commercialize technology funded by the private sector. And he can’t give a corporate sponsor a discount on the intellectual property that same company paid Mr. Reed to develop.
None of those restrictions would apply at what is now called the Energy Innovation Center in the Hill District, where Mr. Reed and other researchers from the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University are building their labs alongside their industry partners.
Yes, it’s three miles away from campus. But it’s closer in mission to where both universities want to be — more accessible to industries’ opportunities and their money.
“When we go off campus, that aspect of tax exemptions, all those rules don’t necessarily apply in the same way,” Mr. Reed said. “A good example is fee for service.”
Mr. Reed’s lab on campus has a bunch of gadgets that could help companies test and certify their electronic components. At least two companies have asked if they could pay to use his equipment to do just that. The answer is no.
When he started talking to companies about his planned capabilities at the Energy Innovation Center lab, they asked the same question.
“And I said, ‘Yes!’”
The heightened interest in working with industry stems from a shift in culture and funding.
Universities typically fund around 10 percent of their research with money from commercial interests, said Garry Fedder, CMU’s vice provost for research.
“We kind of think we should be able to do more than that,” he said, in part because it speeds up the process of translating academic research into real world applications, and in part because federal funding for research has been tapering over the past decade.
“I think most of the research universities are looking at where (there) is the potential for growth. There isn’t really room for growth in federal funding,” he said. “On the corporate side, one would think there’s potential.”
CMU has been leasing space off campus to accommodate some industry projects, but it’s not much, Mr. Fedder said.
Recently, universities such as Yale, Northwestern and the University of Illinois elected to build new facilities with taxable bonds to give themselves more flexibility in working with companies.
“Here, at a university, we’re basically a federated set of entrepreneurs,” Mr. Fedder said. “It’s the Wild West. We want to be open, collegial, and innovate, but you have all these legal issues.”
A lot of researchers working at Pitt and CMU have horror stories about how the tax code or intellectual property negotiations foiled a potentially fruitful partnership with a company.
Mr. Fedder recalled a negotiation a few years ago involving a multinational oil company whose technical staff had spent the better part of a year brainstorming research ideas with CMU faculty before involving the lawyers.
“It’s a win-win technically,” he said, but “we got to the point where the company just had to walk away because [both sides] just couldn’t get it done,” he said.
Mr. Reed, who advocates for and partakes in industry partnerships, said he’s still in the convincing stage with some of his colleagues.
“This is new for Pitt,” he said. “There’s going to be a learning curve.”
One person who needed no convincing is Chancellor Patrick Gallagher, Mr. Reed said.
Six months after he took the helm at Pitt, Mr. Gallagher wrote a memo on commercialization calling on the university to lean on its relationships with businesses “both for research support and for collaboration in research activities.”
To pursue those corporate connections, Mr. Gallagher created a new role — vice chancellor for economic partnerships — and hired Rebecca Bagley to fill it in March 2015.
For years, universities like Pitt were so focused on racking up their government research grants that they built their physical and intellectual infrastructure around that, Ms. Bagley said.
The move to attract more corporate attention is “holistic,” she said, but it’s “also the realization that as the industry does less and less R&D, there’s an increased role for us.”
The biggest opportunities are in pharmaceuticals and biotech, she said, but energy is a close third.
“There’s both a shift in industry, in how they’re doing R&D, and in universities — where they get their funds. We’re really trying to be at the cutting edge of how we take advantage of it,” she said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.