John Pippy, CEO of Pennsylvania’s main coal advocacy group, PA Coal Council, said he was doubly pleased on Wednesday.

After the U.S. Supreme Court put on hold the nation’s first regulation aimed at fighting carbon pollution, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection backed away from its ambitious goal to have a compliance plan ready by September.

On Tuesday, the Supreme Court granted a stay for the federal Clean Power Plan while its merits are debated in court. The next day, the state DEP said it would follow the regulation as it makes its way through the legal system.

“DEP is still preparing a plan to present to EPA once the legal issues are resolved,” said Neil Shader, a spokesman for the department. “Pennsylvania will continue planning and engagement with stakeholders on the Clean Power Plan, pending final decision of this issue by the Supreme Court.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Shader said if the matter is resolved before September, the DEP’s compliance plan will be ready, but the legal process is likely to take longer than that and could stretch into 2018.

A coalition of 27 states and industry groups are headlining a lawsuit challenging the rules and that challenge is likely to make its way back to the Supreme Court for the final say.

Read More

The delay creates another layer of uncertainty for everyone from the struggling coal companies and power plants endangered by stricter environmental regulations to the renewable energy and energy efficiency advocates buoyed by them.

“All of the players, no matter where they are in the power sector, needed to wait to see what states were going to do to comply,” said Cheryl Wilson, an energy policy analyst with Bloomberg Intelligence. “Under the original schedule, they would have had an answer within the next few years. Now they won’t have that.”

Pennsylvania was among a handful of states that didn’t oppose or support the Clean Power Plan in court, but the DEP had already begun its stakeholder engagement process by holding listening sessions on the regulation in different parts of the state.

Advertise with us

The Clean Power Plan gives states individual carbon reduction targets but allows each state to come up with its own tailored plan to comply. The first reductions would be mandated by 2022.

Under the plan, Pennsylvania would need to reduce its emissions by 33 percent from 2012 levels by 2030.

Analysts and even coal advocates such as Mr. Pippy agreed that there aren’t likely to be any immediate market implications from the ruling. Coal prices are still getting beaten by cheap natural gas and bankruptcies are rampant in the sector.

“The Clean Power Plan was always more of a long-term signal to the industry,” Ms. Wilson said.

It’s also one of many environmental regulations that pressure the power sector and coal.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pippy said the DEP’s commitment to produce a compliance plan by September was premature and “arbitrary” given how much is still in flux with the rule.

Meanwhile, volunteers for environmental advocacy group PennEnvironment plan to serenade Gov. Tom Wolf with “climate-themed love songs” on Friday and parade across three cities with Valentines asking the governor, “will you be our climate sweetheart?”

The spectacle was organized on Wednesday to thank Mr. Wolf “for his commitment to moving forward with a strong Pennsylvania Clean Power Plan.”

FirstEnergy Corp., the Akron-based parent of West Penn Power and operator of Bruce Mansfield coal-fired power plan and Beaver Valley Nuclear plant, said it supports the Supreme Court’s move, which came out the day after FirstEnergy launched its new media campaign to “demonstrate the company’s commitment to a cleaner energy future.”

Company spokeswoman Jennifer Young said FirstEnergy would still work with states if they choose to develop compliance plans while the rule is stuck in court, but said it won’t have a handle of how the regulation will impact its operations until the state plans are approved by the EPA.

Advertise with us

Tom Sanzillo, director of finance for the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, a group that promotes a move away from fossil fuels, considers the Supreme Court decision “a procedural blip.”

He’s seen industry advocates fight other environmental regulations and says the pattern is always the same. “They win concessions and they win delays, but they never win on the environmental issues because they won’t go away,” he said.

To Pennsylvania, Mr. Sanzillo says keep calm and carry on. “This is going to get implemented at one point or another, and they should just move forward with what they’re doing,” he said.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com.