In a roundabout way, a win for uneconomic coal plants in Ohio might be a win for Pennsylvania wind.

Akron-based FirstEnergy Corp. is asking Ohio’s Public Utility Commission to allow its otherwise unprofitable coal and nuclear power plants to sign a long-term agreement with its affiliated utility, shifting the risk of operating the plants from the company to utility ratepayers.

AEP Co Inc. has proposed a similar deal for six of its coal plants, arguing a long-term power purchase agreement would benefit customers by ensuring a reliable power supply is available for years and protecting against price volatility.

That’s what Michael Speershneider, chief permitting and public policy officer at Strip District-based EverPower Wind Holdings has been saying for years — not about coal, but about wind.

Advertise with us

“When I read what AEP and FirstEnergy wrote in Ohio, I said, ‘We could have written that,’” he said.

Wind farm developers need long-term power purchase agreements to guarantee there will be a market for their product. That’s how they can prove to financial backers that an upfront capital investment will pay off.

But the last long-term power purchase agreement that EverPower signed with a utility in Pennsylvania was in 2009 — a 22-year deal with FirstEnergy worth about $90 million.

That’s because in a deregulated electricity market, “There’s no natural buyer for the product,” Mr. Speerschneider said.

Utilities don’t own power plants and they don’t make money off the kilowatts transmitted through their distribution lines. Many customers in Pennsylvania have entered into supply contracts with competitive suppliers and those that haven’t get electricity from the utility, which buys it from the grid at market rates.

Advertise with us

This dynamic leaves little room for considerations such as price volatility and reliability, FirstEnergy and AEP told Ohio regulators.

It’s also what renewable energy advocates argued a few years ago when the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission was examining how utilities should deal with their default customers — those that don’t choose a competitive supplier.

Bruce Burcat, executive director of the Delaware-based Mid-Atlantic Renewable Energy Coalition, was one of the voices advocating for utilities to be able to get at least part of their default electricity supply from long-term contracts.

Ultimately, the commission opted for much shorter procurement periods.

Since then, the matter hasn’t come before the Pennsylvania PUC. The makeup of the commission has changed since that discussion three years ago, Mr. Burcat said. As have energy markets.

Advertise with us

Over the past several years, environmental regulations and cheap natural gas have pushed dozens of coal plants into premature closure. The polar vortex temporarily spiked electricity prices for consumers in the Northeast and came close to blacking out the grid, according to PJM Interconnection Inc., which manages the flow of electricity to 13 states including Pennsylvania.

These same considerations, cited in FirstEnergy’s and AEP’s arguments before Ohio regulators in favor of propping up uneconomic power plants, are used by wind advocates.

“We’ve been arguing, if you want to give them contracts, give us contracts,” said Jim Spencer, EverPower’s CEO.

“Or go a step further and open it up for bid,” Mr. Speerschnieder said.

That’s what Mr. Burcat’s organization is trying to hash out in the AEP case in Ohio. He wants the public utility commission to tack on a requirement for AEP to procure 1,000 megawatts of renewable energy through a competitive process.

Advertise with us

FirstEnergy last week put forward a settlement it has reached with a number of parties that previously opposed its application, including the staff of the public utility commission in Ohio. It includes a small, and wind advocates say unenforceable, provision for 100 megawatts of solar or wind.

Mr. Burcat called it “window dressing.”

If the FirstEnergy settlement is approved as is, Mr. Burcat said he wouldn’t necessarily regard that as a good sign for renewable energy.

“But I will say, as much as we dislike the FirstEnergy case, it would present communication from the commission that long term contracts” are both legal and beneficial, he said.

“If they’re allowing them for dirty coal plants, then there should certain be a push from our perspective to allow these for clean wind energy,” he said.

Advertise with us

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.