As the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency gears up to drop the acceptable ozone pollution limit across the country and industry trade groups forecast massive economic consequences, it’s hard to predict how Pennsylvania will fare.
For the third time in 18 years, the EPA plans to lower the ozone limit to something in the range of 65 parts per billion to 70 parts per billion. It is currently set at 75 parts per billion, a level that 17 counties in Pennsylvania don’t meet.
Decreasing the acceptable level would plunge 16 more counties into “nonattainment.” But doing so may not have much of a practical impact on Pennsylvania businesses.
That’s because all of Pennsylvania is treated as a “nonattainment” area by virtue of its inclusion in a group of 12 northeastern states that waft ozone pollution across hundreds of miles.
Ground-level ozone is formed when nitrogen oxides (NOx) and volatile organic compounds (VOC) are exposed to sunlight. It can be carried long distances in the wind. In the early 1990s, federal regulators designated an ozone transport region and required all the states within it to draft plans to reduce pollution.
States typically do that by requiring new or modified pollution sources to install emission controls and offset their pollution by buying emission reduction credits. Those are generated when another polluter shuts down or lowers its output through retrofits.
Read More
That’s the same scheme the federal government uses to permit new polluters in nonattainment zones. So from a permitting perspective, a major emission source in Warren County whose ozone levels are below the current threshold has to go through the same steps as a major source in Allegheny County where ozone levels are higher than the EPA limit.
If the EPA lowers the acceptable ozone limit, new emitters in states outside the transport region — such as neighboring West Virginia and Ohio — would likely see stricter permitting requirements than they have today.
“In Pennsylvania, I don’t think it’s going to matter much,” said Michael Winek, shareholder at Babst Calland law firm who helps business navigate through emission requirements.
The kinds of Pennsylvania businesses that are subject to the most stringent emission controls and offsets are a small fraction of industry in the state.
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection typically issues about five permits a year to new or modified facilities whose emissions go above a threshold that qualifies them as a major source. Think: Shell ethane cracker.
With the new rules, “There will be no new obligation for industry that wasn’t already there,” said John Slade, a senior consultant with ALL4 Inc., which helps companies with air permitting.
At least not at first. The new ozone standards could compel Pennsylvania to reconsider other requirements, he said, such as what it would regard as cost-effective emission controls and what kind of technology each industry would be expected to adopt.
For example, as part of its plan to reduce smog, Pennsylvania requires vehicles to pass emission states, while neighboring Ohio has no such mandate.
“It’s something industry’s been through before,” Mr. Slade said. “Is it a burden? Yeah. Is it a burden that can’t be dealt with? No.”
Still, the Center for Regulatory Solutions, a project of the Small Business and Entrepreneurship Council whose mission is to “educate the American public about the burdens and consequences of over-regulation on the economy,” predicts dire consequences.
In a 100-page report, the organization quotes business leaders and politicians urging the EPA not to toughen a standard that is already not being met by many counties. The regulation “poses an urgent threat to the Pennsylvania economy, Pennsylvania employers and Pennsylvania workers,” the report states.
The sentiment is echoed by the National Association of Manufacturers, which has opposed every EPA ozone reduction since 1997 and has claimed for years that technology doesn't exist to keep driving emissions lower.
"There’s just no low hanging fruit left," said Greg Bertelsen, director of energy and resources policy at the national association of manufacturers, echoing a talking point from a 2007 study by the another manufacturing trade group fighting the 2008 revision to the ozone standard, which lowered the limit from 80 parts per billion to the current 75.
"Inevitably, the smaller guys will have to go into the fold if states are forced to go lower," he said. "The fact of the matter is, the lower you get, the more expensive the rule becomes.
The argument resonates with many businesses who view the EPA’s shifting standards as a moving target.
“One of the frustrating things that my clients deal with is they spend lots of money and you think you’re good, and you’ve improved air quality,” and then the standard changes again, Mr. Winek said. “[They say] ‘I’m willing to spend millions of dollars to put on these controls, but can I get assurance that it’s all I have to do?’ The answer is no.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.