Appalachian coal companies would be the hardest hit by a proposed federal rule designed to protect streams from damage during mining operations.

The Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement on Thursday unveiled its long-awaited stream protection rule that may change how surface and longwall mine operators treat water resources.

The rule calls for mine operators to measure stream conditions before, during and after mining and to restore them to their pre-activity conditions. It also establishes a national standard of “material damage for hydrologic balance outside the permit area,” and requires companies to restore the land around the stream to its original state.

The contents of the 1,238-page document already have ignited the passions of environmental advocates and politicians. They likely will elicit robust attendance at five public hearings the agency will host later this summer. One of them will be in Pittsburgh. A schedule has not been released yet.

Advertise with us

Economic impacts of the rule will be “relatively minor,” Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell told reporters during a conference call Thursday afternoon. However, she estimated that a few hundred people will lose their jobs, many in Central Appalachia.

Most of the compliance costs, as well, will be felt in the Central Appalachian region, which includes parts of West Virginia, Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee.

Coal prices and electricity prices also are expected to increase as a result of the rule, officials said, but by less than 1 percent.

The Citizens Coal Council, a coalition of citizens from coalfield communities, has been hoping the new rule would address stream impacts from longwall mining and establish a national definition of what constitutes material damage to water sources.

“My heart’s racing right now because we’ve been waiting so long for this to come out,” said Aimee Erickson, the council’s executive director, who said a stream in the back yard of her house has turned into a pool when the area subsided after longwall mining in 2008.

Advertise with us

In Pennsylvania, mine operators are supposed to restore or replace water supplies damaged by longwall mining-related subsidence, but a recent report commissioned by the state to examine the impact of subsidence between 2008 and 2013 shows that requirement isn’t always enforced.

“Subsidence from longwall mining continues to affect base flow in affected streams, despite the requirements contained in the current regulations,” the proposed federal rule said.

It took half a dozen years, a name change and fierce industry opposition for the rule to emerge in its current form.

Ten state agencies originally signed on as collaborators with the federal government, but six withdrew from the process claiming they weren’t being heard. Pennsylvania was never among them.

Appalachian coal companies already are stressed by oversupply and competition from cheap natural gas that, for the first time, overtook coal as the leading source of power generation in the United States.

Advertise with us

Virginia-based Alpha Natural Resources started the day with rumors of a bankruptcy and ended it by losing its spot on the New York Stock Exchange. The company’s stock was at 23 cents per share when trading halted.

Walter Energy, an Alabama-based metallurgical coal miner, filed for bankruptcy earlier this week. Cecil-based Consol Energy Inc., whose initial public offering of its thermal coal spinout came in below expectations, announced earlier in the week it was cutting its workforce by more than 10 percent.

The coal industry also is fighting regulations that would force power plants to curb air pollution.

On Wednesday, the Sierra Club, a national environmental organization, celebrated the announcement of the 200th coal power plant closing since 2010.

While the Pennsylvania Coal Alliance declined to comment until it could digest the heavy volume, the National Mining Association released a fiery statement calling on Congress to block the rule, calling it “the latest in a series of costly and unnecessary regulations from an administration that appears determined to destroy coal mining communities.”

Advertise with us

“This is a rule in search of a problem,” the organization’s president and CEO Hal Quinn said in the statement. “What OSM has made transparent is the need for Congress to bridle an agency and a rule that is more about extending its bureaucratic reach than improving environmental performance.”

Those sentiments already have ears in Congress. Last month, Rep. Bill Johnson, R-Ohio, pushed through legislation to take $2 million out of the agency’s budget that he argued would restrain the Office of Surface Mining from promulgating this rule.

The stream protection rule “is intentionally designed to shut down all surface mining and a significant section of underground mining in the Appalachian region,” Rep. Alex Mooney, R-W.Va., said in support of Mr. Johnson’s effort.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.