Behind closed doors, electric utilities grumble about Pennsylvania’s requirements to reduce energy demand, said Pennsylvania Public Utility Commissioner Robert Powelson.

He doesn’t fault them for it.

“They don’t like that we’re asking them to go to their customers and say use less of my product,” he said. “I get that.”

Saving energy means cutting revenue, because what a company charges to deliver electricity is based on how much of it travels through its system. That’s how it’s always been, before energy efficient appliances and renewable energy installations challenged the model.

Advertise with us

Now, Mr. Powelson is challenging the industry to evolve and embrace what’s known in the utility business as decoupling. One way to do that is to base electric rates on the cost of operating the distribution system, regardless of how much energy travels through it.

Decoupling would help utilities cope with customers who put up solar panels and pull less electricity from the grid but still require the utility to maintain the electric lines running to their homes, said Rob Altenburg, director of PennFuture Energy Center. Utilities could structure their rates to reflect that actual cost of maintaining their infrastructure, regardless of how much it is used.

Nearly a decade ago, the PUC charged a working group with studying the issue of decoupling. The result was a mixed bag, with environmental groups recommending it, consumer advocates opposing it and the utilities wanting to leave the door open without any state mandates.

Mr. Powelson addressed decoupling, in a recent public letter, in the context of a related debate about energy efficiency — how to make it easier for customers to finance energy saving measures such as home retrofits.

He advocated that customers be allowed to borrow the upfront cost of such measures against their future energy savings. The concept, called on-bill financing, means customers can amortize the cost of their energy efficiency projects over the time it takes for the money they save from using less energy to net out their investment.

Advertise with us

Those payments would be included in their utility payments each month. It could be the utility lending the upfront capital or a third party — the latter is then referred to as on-bill repayment. But the key is that customers have a simple way of financing energy efficiency efforts that doesn’t require shelling out a large sum upfront.

The financing method is available in some 20 states. But when the Pennsylvania PUC last explored on-bill financing in 2012, state utilities, then as now, were less than enthusiastic about the concept.

“Neither utilities nor ratepayers are appropriate sources of funding, and neither should serve as banks or financial institutions,” FirstEnergy Corp. wrote to the PUC. The Ohio-based energy company and corporate parent of West Penn Power said the concept is “fraught with legal and practical complications.”

Duquesne Light said the same, claiming on-bill financing would “increase the cost and complexity” of its energy efficiency and conservation program.

Mr. Powelson called utilities’ reasons “Debbie Downer arguments — 10 million reasons to find a reason not to do something.”

Advertise with us

Gas utilities in the state have embraced a form of on-bill financing that allows customers to finance the cost of hooking up their homes to a gas pipeline through a charge on their bill. But that’s an easier pill to swallow, Mr. Powelson noted, as it gives gas companies more sales, not less. It will be difficult for electric utilities to buy into the concept without cutting the link between their sales and revenue, he said.

Hence, his call for decoupling.

“Personally I think PA needs to come out of the stone ages here,” he said.

Since issuing his call to rewire the way utilities charge for their services, the commissioner has gotten a few supportive responses, including an enthusiastic one from Columbia Gas, but none from the electric utilities. And he’s not expecting any movement on the issue soon because, as Mr. Powelson likes to say, “utilities take two hours to watch ‘60 Minutes.’” In other words, everything in the industry moves slowly, especially major changes that challenge how utilities have functioned for a hundred years.

“I don’t think anybody is knocking my door down at this point,” Mr. Powelson said.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.