Matthew Patsky, CEO of Boston-based Trillium Asset Management, has begun to notice he has a kind of shadow when he speaks at town hall meetings and statehouses on the topic of shedding fossil fuel stocks from investment portfolios.
An oil industry representative is usually not far behind, armed with an anti-divestment speech.
That’s a huge deal, Mr. Patsky said. “It means we’re getting under their skin and that’s good.”
He’ll be the first to admit that after more than two decades of managing fossil-free fuel portfolios, Trillium hasn’t hurt oil company profits one bit. It’s likely none of the divestment campaigns that have gained momentum since the climate activist group 350.org launched its international push in 2011 have done anything to dent the finances of fossil fuel firms or sent them soul searching about their impact on the world.
Divestment, at least on the current scale, isn’t about that, Mr. Patsky said. Oil, coal and gas companies aren’t even the target audience, he continued.
It’s the policy makers. They have the power to sway markets on a much larger scale by issuing regulations that make it difficult to burn fossil fuels, ending tax benefits or entering into international agreements that would penalize carbon pollution.
Oil industry representatives now trail Mr. Patsky on his public appearances because they sense that politicians are perking up to the message of divestment, he said.
The fossil fuel divestment movement is modeled on the effort that urged institutions to dump companies doing business in South Africa during the apartheid era.
The fossil fuel push was conceived by 350.org — the number refers to the maximum concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere that some scientists say would keep at bay the more disastrous effects of climate change. Limiting CO2 to the 350 parts per million threshold would mean keeping 80 percent of currently known fossil fuel reserves in the ground, according to the organization.
The Fossil Free campaign asks universities, foundations, governments and individuals to divest holdings in the top 200 fossil fuel companies, as ranked by their reserves. Those who take up the challenge should be fossil fuel-free within five years.
Several regional companies or companies with significant operations in Western Pennsylvania are on the divestment list, including Cecil-based Consol Energy Inc., which is among the top 50 coal and oil and gas reserve holders; Downtown-based oil and gas producer EQT Corp.; and Texas firms Range Resources and Cabot Oil & Gas, whose Marcellus operations are among the most prolific in the region.
Today and Saturday, the movement plans its biggest push, with simultaneous events all over the world.
During a rally planned for Schenley Plaza today and a teach-in at William Pitt Union in the afternoon, divestment advocates plan to put pressure on the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University, the City of Pittsburgh and PNC Financial Group.
A group urging divestment has already made the pitch at the city’s pension board meeting, said spokesman Tim McNulty, and was told by the finance director that he would consider the request.
At Pitt, university officials have had “some preliminary conversations with some students on this topic,” according to Kenneth Service, vice chancellor for communications. “The entire issue of our nation’s dependence on fossil fuels is a complex one, involving many interrelated issues, and it is far from clear how divestiture would affect this matter,” he added.
There have been a number of studies, sponsored by either pro or anti divestment advocates, that show how investment portfolios without fossil fuels overperform or underperform the overall market.
The latest was released this week by the Independent Petroleum Association of America. It claimed that universities that divest stand to lose billions of dollars.
Having done this for 25 years, Mr. Patsky is more than just skeptical of such claims. He said he has decades of evidence showing that a properly designed portfolio, with or without energy, follows the market benchmarks.
Five years ago, less than 10 percent of Trillium’s assets under management were fossil fuel-free. Today, more than half of its $2.2 billion has no exposure to fossil fuel companies.
The fact that the petroleum trade group took time to commission the study is telling, Mr. Patsky said. He attributes its attention to the success of the Fossil Free movement.
On its website, Fossil Free claims it has gotten divestment commitments from hundreds of institutions. Its most notable wins have been Stanford University, which agreed to divest of its coal stocks, and the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, whose fortune was built by the Standard Oil.
The New School in New York City said this month that it would not only divest of its fossil fuel interests but also work to revamp its curriculum to be more focused on sustainability and carbon awareness.
Many other institutions have considered and rejected the divestment call, such as Harvard University, Cornell University and Yale University. Harvard’s President Drew Faust called it dishonest to use fossil fuels and divest of them, penalizing not the companies that make them but the university’s substantial endowment that she believed would suffer for the loss.
“Generally, as shareholders, I believe we should favor engagement over withdrawal,” she wrote in October.
Shanna Cleveland, senior manager at Ceres, a nonprofit coalition of investors that pushes for sustainable business policies, said both are useful options.
Ms. Cleveland heads the Boston organization’s Carbon Asset Risk Initiative, which is focused on getting public companies to assess and disclose the risk that a carbon-constrained world would pose to their ability to develop and sell their reserves.
While much of the divestment talk is focused on moral responsibility, Ms. Cleveland’s work touches on the central financial premise behind the divestment push— the idea of stranded assets.
Natural resource companies are valued by investors based on their reserves. Besides spending money to develop those reserves, oil, gas, and coal companies invest heavily in replenishing the pipeline of these assets.
Regulations, public opinion and market forces could stifle their ability to capitalize on those reserves. “To the extent that companies hold a large number of reserves, the portion that they can’t burn would turn into a stranded asset,” Ms. Cleveland said.
Now seems like a particularly fortuitous time to be making the argument, with coal and oil prices in the gutter, Naomi Klein, a writer and climate activist and director at 350.org, said in an interview with Grist.
“Fossil fuel stocks are not performing very well right now,” she told the online news site. “They won’t lose it for long, so that’s another reason to just pound away at this.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.