Most of the coal power plants operating in the U.S. today were built to run 24/7. They’re baseload — the backbone of the American grid, historically called on first by grid operators to meet demand because, until recently, they were the cheapest option.

In the past decade, two major developments have demoted these grid leaders into followers: intermittent renewables and natural gas.

And following means running more and more coal plants contrary to their original design — intermittently, with frequent start ups and power downs that put stress on components, cause more frequent outages, and shorten their life.

“We’re sort of beating the hell out of them” is how David Schmalzer, former director of fossil energy at Argonne National Laboratory, put it a recent conference of energy economists in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

“On a number of levels, people understand there’s a problem. But if I had to describe it right now, (the industry is) thrashing around looking for a solution,” he said.

Mr. Schmalzer spoke to a small group of energy market professionals at the U.S. Association of Energy Economics meeting last month. They all agreed that the impending carbon regulations from the federal Clean Power Plan, which goes into effect in 2022, will exacerbate the problem.

Operators know they’re hurting their plants by cycling, Mr. Schmalzer said at the event, but the future outlook for coal may look so bleak that it may not matter if the practice is shaving years off the end of plants’ useful life.

Imperfect market

Grid operators like Valley Forge-based PJM Interconnection Inc., which lines up electricity generation for 13 states including Pennsylvania, assess the level of demand on the grid and dispatch the lowest-cost generation first.

Advertise with us

Renewable sources like wind and solar go first. Their marginal cost — which includes fuel, pollution price and heat rate — is next to nothing.

Then nuclear, coal and natural gas battle it out for spots on the dispatch curve. Whichever plants get called last are subject to the push and pull from the grid, from changes in demand and fluctuations in wind energy.

When demand falls, these plants must lower their output or shut down. When it picks up, they ramp up.

Natural gas plants are good at cycling and have traditionally been dispatched at peak hours to fill in gaps. Now, because natural gas is cheap, they’re being called on to provide constant baseload power, leaving coal plants to cycle.

A less efficient coal plant that requires more heat and, therefore, more money to produce power, gets pushed further down the dispatch curve. That makes it more likely to be called to cycle rather than run constantly. It’s a self-fulfilling cycle.

Advertise with us

In 2014 study commissioned by PJM found that operations and maintenance costs for coal generation units is rising faster than any other metric. That’s because of the increased repair and replacement of damaged components and the time the plant is offline as a result of cycling.

The Electric Power Research Institute, a scientific and technical research organization, wrote in a 2001 report that the life of a coal plant can drop between 40 percent and 60 percent after cycling is introduced.

Donald Hanson, an energy economist with Argonne, said that while the market arrives at the lowest cost of electricity for every hour, it does so at the expense of a long-term strain on the grid.

“It’s not necessarily good for the country but that’s the market design,” he said.

Utilities take notice

Advertise with us

While cycling has increased significantly over the past five years, Akron-based FirstEnergy Corp. was formulating a strategy to deal with it as far back as the early 2000s.

Around 2003, the Akron-based parent of Bruce Mansfield Power Station in Beaver County said it was shifting its strategy away from cycling larger units, like Mansfield. Instead, it had designated a few smaller plants to chase the load so that its bigger units can avoid the efficiency, reliability and financial losses that come with cycling.

With today’s low natural gas and electricity prices, the company has to be flexible, said Don Moul, senior vice president of fossil operations and environment.

The grid sends price signals all the time. There are 5-minute price signals and week ahead price signals.

FirstEnergy can’t chase the immediate payoff with its coal plants, Mr. Moul said, but it’ll consider what prices may be a day to a week in advance and decide if and how it will run its coal units during that time.

Advertise with us

“If you see a prolonged period of low prices, you may choose to take that unit off completely,” he said.

“What you’ll find is a lot of the competitive plants’ performance is slowly degrading” because the market doesn’t fully recognize the value of coal’s reliability, he said.

“We realize that these plants right now in this market, in these low prices, they’re going to have to cycle,” he said. “We’re doing everything we can to manage it.”

Other utilities are taking notice as well.

In 2010, NRG Energy’s COO John Ragan told analysts that the company was teaching its plant operators to “become more proficient at dealing with the cycling of coal plants.”

Advertise with us

When natural gas prices plunged by more than half from 2008 to 2009, NRG’s coal plants were being crowded out by cheaper natural gas units. So the company was training its plant managers to monitor equipment during start ups to minimize the impacts on the plants.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.