Last week, the Virginia State Corporation Commission dealt a blow to a $126 million deal that would have made an out-of-state natural gas utility the owner of 25 Marcellus Shale wells in Pennsylvania.
Washington Gas, a subsidiary of Washington, D.C.-based WGL Holdings, announced in May that it had signed a 20-year deal with Energy Corp. of America, a Colorado-based oil and gas driller, for a 96 percent stake in 22 Marcellus wells in Greene County and another three wells in Clearfield. The gas produced from the wells would be delivered to Washington Gas’ customers in Virginia and the length of the deal would protect them from supply and price volatility, the company argued.
The utility was testing a year-old Virginia law that allowed utilities to invest in oil and gas assets, and recover that investment in customers’ rates.
Washington Gas’s proposal hinged on two assumptions: that the wells will produce their gas in a predictable way, and that the price of natural gas in the market will increase over time.
The staff of the Virginia State Corporation Commission opposed the application.
It argued that there’s no contingency if the wells stop producing or yield less gas than projected. It also took issue with the price forecast, which came from the U.S. Energy Information Administration’s 2015 short-term outlook.
In the end, the commission ruled, “The potential harm to customers is too great when compared to the potential benefits.”
The commission’s central issue with the proposal, however, was the risk sharing balance, or lack thereof. If something doesn’t pan out like the company projects, the ratepayers will take the heat, not the company, it said.
The case illustrates the uneasy marriage between utilities, which are highly regulated to protect consumers against risk, and oil and gas development, an industry with few regulatory limits on the amount of financial risk it can take.
“It’s not surprising that getting the two together is something of a hurdle,” said Gardner Walkup, a managing director at D.C.-based Berkley Research Group, who advises utilities on such deals.
“One thing that complicates it even a little bit further is that most of these (companies) are investing in unconventional wells,” he said.
While shale drillers have a much better success rate striking oil and gas than conventional drillers, these wells are still young — most of the wells drilled in the Marcellus, for example, are less than five years old and their production declines drastically in the first few years. While industry experts map decline curves for these wells that stretch several decades, that is still very much a projection, not a history.
That was one of the arguments made by the Virginia commission’s staff, which noted that the wells Washington Gas intends to buy into were drilled between 2011 and 2014.
That joins a litany of other unkowns and unknowables.
For example, Pennsylvania’s will-they-or-won’t-they severance tax dance places another uncertainty on the cost to get the gas out. The longer the contract, the more uncertain all these factors get. Washington Gas looked for anyone who would be interested in a shorter deal,but couldn’t find any takers, the company said.
None of that is an automatic deal-breaker, Mr. Walkup noted. But utilities need to do their research to understand the risks.
He predicted that more such deals will surface. State public utility commissions have been either outright supportive or cautiously interested, Mr. Walkup said. None have declared “an absolute no fly zone” on the matter.
More deals coming
Indeed, the appetite for these kinds of deals is growing, owing to the unique confluence of circumstances, as described by Washington Gas’s attorney Lonnie Nunley in his closing statement to the Virginia State Corporation Commission last month.
“The time to solicit, negotiate and present a plan like this one is when natural gas supplies are flush, when sellers are motivated and when prices are low,” Mr. Nunley said. “That's the environment we find ourselves in today.”
Last year, Virginia joined about a dozen other states in passing its law allowing utilities to buy oil and gas assets and bill customers for the cost, provided such deals are in the public interest and meet other qualifiers.
Unlike a long-term supply contract, which experts say would be impossible to secure these days anyway, direct investment in oil and gas allows utilities to recover a rate of return. Typically, distribution companies simply pass along the cost of the fuel they disburse without making a profit on it.
Pennsylvania has no such law and the arrangement would be impossible in the state, said Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission spokesman Nils Hagen-Frederiksen.
Florida Power and Light made a deal to buy into oil and gas development in the Woodford Shale in Oklahoma, and the state’s public utility commission allowed the company to cover the costs from ratepayers.
South Dakota-based utility Black Hills Corp. has asked regulators in South Dakota, Nebraska, Wyoming, Kansas and Iowa to do the same.
As far back as 2011, NW Natural, an Oregon utility, signed a deal with Encana Corp. and pledged to invest around $250 million to develop wells in the Jonah Field in Wyoming.
Jerry Fish, a partner at Stoel Rives LLP in Oregon, negotiated the deal for NW Natural and said the utility built in a host of protections to share the risk with the driller.
Such deals may be a departure from the cautious mandate of utilities, he said, but the tradeoff for uncertainty on the gas production side is certainty for consumers that their rates will remain predictable for the next 20 years.
“A producer isn’t going to give you a 20-year contract,” he said, not at today’s low prices. But a direct cash infusion allowing that driller to develop more wells makes the partnership attractive.
It’s not clear what will happen to the relationship between Washington Gas and Energy Corp. of America. In an earnings call with analysts on Monday, the company said it is exploring its options and stressed the commission didn’t close the case yet.
Jennifer Vieweg, corporate affairs manager for Energy Corp. of America, said the company is disappointed with the commission’s decision and feels the deal was fair and beneficial for all involved.
“At this point, we are still in discussions with (Washington Gas) about how to move forward,” she said.
The oil and gas company has explored similar deals with other utilities.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.