When it comes to green buildings, Pittsburghers can point to a series of firsts.

Big-ticket building projects over the years have pioneered — and earned recognition for — sustainable practices: the first green convention center, the first green financial institution, the first green children’s museum, to name a few.

Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Garden has achieved four of the world's most coveted green building standards, and, most recently, Chatham University’s Richland Township campus has attracted international attention for building sustainable residence halls and classrooms from the ground up.

But a report released last week by Clean Edge, a clean technology research firm based in Portland, Ore., assembles a more nuanced picture of the Pittsburgh area’s broader leadership in clean technology, particularly when it comes to green buildings.

Advertise with us

Clean Edge ranked the Pittsburgh area 25th among the top 50 largest U.S. metropolitan areas in its annual U.S. Clean Tech Leadership Index. That’s up three spots from last year, and up 14 spots from the 2013 report. The survey accumulated 26 individual metrics, including electricity and carbon emissions; clean technology investment and workforce; and use of natural gas and electric vehicles.

But in the Green Buildings category, the survey put the Steel City at 33rd, down from 2014’s ranking of 31st. While it was expectedly far behind green-tech giants like San Francisco, Seattle and San Diego, Pittsburgh trailed lesser-known areas like Raleigh, Virginia Beach, Louisville and Cleveland.

Local green advocates were quick to point out that the survey’s five chosen indicators of green building leadership could have been more inclusive and that Pittsburgh performance varied widely among them. The survey’s methods and results also call attention to the multitude of third-party building certifications that have proliferated and evolved in the last two decades, affirming a wide range of project aspects, including design, construction, operations and maintenance.

Clean Edge measured, in each metro area, the number of building projects and amount of floor space per capita that had received a Leadership in Energy & Environmental Design, or LEED, certification. Developed by the Green Building Council, LEED is the predominant certification, with nearly 80,000 building projects in the world listed in its online project directory.

Pittsburgh ranked 12th among the metro areas in number of LEED-certified projects per capita and 21st in the floor space per capita for those projects. 

Advertise with us

However, the report also surveyed projects certified by Energy Star, an annual designation from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency based on a commercial and multi-unit residential building’s energy efficiency performance. And the survey showed that few cities had both in equal numbers: Five of the top 10 metro areas in number of LEED projects did not crack the top 10 in number of Energy Star projects.

The report found Pittsburgh ranked 37th among metro areas in both number of Energy Star projects and floor space.

Aurora Sharrard, vice president of innovation at the Green Building Alliance, said though some retail owners in Pittsburgh such as Giant Eagle, J.C. Penney and Kohl’s have embraced Energy Star, the Pittsburgh real estate market has simply preferred LEED.

“It is true that compared to other cities, Pittsburgh does not have a lot of Energy Star commercial buildings,” Ms. Sharrard said, but added, “LEED and Energy Star are just two indicators of green buildings.”

New certifications have spawned with the improvement of technology and as building owners have increasingly desired buildings that reduce a range of environmental and health impacts. The construction and operations of buildings are responsible for 65 percent of electricity consumption, 30 percent of greenhouse gas emissions and 30 percent of raw materials use, according to the Washington D.C.-based nonprofit U.S. Green Building Council.

Advertise with us

LEED, for instance, can apply to a range of structures, from single-family homes to high-rise commercial buildings like hotels and convention centers to industrial facilities like warehouses and data centers. It offers tiered levels — Certified, Silver, Gold and Platinum — depending on how many points a project earns.

Phipps Executive Director Richard Piacentini remembers first hearing about LEED in the late-1990s, as the conservatory was constructing its welcome center. At that time, he said, the goal of the welcome center project was to improve visitor amenities and increase revenue.

After agreeing to pursue LEED, Mr. Piacentini said he became excited. It “provided us with the perfect opportunity to spread the word about the importance of conservation and create future change,” he said. “We think our building should reflect our values.”

But he soon wanted more: “We thought, why stop at the building?”

The International Living Future Institute — an organization of green building advocates of which Mr. Piacentini now serves as board chairman — developed in 2006 the Living Building Challenge certification, which assesses a building on seven “petals”: Place, Water, Energy, Health & Happiness, Materials, Equity and Beauty.

Advertise with us

Phipps is one of eight certified Living Buildings in the world.

“The next step for us was to recognize that human health and environmental health are connected,” Mr. Piacentini said. “We found ourselves thinking in systems and how all these things are connected.”

The Clean Edge survey, as a final measure in addition to LEED and Energy Star projects, asked a yes-or-no question of metro areas: Does its main city require owners of large buildings to publicly disclose energy usage? Pittsburgh was not one of the 11 areas that have such a law, which can vary by city but generally applies to non-residential buildings above a certain square footage threshold. Atlanta and Portland adopted the requirement in 2015.

“We think it’s important to keep an eye on building energy performance over the life of the building, and there are great metrics out there for that,” said Clint Wilder, senior editor at Clean Edge. “Obviously, if you have to disclose it, then you’re going to track it, then you’re hopefully keeping it efficient.”

Tim McNulty, spokesman for Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto, said in an email the report used “incomplete information.” He acknowledged the city had no such disclosure law but said it has “backed very successful energy reduction initiatives.”

Advertise with us

In April, as part of a plan to reduce energy use by 50 percent in Downtown and Oakland buildings by 2030, city officials for the first time publicly disclosed performance for many of Pittsburgh’s buildings and parking garages.

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.