The July 2008 launch of MyGallons.com, a website that allows motorists to secure future purchases of gasoline at current prices, could have gone smoother for founder and CEO Steven Verona.
U.S. Bancorp, a Minneapolis bank that Mr. Verona expected to ensure the credit of special MyGallons cards, pulled out unexpectedly. The bank, Mr. Verona alleges, then lied to the media and the Better Business Bureau about its involvement in the venture. The bureau — which grades businesses on trustworthiness — slapped MyGallons with an “F” rating for distributing false information to customers.
MyGallons reimbursed tens of thousands of customers who had already paid membership fees, and Mr. Verona put the endeavor on hold while he redesigned the service without a financial partner.
But the Miami-based company, which in 2013 won a defamation lawsuit against the bank, claims it has not only survived but is poised for record growth this month, as retail gas prices continue to rise.
The company expects to sign up about 38,000 new customers who are scrambling to buy fuel while pump prices still stand to rise significantly. Mr. Verona would not disclose the number of MyGallons customers, but he said this growth is on par with the customers it gained in 2009, when oil prices spiked.
“When prices are dropping, we encourage people to sign up,” Mr. Verona said. “When they go up significantly, people who bought much lower are using MyGallons to realize savings.”
The service doesn’t give consumers literal tanks of gasoline for storage. Rather, it allows them to pay for a certain virtual quantity of gas — limited at 150 gallons per vehicle per month — at the average retail price in their home state. Consumers can “cash in” these gallons at any time and receive a deposit in their bank account equal to the difference.
It works like this: If the price of gas were $2 a gallon, customers could pay $300 to purchase 150 gallons. They could then redeem those gallons at any gas station if prices were to hit $2.50, which would save them $75 when MyGallons deposits $375 in their bank account.
But that savings doesn’t account for service fees of $30 per vehicle for an annual membership, a 6 percent fee on the pre-purchase of gas and then another 6 cents per gallon as a quantity of gas is cashed in.
And with the volatility of oil prices, skeptics are concerned that most consumers don’t have the level of prowess needed to see significant benefit from such an arrangement.
MyGallons is what some call a “gamification” of what futures traders already do. That is, it allows ordinary consumers in on the speculation on the price of gas while not necessarily understanding the complexities of the marketplace.
“It is possible for a consumer to win, but chances are, they’re going to lose,” said Michael Green, spokesman for AAA’s fuel division, which tracks pump prices. “There’s a knowledge gap for the average consumer in order to make the best decisions.”
Given the service fees, Michael Santoli, a blogger and Wall Street analyst for Yahoo! Finance, calculates that consumers could gain only if their cash-in price is well more than 10 percent higher than their pre-purchased price.
“In the end,” Mr. Santoli wrote last week, “MyGallons is essentially a broker taking a fee to relieve its customers of some price risk.”
Some restrictions, including the monthly limit of 150 gallons per vehicle, prevent large-scale market speculation. The company allows small business fleets to go above that limit if they provide gas receipts to prove the fuel was actually put into a vehicle.
But the long-term game is tricky.
“Gas prices are very difficult to predict, even for experts,” said Mr. Green at AAA. “It’s not unlike the stock market in the sense that no one really knows what’s going to happen in the future.”
Average retail gas prices in Pennsylvania — which is what would determine the MyGallons benchmark for customers here — hit $2.65 per gallon on Monday, up 20 percent from their bottom-out price of $2.22 per gallon in early February.
“There’s not a lot of room for prices to increase further,” said Mr. Green, warning customers against more pre-purchases at this point.
Mr. Verona said MyGallons has about 250 customers in the Pittsburgh area but he would not discuss specifics related to the exact size and distribution of its customer base. He said his business model has been sustainable through gas prices swings because the company hedges every penny of its customers’ pre-purchases and cash-ins.
“If the price of gas goes up $1 a gallon, we lose $1 a gallon when we pay you the $3.50, but we’ve made $1 a gallon on our hedge,” he said. “If we owe 100 gallons to 1,000 customers ... we would hedge 100,000 gallons in our financial market.”
The company is in effect subscribing to a similar strategy it provides its customers.
By design, MyGallons is buying futures on the derivative market, agreeing to a future “swap price” with a third party, explained David Meats, energy analyst with investment research firm Morningstar Inc. If the price of gas were to spike, the third party would pay MyGallons the difference from the agreed-upon price, which would cover the amount MyGallons would then pay to customers.
If the price drops, the company pays the difference to the third party but makes the same profit from its customers.
“As a result, the company has protected its downside by giving up its upside,” Mr. Meats wrote in an email. “It has ‘locked in’ the swap price because that’s effectively what it is getting no matter what happens to prices in the future.”
Plus, Mr. Verona said, MyGallons has connected with a customer base that simply wants the stability in their household budget that a predicable fuel expense can bring.
For most of their customers, “Every month they cash in gallons so they have control over their budget and their costs,” he said.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.