To hear some Ukranian politicians talk, it might seem like Westinghouse Electric Co. is a household name in the former Soviet republic — a trusted business partner picking up the nuclear pieces of Ukraine’s unraveled bonds to Russia.

Just because it’s exaggerated doesn’t make Westinghouse’s ascent in Ukraine any less significant for either side.

For decades, all 15 of Ukraine’s Russian-style reactors were using 100 percent Russian-made fuel. Today, there are Westinghouse fuel assemblies in three of them. Next year, it could be six, and the country’s energy officials have said they want Westinghouse’s share to be 30 percent.

Western fuel has nudged the monopoly of TVEL, the nuclear fuel fabrication arm of Russia’s state-owned nuclear company Rosatom, which is the culmination of more than a decade of diplomacy and a few commercial setbacks. The U.S. Department of Energy helped open the door for Westinghouse in Ukraine to pilot a new type of fuel for the company starting in 2005 — specifically designed for Russian reactors.

Advertise with us

Cranberry-based Westinghouse first tested fuel for a Russian reactor in Czech Republic in 2000 but the trial ran into technical issues. In 2009, TVEL regained the country’s nuclear fuel business. A Russian-designed nuclear power plant in Finland that ran on a different type of Westinghouse fuel a decade ago also awarded a subsequent contract to the Russian firm.

When news of technical problems surfaced in Ukraine several years ago — TVEL claimed Westinghouse’s fuel had design flaws while Westinghouse, whose pilot fuel was co-loaded into the reactor core with TVEL’s said the Russian product was deforming its own — it looked like Westinghouse’s ambitions for supplying Russian-made reactors were in danger. In 2012, Ukranian utility National Nuclear Energy Company Energoatom asked Westinghouse’s to make certain design modifications after some of its fuel assemblies were found to have deformed.

Negotiations were ongoing between Energoatom and Westinghouse to spread its fuel to more reactors.

In March 2014, Russia annexed Crimea. Nine months later, Westinghouse had a new five-year contract to supply fuel to Energoatom.

“With the geopolitical developments, Westinghouse certainly saw an opportunity for it to make a comeback,” said Anna Bryndza, senior vice president for policy at Georgia-based Ux Consulting Co. “It increased its initiatives in Ukraine and it also increased its initiatives to return to the (Russian-design) fuel market elsewhere.”

Advertise with us

In February, Westinghouse said it had signed an agreement to once again start testing fuel at the Czech utility that abandoned it years earlier.

Mark Marano, president of Americas, Europe, Middle East and Africa regions for Westinghouse, said the political situation in Ukraine in 2014 “created an opportunity” but that it was the fuel’s quality that has been gaining momentum.

“In fair situations, our product wins out,” Mr. Marano said.

It hasn’t hurt that the European Union adopted a policy in 2014 that prioritizes nuclear fuel diversity within its member states. There are five countries that rely on Russian fuel, four of them for 100 percent of their nuclear generation. Last year, the EU gave a Westinghouse-led group a $2.3 million grant to be put towards licensing its fuel for Russian reactors.

Fuel factory

Advertise with us

Over the past month, Ukraine’s coal and energy minister Ihor Nasalyk has twice announced that Westinghouse is ready to build a nuclear fuel factory in Ukraine.

Westinghouse, however, has made no such announcement. When asked, spokeswoman Courtney Boone said the company has plenty of capacity at its Swedish factory to make fuel for its Ukrainian contracts.

“Ukrainian political statements have been sort of all over the place recently,” Ms. Bryndza said. “And they’re politically driven.”

That’s because in 2010, Energoatom and TVEL formed a joint venture to build a nuclear fuel factory in Ukraine that would produce the Russian-designed fuel. Some construction was under way when the conflict in Crimea broke out in 2014. Last year, Ukraine broke the contract with Russia and the project stalled.

But for Westinghouse to take over the project doesn’t make economic sense, Ms. Bryndza said.

Advertise with us

Furthermore, even the goal of Westinghouse supplying 30 percent of nuclear fuel might be a stretch, she said, as TVEL has a long-term contract with Energoatom that limits how much foreign fuel can be used.

But there might be other opportunities. When Ukraine cancelled Russia’s participation in the fuel factory, it also terminated its contract to build out two reactors.

That’s the kind of business that Westinghouse and French-company Areva would like to get their hands on, Ms. Bryndza said, although its questionable whether that project will proceed because Ukraine doesn’t have the money nor the need for more electricity in that part of the country.

“More promising is work with the existing fleet in Ukraine,” she said.

In March, Westinghouse signed an agreement “to explore cooperation” on such work. It also announced that Ukraine would be using Westinghouse software to monitor its reactor cores.

Advertise with us

Home turf

Earlier this year, TVEL announced it was coming to the U.S.

The company said it was partnering with GE Hitachi to make and license nuclear fuel for Westinghouse-designed reactors. The partnership has indicated they have at least one U.S. utility already signed up.

During a call with analysts in July, Danny Roderick, who heads Toshiba’s energy business which includes Westinghouse, said the company will be “watching and concerned about how much government money is put into subsidizing that assembly.”

Mr. Marano estimated that Westinghouse has up to 85 percent of the market share for nuclear fuel in the U.S. It will take years for TVEL to qualify and license its fuel in the U.S., he predicted.

Advertise with us

“It’s a free market and we welcome competition,” Mr. Roderick said. “We will make sure it's fair competition and then we’ll let the technology win at the end of the day.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.

Correction, posted Aug. 8, 2016: An earlier version identified the wrong U.S. department involved in helping Westinghouse enter the market in Ukraine.