Alpha Natural Resources, a Virginia-based coal miner working to reorganize itself under bankruptcy protection, has struck a deal with several environmental groups in which it will surrender some 53 million tons of coal reserves in Westmoreland and Fayette counties.

The reserves, currently controlled by Alpha subsidiary Rostraver Energy Co., will be donated to a yet-to-be named nonprofit which will guard them from ever being mined and burned.

The Rostraver reserves lie mostly in the Upper Freeport coal seam. Alpha also owns about 2,400 acres of surface property above them and, as part of the settlement, will try to sell that land and donate the first $2 million of the profits to the environmental groups.

The settlement between Alpha and the Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition, West Virginia Highlands Conservancy, and Sierra Club also stipulates that Alpha will pay $7.5 million to fund land and stream restoration projects. In exchange, those environmental groups have promised to give Alpha a three-year extension on deadlines in a previously negotiated environmental settlement. They've also said they won't oppose the company’s reorganization plan.

Advertise with us

That plan, which is up for approval before a federal judge Thursday, has drawn opposition from a number of stakeholders, including federal and state regulators.

Alpha filed for bankruptcy protection in August 2015, citing an “unprecedented period of distress” for the coal industry. The company, which owns the Cumberland and Emerald mines in Greene County, operates more than 50 underground and surface mines across four Appalachian states and Wyoming.

Read More

Its reorganization plan proposes to split those assets between two companies. The good ones have been auctioned off to a group of creditors and renamed Contura Energy Inc., and the remaining assets will be kept under the reorganized company and operated to the extent that they cover their environmental liabilities.

Alpha’s reorganization plan assumes that federal leases, among the more valuable of the company’s assets, will be transferred to Contura. But the U.S. Department of Justice, which filed objections to the plan, said that’s not a guarantee and cannot happen without federal approval.

The problem is that if Alpha gives its best assets, including federal leases, to Contura, the remaining company will be “inadequately funded and infeasible,” the U.S. trustee wrote.

Advertise with us

That will make it “incapable of complying with public health and safety requirements applicable to coal mining companies.”

The U.S. trustee also took issue with the plan’s intention of excusing the surviving entities from certain environmental and other liabilities.

“No one is entitled to ignore hazards or disregard laws that protect the public and the environment,” the trustee wrote.

The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection echoed those objections in its filing and urged the judge not to allow the plan that, as written, “fails to clearly provide for (the company’s) continued compliance with Pennsylvania environmental law.”

Specifically, the DEP is concerned with Alpha’s obligations to two families who have appeals pending before a state environmental board regarding the damage that Alpha’s Cumberland and Emerald mines have caused to their property.

Advertise with us

The agency is also concerned that the surviving company and the new one will be let off the hook from paying operation and maintenance costs for three homeowners whose water supplies were affected by Alpha’s subsidiary Amfire Mining Co, and from a 2014 multi-state consent decree that requires Alpha to continuously monitor and address mine discharges.

In its reorganization plan, Alpha has claimed that provisions that release its surviving and new companies from certain responsibilities are “narrowly tailored, and each of the released parties has provided value to the debtors and aided in the reorganization process.”

A hearing is set for Thursday to approve the plan of reorganization, which will put the company on a path to exiting its bankruptcy. Before that can happen, the U.S. trustee has made known its intent to depose several Alpha executives, issuing subpoenas to the company’s chief financial officer and restructuring advisers.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.