Despite the company’s objections, Consol Energy shareholders voted in favor of giving themselves more power to shape the corporate board of directors.
The so-called proxy access resolution, put forward at the company’s annual meeting on Wednesday by the New York City comptroller and several pension funds, allows shareholders holding 3 percent of the company’s stock for three consecutive years the ability to nominate a candidate to the board. His or her election would still need a majority vote of all the company’s shareholders.
Currently, only the company’s nominating committee has the power to put forward a candidate.
In a lengthy rebuke of the proxy access concept, Consol warned its shareholders that “the proposal is a political ploy that is not presented for the purpose of promoting the best interests of all of our shareholders.”
The Cecil-based oil, gas and coal company was targeted by the New York City comptroller because it is a fossil fuel company, Consol said in a statement to shareholders.
The comptroller’s office hasn’t denied that. In fact, Laura Campos, director of shareholder activities with the Nathan Cummings Foundation, said that climate change concerns are a major financial risk factor for such companies. Ms. Campos appeared at Consol’s annual meeting Wednesday morning to present the resolution on behalf of the New York City comptroller. The meeting was held at the Hyatt Regency Pittsburgh International Airport.
Proxy access has spread through the corporate world with record speed. In 2010, the Securities and Exchange Commission wrote a rule that looked similar to the resolution put before Consol — 3 percent for three years — but it was struck down in court. Nevertheless, the subject has gotten a lot of attention from activist shareholders and large pension funds that push for socially and environmentally responsible corporate governance practices.
Just three years ago, only half a percent of S&P 500 companies had proxy access. At the end of last year, that total spiked to 20 percent, according to Institutional Shareholder Services Inc., a corporate governance advisory firm. Nearly all of the 120 companies that had proxy access resolutions introduced last year adopted it in some form.
Consol did not. Its 2015 shareholder resolution on the issue received 47 percent of the vote. On Wednesday, it tipped to 52 percent.
While Consol has previously warned that “proxy access may lead to an inexperienced, fragmented and unstable board that is less efficient and less focused on creating long-term value for our shareholders,” the company said on Wednesday that it values the input and will consider the shareholders’ views on this advisory proposal. The company is not obligated to act on it.
Another shareholder proposal asking Consol to compile and publish a report that chronicles its spending on lobbying activities, including money paid to trade associations that lobby on its behalf, received 16 percent of the vote.
“The shareholders have wisely defeated similar proposals in prior years,” Consol wrote in its counter argument before the meeting.
The company also claimed that making that information public would undermine its competitiveness with peers “by revealing its strategies and priorities.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.
Correction posted May 13, 2016: An earlier version had an incorrect name for Institutional Shareholder Services Inc.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.