To be like Andrew Carnegie, you have to act like Andrew Carnegie, said Mark DeSantis, founder of an energy analytics firm in Pittsburgh that recently has begun to gain traction with some deep pockets.
By that he meant that innovators and entrepreneurs need room to fail. They need money to try and fail and try again. It’s a hard sell, he acknowledged.
Still, Mr. DeSantis, founder and, until this month, CEO of kWantera, heard the echo around the room at a panel discussion at Carnegie Mellon University last week.
Two dozen energy entrepreneurs, some academics and private equity funders, nodded their heads and took turns bemoaning Pittsburgh’s valley of death — the time between an idea’s proof and proof of worth.
The city has a healthy bulk of resources and funding for early stage companies, most agreed. But when it comes to the next level — venture capital funding or commercial contracts — it’s time to hop on a plane and head for the coasts.
When kWantera decided to seek its second round of funding — its Series B round — it didn’t even look in Pittsburgh.
“Pittsburghers are risk averse,” Mr. DeSantis said.
Others recounted their air travel for money, both from funders and from customers.
Enes Hosgor, who founded the building energy analytics company EEme while at CMU, got financing from Silicon Valley and clients from across the Atlantic.
“We have not worked with any single organization in Pennsylvania, let alone Pittsburgh,” he said. “We’ve gone all the way to China. We’ve gone all the way to Europe.”
The barrier here has been “that risk-averse attitude, the lack of innovation culture,” Mr. Hosgor said.
Lisa Weiland, who said she’s done her share of coastal travel for funding for her hydropower start up Renerge Inc., offered a different take.
“I think half the city would take a bullet for Sid Crosby,” she said. “That’s not risk averse. (It’s) team oriented. We haven’t found a good way to bring them to the team.”
That’s just the disconnect that struck Jared Cohon, former CMU president.
“It’s almost unique to Pittsburgh: our own company leadership has nothing to do with you,” he told the entrepreneurs in the room.
He thought back to meetings at the Allegheny Conference on Economic Development, a group that includes Pittsburgh’s Fortune 500 contingent.
“They don’t think of you. They never, ever talk about you,” he said.
There are notable exceptions, of course. Metals giant Alcoa gave kWantera a chance to prove its mechanism and the experience helped the startup attract General Electric as a funder.
Consol Energy Inc. invested in Epiphany Solar, a Lawrenceville firm that makes solar-powered water processing units. Consol’s support pivoted Epiphany to focus on oilfield services above all other applications.
But for every such success, there’s been a time when Lalit Chordia, a serial entrepreneur and founder of Thar Energy, has appealed to institutions including CMU to try out his geothermal solution and been told they would only consider it if Mr. Chordia waives the cost.
Same goes for Ron Gdovic, founder of vertical wind turbine firm Windstax in the Strip District.
“I can’t tell you the number of times we’ve been asked to install something for free and give a 20-year (power purchase agreement),” he said, “Basically, to be the bank for the institution.”
With seven companies under his belt, Mr. Chordia said he doesn’t see the point of complaining about Pittsburgh’s risk appetite: ”It is what it is,” he said.
He suggested the focus should be on attracting high-level marketing talent to the area to sell what Thar and other energy companies in the room have to offer.
“Let’s get the right marketing people and sell the hell out of Pittsburgh,” he said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.