It’s unavoidable that when something is free, it gets wasted, said Josh Adler, CEO of Sourcewater Inc.
Fresh water, in most of Pennsylvania, is free. It is therefore being wasted every time an oil and gas company slurps it from a river or the ground to frack a shale well.
According to Mr. Adler, there is never a reason to use even a drop of fresh water for fracking when recycled water works just as well. Even at no cost, it’s too expensive given the current market dynamics. As he sees it, because wastewater disposal is expensive, companies can get paid to use recycled oil and gas wastewater to frack their wells.
On this principle, Mr. Adler founded his company two years ago, which he envisions as an “Expedia” or “eBay” of water. It’s an online marketplace where companies that need water and those that need to get rid of it post listings to connect.
Cambridge-based Sourcewater went live last April in Pennsylvania although active trading started earlier this year. It has also made a push into Texas. The two oil and gas producing states — together, they produced 40 percent of the nation’s natural gas last year — have contrary water challenges.
In Pennsylvania, fresh water for drilling and fracking is almost always free and plentiful, but wastewater disposal is cumbersome and expensive. Pennsylvania has fewer than 10 injection wells and only one wastewater treatment facility permitted to discharge the water it processes back into the ground.
When fracking was booming, companies could more easily recycle their wastewater for use in future wells. But now that activity has slowed substantially in response to low commodity prices, more companies are trucking wastewater to disposal wells in Ohio and West Virginia.
Texas has the opposite problem. Fresh water is scarce. But opportunities for disposal are aplenty.
Both imbalances create just the right conditions for an eBay-type service, Mr. Adler said.
The companies in Pennsylvania that would otherwise be paying up to $20 per barrel to truck used water out of state can offer, say, $10 per barrel to companies that need water for fracking. And those that take the used water and the money would be cutting their well costs — a win-win.
For each deal consummated through the site, Sourcewater charges a 6 percent commission, but Mr. Adler indicated he’s flexible on that if price is a barrier to entry.
Barriers to entry
Mr. Adler is a serial entrepreneur who’s worked in real estate and tech, industries that are arguably easier to penetrate with a spiffy Internet-based solution.
He thought of the idea for Sourcewater during a year-long fellowship program at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2012. Mr. Adler said he saw a graph charting the rise of shale production in the U.S. and couldn’t believe his eyes.
“That’s happening? Now? In the U.S?” he thought. “Is this the Internet? Is this the gold rush?”
He started to think about the water logistics needed to make fracking work — each horizontal well requires several million gallons to bust open the shale that holds the oil and gas trapped inside.
How can companies know exactly where water is available at the cheapest price, he thought. And how can they ensure they’re getting rid of their wastewater in the most efficient way?
“My intuition is something that’s gotten this big, this fast, there’s no way they know,” he said. “Nobody’s looking at the whole ecosystem.”
Since trading started, Mr. Adler said the site is averaging a few transactions a week, but convincing operators to join hasn’t been easy.
“You think that something that is free and is going to save you money — you’d think they’d just be like, ‘Sure, I’ll try that,” Mr. Adler said. “That’s not how it works. From the time we have our first conversation with a water manager in the oil and gas industry, it’s probably about a year until we get (them) doing the first transaction.”
David Yoxtheimer, a hydrogeologist and extension associate with Penn State University’s Marcellus Center for Outreach and Research, said he’s watched Sourcewater leaders present their concept before groups of oil and gas decision makers who said they were anxious to make sure the counterparties in the Web deals would be reputable.
“The operators were very intrigued,” he said. “There’s some skepticism, which is kind of inherent with the industry players.”
Oil and gas companies like to keep their operational details close to the vest, so Sourcewater designed a system where listings are anonymous. But that creates another problem: producers like to know who they’re dealing with.
For the past decade, shale gas companies have been bombarded with pitches about technologies that could save them money, cut their environmental footprint, build a better oil and gas trap. Many have been burned by the work of contractors and suppliers who veered off course.
“Just because of the environmental concerns with the water, everyone is really particular with where their water is going and who’s taking it and what the end result is going to be,” said Kelly Roddy, manager of Waste Treatment Corp., a Warren-based wastewater processing plant.
Mr. Adler said that since the site launched, the most popular piece of feedback has been the concern that companies need to vet their suppliers. In response, Sourcewater now has oil and gas operators provide a list of their pre-approved contractors to the site which can narrow listings to that list.
Waste Treatment has done two or three transactions through Sourcewater’s site, but Ms. Roddy said that Sourcewater has been able to connect her company to clients offline and most deals have been made the old-fashioned way, through phone calls and e-mails.
Mr. Adler said it’s part of getting users comfortable with the product.
“If it gets going, I think that Sourcewater would be a great thing for the industry,” Ms. Roddy said. “But I guess it’s a wait and see.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.