More than a year after Westinghouse Electric Co. lost a bid to replace steam generators at a South African nuclear plant and cried foul, the country’s second highest court finally agreed.

The Supreme Court of Appeal ruled last week that the evaluation process used by Eskom, a South African utility, to select French company Areva over Westinghouse in August 2014 was “irrational and unlawful” because it relied on “strategic considerations” conjured outside of the official bidding process and not communicated to Westinghouse.

But the court stopped short of taking the contract away from Areva and handing it to Westinghouse, as the U.S. firm had asked. Instead, it tossed the sticky situation back to Eskom.

An Eskom spokesperson said the utility is reviewing the judgement and can’t answer any specific questions on the ruling.

Advertise with us

“We are certain, though, that we will definitely appeal this judgement,” the spokesperson said.

Westinghouse, too, declined to forecast what will come next.

“The finding that Eskom’s Board Tender Committee unlawfully took into account so-called ‘strategic considerations’ is, however, to be welcomed,” said Westinghouse spokesman, Hans Korteweg.

The legal fight stems from an estimated $370 million project to install two new steam generators at the Koeberg nuclear power station near Cape Town, the only supplier of nuclear power in South Africa. By the end of this month, both generation will have been in service for 30 years and the utility determined that 2018 is the last possible year they can be replaced to avoid safety problems.

Since the bid, called a tender, began in 2012, Westinghouse appeared to be the front-runner in a series of evaluations from utility staff and other experts. So the company was shocked when, in August 2014, the award went to Areva.

Advertise with us

Eskom explained that the bidders were evaluated not just for their price, which would award Westinghouse a substantial advantage, and technical expertise, but also for certain strategic issues such as their history of managing projects on time and on budget, and a historical claim to the reactors — it’s a Westinghouse design, but they were built by a predecessor of Areva.

The problem is that the strategic considerations appeared seemingly out of nowhere towards the end of the evaluation process.

Westinghouse filed lawsuits and even demanded that two utility officials be thrown in jail over the upset. It alleged that a high-ranking Eskom official was prejudiced against the company and set events in motion to deny it the contract.

A lower court ruled against Westinghouse but the Supreme Court of Appeal said that Eskom, as an entity of the state, can’t justify awarding the contract to Areva if the process wasn’t fair to all applicants.

If these special considerations are still important to the utility, the court said, Eskom should repeat the whole bidding process.

Advertise with us

One problem, however, is that Areva has already begun the work. It started the month following the award, in fact, and has already ordered components from manufacturers.

And the deadline to replace the generators is already pushed to its limits.

“None of the parties deny that the replacement of the generators is vital to the country’s power grid and that the energy crisis that affects it will be greatly exacerbated if the work for which Westinghouse and Areva tendered is not done urgently,” the court decision states.

More broadly, the contract might have bigger implications than its $370 million price tag. The winner may have an inside track on benefiting from South Africa’s nuclear ambitions — the country says it wants to build at least six new nuclear reactors by 2030. Each new reactor would likely run a few billion dollars.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.