At the state’s largest power plant, FirstEnergy Corp. is under strict orders to do something else with as much as 3.5 million tons of coal waste produced annually by the end of 2016. To that end, the Akron, Ohio-based energy company is progressing on a $200 million facility to prepare it to ship elsewhere.
In a media tour last week, officials at the Bruce Mansfield Power Plant in Shippingport showed off the early phases of construction on a 24,000-square-foot facility.
Though seemingly unremarkable and dwarfed by other structures at the plant, its function is critical: Fully operational, it will remove water from a slurry of coal combustion residuals. The waste byproducts are produced from burning coal and by the plant’s emissions control equipment that scrubs sulfur dioxide before it’s released into the air.
The waste from the 2,490-megawatt plant — about 40 percent coal ash and 60 percent lime-based agents used in the scrubbing process — will be piped in and dried in three enormous tanks, each capable of holding up to 1 million gallons at a time. The product will exit on a conveyor belt and be placed on a barge on the Ohio River, destined for a landfill 113 river miles away.
“It’s a major team effort,” said James Fitzgerald, manager of special projects for FirstEnergy, describing the work begun by more than 135 contract laborers, a workforce he expects to double in the next month.
A widespread problem
The process shows the challenges that power companies like FirstEnergy face with disposing of one of the country’s largest sources of industrial waste. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency estimated that 470 coal-fired electric utilities in 2012 generated about 110 million tons of coal ash, with most ending up in landfills and surface impoundments like wet ash ponds.
Bruce Mansfield, the fifth-largest fossil power plant in the country, burns about 7 million tons of coal each year, enough to power 1.5 million homes, according to the company.
The 2017 deadline was finalized last year by state environmental regulators to close Little Blue Run, an unlined 900-acre waste pond about 7 miles west of the plant that straddles Greene Township, Pa., and Hancock County, W.Va. The company settled with the Department of Environmental Protection to clean up Little Blue Run after decades of groundwater contamination due to the absence of a protective liner.
The disposal options aren’t close. The leading destination is a dry, double-lined landfill of retired Hatfield’s Ferry Power Plant in Greene County, a plant that the company shut down in 2013. This would involve a 113-mile voyage on the Ohio and Monongahela rivers.
The Hatfield landfill would receive on average six barges of waste a day, company officials have said, and the materials would need to be trucked on a private, paved road for the last mile.
The company and state officials faced searing criticism from the local community during a May public hearing in Carmichaels, just a few miles from the shuttered plant.
Nonetheless, FirstEnergy last month won DEP approval to reopen Hatfield’s landfill, which spokeswoman Stephanie Walton said had enough capacity to handle all the waste from Bruce Mansfield without any need to expand. She noted the material from Shippingport will be identical to that which already fills the dump at Hatfield.
The company is still seeking approval to possibly ship waste to the LaBelle mine reclamation site, a former coal mine in Fayette County where it could be used to help mitigate acid mine drainage. That option is 97 miles away by barge.
When asked whether the company considered W.H. Sammis plant, which has a dry landfill roughly 15 miles down the Ohio River in Stratton, Ohio, Mr. Fitzgerald said the company wanted to keep its options open and not rely on one site.
Bruce Mansfield is the company’s only large coal plant without a dewatering facility. In addition to its Sammis and Hatfield plants, FirstEnergy has constructed a dewatering facility at Harrison Power Station in Haywood, W.Va., Pleasants Power Station in Willow Island, W.Va., and Fort Martin Power Station in Maidsville, W.Va.
Only its Bay Shore plant in Oregon, Ohio — a fraction of a typical coal plant’s capacity at a measly 153-megawatts — does not have one, according to the company. The dewatering process varies among the plants, and Bruce Mansfield’s facility would contain the latest technology, Ms. Walton said.
Next to the steel frame of a building and towering cranes lifting beams, crews were digging an 860-foot-long pit and rolling out protective liner. That pad, Mr. Fitzgerald said, will be used to temporarily hold the waste product and allow the plant to keep churning if the river freezes or there’s a disruption at the dewatering facility. The pit can hold about three or four days’ worth of waste, officials said, which could be critical during the winter.
Recycling waste into gypsum
Not all of the plant’s waste is dumped in Little Blue Run. Each year, the company recycles about 500,000 tons of the material into gypsum in a separate facility on plant property. It’s then sold to National Gypsum Co. to be used in wallboard manufacturing — enough drywall to be used in the construction of 70,000 homes — transported by conveyor belt to a plant right across the street.
It is a steady source of additional revenue for the company and diverts some 15 percent to 20 percent of the waste stream, Mr. Fitzgerald said. From the roof of a 17-story building that houses the plant operations equipment, a pearl-white mound of the substance is visible next to the gypsum company’s plant.
The only time the two companies worried about their partnership, he added, was during the recession when construction of new homes dropped precipitously.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.