Robert Murray has taken his fight for the survival of the U.S. coal industry — an industry that he believes will have room for only one other company besides his — to court.
“We’re under attack for total elimination of the use of coal, the mining of coal, coal mining jobs” and those that depend on them, Mr. Murray said in an interview last week. “It’s no question that the regulatory rampage of the Obama administration has accelerated and that has resulted in more litigation against the government.”
Murray Energy, the nation’s largest privately held underground mining company, is leading the charge in eight lawsuits against various federal agencies.
It is also a frequent plaintiff against another group that Mr. Murray says can threaten his ability to run a coal company — the media.
“My reputation has to be beyond reproach and it is. And when someone lies or even colors their media reports, we will absolutely sue them.”
Since 2001, Mr. Murray has filed at least nine lawsuits against reporters, editorial writers, a cartoonist, media organizations and radio stations that carried a paid advertisement from an activist group that was critical of Mr. Murray, claiming each time that their actions malign his reputation; threaten the jobs of his employees; and hamper his ability to get financing and negotiate with regulators.
None of these cases has made it to trial, although two are still pending. Some have settled and some have been dismissed by the court.
In several instances, Murray Energy has been able to extract printed apologies, most often in the vein of “sorry if you took it the wrong way” or “sorry if Mr. Murray’s feelings were hurt” without retracting the accused stories.
Mr. Murray is happy with his success rate. “We win more than we lose,” he said. Other companies might let unsympathetic coverage slide, but Mr. Murray isn’t taking any chances.
“I think they ignore it, and we want to survive.”
Government attacks
Mr. Murray says he’s been hurt by the “war on coal” but Murray Energy is also, by his account, one of the only coal companies in the country that’s doing well.
In 2013, Ohio-based Murray Energy more than doubled its workforce when it bought five mines from Consol Energy Inc. for $3.5 billion. Earlier this year, the company bought a large stake in Foresight Reserves LP, a company that mines for coal in the Illinois Basin, for $1.37 billion. In August, it acquired some Colombian mines.
Mr. Murray doesn’t see it as a contradiction. He says he could be doing better.
For example, in May, he had 8,400 employees. Today, he has 6,100. In several press releases, he blamed the layoffs on competition from natural gas and “the ongoing destruction of the United States coal industry by President Barack Obama.”
Mr. Murray says he’s fighting against corruption: The Obama administration doesn’t believe that its proposed regulations will help climate change or the environment, he said, nor is that even its goal.
“It has nothing to do with the environment. It’s a hoax,” he said. “It’s to pay back those who got him elected — radical environmental organizations, liberal elitists who have the money and don’t know what to do with it. Some unionists.”
While other coal companies let states or trade organizations take the lead in expensive, prolonged legal battles against new regulations, Murray Energy has greeted new government rules with press releases announcing lawsuits with him as the lead plaintiff.
When the Environmental Protection Agency released a draft of its Clean Power Plan this summer, Murray Energy was the first to act. Sixteen states attached their names to the company’s lawsuit, which the court declined to take up because the rule wasn’t yet final — it still hasn’t been published in the Federal Register.
When an Ohio Court of Appeals issued a stay for an EPA rule that seeks to extend federal authority to more small streams and wetlands, Murray Energy immediately issued a press release claiming credit for the result and highlighting that it was the first to file this lawsuit.
The cost burden is substantial, Mr. Murray acknowledged, but according to company statements, the legal strategy is paying off.
Murray Energy has a lawsuit pending against the Mine Safety and Health Administration for its Black Lung regulation, saying it’s unworkable; another against the Department of Interior for not satisfying Mr. Murray’s request for records about the agency’s proposed Stream Protection Rule that Mr. Murray has called “the single greatest threat to the jobs and family livelihoods of our employees”; and five others against the EPA, which charge that the agency and the Obama administration have acted illegally in promulgating certain rules and colluded with environmental groups.
Media detractors
The common thread between Mr. Murray’s voluminous and intricate government lawsuits and the claims filed against journalists and critics is defense.
“We react. We never take the offensive,” he said. “We react to someone attempting to destroy people’s lives and their jobs.”
In 2013, Mr. Murray sued a Huffington Post writer and his employer over a story titled, “Meet the extremist coal baron bankrolling Ken Kuccinelli’s Campaign.”
The article “severely harmed the reputation” of Mr. Murray and his company, the complaint claimed, and “caused great mental anguish and emotional distress” for the CEO and his family.
The Huffington Post story reported that the day after President Obama’s re-election in 2012, Mr. Murray read aloud a prayer asking God for forgiveness for what he was being forced to do to keep his company viable. Then he fired 158 employees.
The lawsuit said Mr. Murray was defamed and that his business was forever damaged. The jobs of all of his workers were on the line.
The case was dismissed by the court.
The same incident inspired another lawsuit against a group called Patriots for Change which used the occasion of the company’s post-election firing to hold a rally outside Murray Energy’s headquarters with signs that read, “Mr. Murray stop intimidating your coal mining employees.”
Mr. Murray sued the group and a local newspaper, Chagrin Valley Times, for covering the protest, writing an editorial about it and publishing a cartoon about Murray Energy.
That case, also, was dismissed by the court.
“If the media knows that you’re going to sue them, they may back off,” said Jack Greiner, a media attorney with Cincinnati firm Graydon Head & Ritchey, who hasn’t been involved in any of the Murray lawsuits.
He hasn’t escaped Mr. Murray’s attention, though.
Murray Energy’s assistant general counsel Gary Broadbent said Mr. Murray was defamed in a blog post that Mr. Greiner wrote after an Ohio court dismissed Mr. Murray’s lawsuit against the Chagrin Valley Times and took the unusual step of urging the Ohio Legislature to enact a statute that would make it harder for plaintiffs like Mr. Murray to file such lawsuits.
The blog post appeared on the website of the Cincinnati Enquirer, which Mr. Greiner represents.
“This column is merely Greiner’s attempt to bully Murray into filing a lawsuit, so that he can generate some new clients for his law firm,” Mr. Broadbent wrote in an op-ed also published by the Inquirer in which he urged people to stop subscribing to the publication and said Mr. Greiner’s post “hurts our employees, our state and our country.”
“It’s hard for me to understand,” Mr. Greiner said, reflecting on Murray Energy’s attitude toward criticism in print. “They really ought to develop a thicker skin.”
For every negative news story, Mr. Murray said he invariably gets a call from one of his hundreds of lenders wanting an explanation, which hurts his business and his relationships.
That’s why often Mr. Murray asks for retractions and apologies, either in lawsuits or in letters that warn of an impending lawsuit. On at least one occasion, the promise of a lawsuit yielded an apology, though not a retraction, in the magazine Coal Age, which published an editorial about Mr. Murray’s press conference following a mine accident that killed six miners in Utah.
A Murray Energy subsidiary paid $950,000 to settle violations that federal regulators determined contributed to the death of those miners in August 2007.
The publisher of Coal Age at the time told the Salt Lake Tribune that the apology was a way of meeting Mr. Murray half way.
Allison Zieve, general counsel at Public Citizen, a Washington, D.C.-based advocacy group sued for radio ads attacking Mr. Murray, said finding a settlement everyone can live with avoids wasting time and money on a trial, even one she’s confident her organization would have won.
“There’s some PR value of having the dispute go on, but to me it was just a distraction from getting the work done,” Ms. Zieve said.
Public Citizen agreed to pay Murray $7,500 for the legal cost of removing the lawsuit from federal to state court.
“They felt like they got something and we felt like we didn’t capitulate in any way,” she said.
As far as Mr. Murray is concerned, any payment is an admission of guilt and an indication that in this lawsuit, Murray Energy has won.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.