One Monday in October 2013, a group of about three dozen environmentalists and union leaders gathered at a hotel in Washington, Pa., to talk about ways to anticipate mass layoffs in the coal industry, as it had become clearer that a combination of pollution rules and a tough market portended a long, painful decline.
The meeting had been planned months before, so it was just a coincidence that the Friday before about 380 workers at two mammoth coal-fired power plants in southwestern Pennsylvania left their jobs for the last time.
“There was an empty feeling in the room,” remembered Khari Mosley, regional program manager for the BlueGreen Alliance, a Washington, D.C.- based coalition founded by the Sierra Club and the United Steelworkers union that advocates for both blue-collar workers and environmental regulations.
As state officials and the electricity sector wonder how to comply with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency limits on carbon emissions from the country’s power plants by 2030, two reports were released last week by the Blue Green Alliance — one, a case study of the handling of Hatfield’s Ferry Power Station in Greene County and Mitchell Power Station closings, and the second, an analysis of employment opportunities following changes in the electric sector.
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection is holding listening sessions across the state to gather input on crafting a plan to comply with the EPA rule known as the Clean Power Plan that was finalized in August. Supporters of the rule say it offers opportunities for the state to protect workers who are laid off as the sector adjusts.
“It’s hard for elected leaders of unions whose job it is to find jobs for their members to embrace something that could potentially lose jobs, at least if that’s the perception,” Mr. Mosley said last week. “If we can find a way to have a just transition, they’ll be a lot less resistant to it.”
The case study about the Hatfield and Mitchell Power Station closings shows the challenges in such situations.
The larger of the plants, Hatfield’s along the Monongahela River, had just installed a scrubber system in 2009 to clean emissions of sulfur dioxide — a $600 million investment that had signaled to many in the region that the plant was there to stay.
Akron, Ohio-based FirstEnergy Corp., which picked up the plants in an acquisition of Allegheny Energy in 2011, in part blamed the shutdown on federal rules on emissions of mercury and other air toxics handed down by the EPA.
The case study, which includes interviews with local social services counselors, utility workers and environmentalists, found what it characterized as missteps in the closings. The central problem was a lack of time for local officials and workers to adjust to the news.
FirstEnergy had publicly announced the closures in July 2013, giving the workers 90 days’ notice.
“With that short time window, it just creates that panic,” Mr. Mosley added. “Everybody starts going in their own direction, and politics comes in. It becomes less solution-driven and more reactionary, and that’s what we would hope to avoid in the future.”
FirstEnergy spokeswoman Stephanie Walton characterized the closing procedures as a “business decision based on the individual plant.” She said 90 days gave PJM Interconnection, the regional electric grid operator, time to complete a thorough test to ensure that there would be enough power to meet demand after the closures.
She said all former workers at Hatfield and Mitchell have been offered a position elsewhere within the company, such as at another power plant or in its electric utility, West Penn Power.
“I think we certainly make every effort to accommodate those workers with positions within the company,” Ms. Walton said.
State and federal governments need to assist, Mr. Mosley said. He suggested the state offer incentives for companies to keep plants open longer than 90 days and to stagger layoffs so workers can have more time to figure out what to do.
Federal and state help
Putting a price on carbon emissions would be an optimal policy decision, said Mick Power, membership and campaign coordinator for the U.S. Climate Action Network and author of the report on employment opportunities, which found jobs could grow significantly in the next 15 years with a ramp-up of renewable development.
Mr. Power said if the state joined a regional carbon trading program as part of its plan to comply with the Clean Power Plan, 5 to 20 percent of the revenues raised could fund a program to assist laid off workers.
Federal help could come in the form of $1 billion allocated by the Obama administration in the fiscal 2016 budget. Known as the Power+ Plan, the federal aid program aims to infuse money to help local economies weather the closures of mines and plants.
That, too, has bred conflict within the coal industry. Speaking in Pittsburgh in June, Hall Quinn, president of the National Mining Association, compared federal assistance to “war reparations.”
Local communities disagree with that attitude, said Patrick Grenter, executive director for the Center for Coalfield Justice.
“We have seen from discussions with Greene County economic development folks, unanimous enthusiasm for engaging in this process,” Mr. Grenter said. “I think the only potential roadblock I’ve seen is political. But in terms of rank and file members of the community, they recognize it as an incredible opportunity.
Plants choose gas over coal
Environmentalists contend that pollution regulations have little to do with the recent downturn in the coal industry, which has faced stiff competition from cheaper and cleaner-burning natural gas, which is also produced in abundance in southwestern Pennsylvania.
As power plants have developed a thirst for natural gas, coal’s share of total U.S. electricity generation has declined 50 percent in 2005 to 39 percent in 2014, according to government data. At the same time, the natural gas share of electricity generation grew from 19 percent to 27 percent.
In May, natural gas installed capacity for the first month in history surpassed that of coal in PJM’s territory, which includes Pennsylvania and 12 other states.
“We can use this situation to develop a strategy or playbook that will resonate across the rest of the country,” said Randy Francisco, state organizing representative for the Sierra Club.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.