The hottest commodity at the Platts Coal Marketing Days conference last week — the most promised and least delivered product — was good news.

Kicking off the event at the Wyndham Grand, Downtown, was Greg Driscoll, president and CEO of Blaschak Coal Corp., a company in Schuylkill County that mines and sells anthracite coal. The market for that kind of coal peaked in the 1920s when 100 million tons of anthracite, which is mined in eastern Pennsylvania, was produced. Last year the nation burped out a mere 2.5 million tons.

“I’m not suggesting that the bituminous industry is going to see that,” Mr. Driscoll said, trying not to sound alarmist.

But he needn't have worried. Others did the suggesting for him.

Advertise with us

Like other industries, coal took a hit during the recession. While it was down, a number of factors — cheap natural gas, slower than predicted growth in demand for power and steel-making coal, and environmental regulations — came along and bruised it some more. It has never recovered.

The amount of coal consumed by the U.S. electric power sector, by far the largest consumer in the nation, is down 24 percent since 2008 and dropping. Appalachian production is down almost 40 percent in the past seven years. Many of the country’s largest coal companies are either in bankruptcy or no longer exist.

Hans Daniels, executive vice president with Colorado-based Doyle Trading Consultants, told the audience to expect another 100 million tons, or one-eighth of power plant demand, to fall out of the market in the next few years.

He asked the crowd to refrain from pelting him with rotten tomatoes and fruit.

The only good news he could muster was that the next sharp drop isn’t expected until the federal Clean Power Plan goes into effect in 2022.

Advertise with us

Chuck West, who procures coal for Ohio-based utility AEP, said he’d grown depressed during Mr. Daniels’ talk. He began his own presentation by berating a fellow panel member for going into coal sales and advising him to fire his career adviser.

At the end of his talk, George Dethlefsen, CEO of Corsa Coal Corp., flashed a collage of goofy television and movie characters: Seinfeld’s George Costanza, Anchorman’s Ron Burgandy, Caddyshack’s Carl Spackler.

He wanted to end his presentation on a high note, Mr. Dethlefsen explained.

The only good news to be had was possible bad news.

Coal sellers said destructive weather in Australia could stem the tide of cheaper metallurgical coal exports coming from the country that have crowded U.S. metallurgical coal, used in the steel-making process, out of the international market. They anticipated coal company bankruptcies would force some mines to close, easing the glut in both met coal and thermal coal, which is used in power plants. They wished for a weaker dollar, for higher gas prices, for frigid cold and sweltering heat.

Advertise with us

In past iterations of the coal gathering, the optimists in the crowd had predicted that prices were as low as they could get. That kind of talk is no longer in vogue.

The two bits of advice that Jack Porco offers his kids are “never burn a bridge and never call the bottom of the market.”

“I’ve been doing it for two years and I’ve been wrong for two years,” said the president and chief commercial officer for Latrobe-based Xcoal Energy & Resources, which markets coal internationally.

He spoke specifically about metallurgical coal, whose ramp up in supply was largely predicated on steep growth in China. Now the market is oversupplied and China isn’t importing as much as was expected.

An afternoon session closed with a tussle over who should announce the best news of the day. The panelists gave the honor to one of the event’s organizers who took the microphone and smiled.

Advertise with us

There was ice cream in the cocktail room.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.