As Consol Energy Inc. mulls the fate of its metallurgical coal mine in Virginia, a new analysis by Bloomberg Intelligence highlights the mine’s profitability during a prolonged gloom-and-doom cycle.
The metallurgical coal industry — which mines the type of coal that’s used to make steel — is operating amid the lowest prices in a decade. Any potential improvement is likely still years away.
And yet 80 percent of the biggest names in the global export market are still making money at these prices, according to a study of their operating costs.
Cecil-based Consol was the only U.S. company whose costs were below the price it received for its met coal, according to Bloomberg analyst Andrew Cosgrove, who compiled the data.
According to a public filing, Consol spent $46 to produce a ton of met coal at its Buchanan Mine in the third quarter of 2014 and later cut that down to $36 during the same three months this year by dropping a shift at the mine, canceling pension benefits earlier than expected and implementing other cost-saving measures.
What it received for those tons of coal also dropped, from about $61 to $48, but still left the company’s profit margin nearly unchanged at around $9 per ton.
Consol’s spokesman Brian Aiello said the mine “very successfully navigates the bottom of the market and is an absolute gold mine when prices are up because of low cost structure.”
More than 100 million tons of coal have come out of the Buchanan Mine since Consol started boring tunnels there in 1983. About 450 employees work underground and at the preparation plant there, after a massive layoff last year cut a third of the workforce.
Consol remains one of the largest employers in Buchanan County. The Pocahontas 3 coal seam there is internationally prized. It is Consol’s only met coal mine. The rest of its coal operations provide fuel for domestic power plants, a business that has also suffered from falling prices and lower demand.
The majority of met coal traveling across the world comes from Australia, where the currency has plunged in relation to the dollar, making everything from labor to materials cheaper. That, coupled with Australian companies using more contractors rather than employees, has cut costs tremendously, Mr. Cosgrove said, giving incentives to increase production even as met coal prices continue to slide.
“U.S. producers are really the losers in all of this,” he said.
Most U.S. met coal companies sell to Europe and are losing their market share because of lower European demand and competition from Russia. Because the cost to ship coal has decreased, too, even Australian coal making a long journey to Europe can edge out U.S. tons.
Now, all eyes are on India, Mr. Cosgrove said, which is the only country where demand is expected to grow in the next few years.
The problem with met coal is a familiar one across the energy commodity spectrum at this time: There’s too much of it.
Production from mines ramped up in recent years to keep pace with what was expected to be ballooning industrial growth in China. Prices also sent an encouraging signal. In 2011, quarterly met coal contract settlements were $330 a ton.
But slower than predicted growth and the recession has kept demand at bay, creating a glut. Many in the industry wanted met coal mines to close — a step to cut supply to better fit the demand — but few players wanted to sacrifice their own production for the greater good.
The price of coal on the international export market slid to $93 a ton during this quarter and is predicted to land even lower, possibly as low as $85 per ton, during the fourth quarter, Mr. Cosgrove said.
U.S. coal producers such as Virginia-based Alpha Natural Resources and Alabama-based Walter Energy Inc. lose $37 per ton and $26 per ton at that level, according to Mr. Cosgrove’s analysis. Both miners are in bankruptcy.
Consol’s Buchanan mine would still be almost $7 per ton in the black, he said.
“[Buchanan] looks really profitable right now,” said Mr. Cosgrove. Even if the coal dips to $85 per ton, “They are still in the money.”
The Virginia mine was destined to be spun out in a public offering during the fourth quarter, but the Cecil company put the effort on hold as its thermal coal IPO performed below expectations. Consol will announce the fate of the Buchanan mine — which could either end up in the same spin-out as thermal coal or become part of a joint venture — later this year.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.