Just a few days ago, betting against energy stocks — especially using other people’s shares — seemed to be a clever way to make some quick cash.
Short-interest investors flocked to oil and gas exploration and production stocks over the past few months. By mid-August, according to the latest available data, 12 percent of all the shares such companies have issued were sold short. That’s more than twice the average of all industries.
Shorters identify stocks they believe will decrease in price, then borrow shares from brokers and sell them. They have an obligation to cover the loan at some point in the future.
Those who succeed at this strategy wait for the expected price drop, then buy back the requisite number of shares for a cheaper price. They can then return the shares to the lender and pocket the profit.
It is investing’s traditional motto — buy low, sell high — turned on its head. For an industry like oil and gas production that is saddled with high debt, low commodity prices and a global oversupply, betting on share prices going down has become a popular direction.
That was a good place to be Monday morning when the Dow Jones industrial average shed 1,000 points soon after markets opened and closed the day down 4 percent. Oil prices dipped below $40 per barrel that day, which happened last in 2009.
Then Thursday, oil prices surged 10 percent, lifting sinking stocks and likely making shorters nervous about covering their positions.
The beaten-up stock of coal-turned-gas firm Consol Energy Inc. soared by 15 percent Thursday afternoon, after a run up in short interest in the weeks before.
In mid-August, 15 percent of Consol’s shares had been sold short. At that rate, it would take investors more than four days of regular trading volume to cover their loans. When short interest holders see an increasing price signal and rush to sell, their demand further pushes up the stock price.
Consol’s stock closed at $13.86 on Thursday, up 14 percent from Wednesday’s close.
In the Marcellus Shale that lies under much of Western Pennsylvania, as in the oil and gas space in general, higher short interest levels are likely a comment on companies’ balance sheets, said Ben Waytt, senior vice president of exploration and production with Stephens Inc. in Fort Worth, Texas.
“Maybe the buy side is anticipating those companies slowing growth,” he said. As counter-intuitive as it may seem during a time when overproduction of oil and gas collapsed their value, “In exploration and production, slowing growth is not a good thing.
“You’re doing the prudent thing by slowing down, helping supply and demand, but your stock gets pummeled in the meantime,” Mr. Waytt said.
Short interest tends to be a staple of exploration and production stocks, he said, because such stocks and their underlying commodities tend toward volatility.
For the majority of firms primarily focused on the Marcellus, short interest spiked to its highest level in mid-August.
For Rex Energy, the number of shares betting against it is almost equal to the number betting for it. About 44 percent of its total shares have been sold short.
Chesapeake Energy Corp.’s short interest portion is 35 percent, the second highest in the Marcellus group.
Canonsburg-based Rice Energy Inc. is 19 percent short while Antero Resources is 16 percent.
Short interest doesn’t have any immediate impact on a company’s operations or its ability to secure money to keep drilling, Mr. Waytt noted.
It’s more of a signal to the market that investors who are paying attention believe there’s pain ahead.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.