Any business that has sprung up or expanded as a result of the shale boom in Appalachia is fair game for a federal investigation into how its employees are paid.
What began in 2012 with exploration and production companies and their service firms now includes hotels, restaurants and convenience stories and could extend to any industry patronized by oil and gas companies in the Marcellus and Utica shales, said Dan Doherty, assistant district director at the Department of Labor’s wage and hour division in Pittsburgh.
Over the past three years, the department has investigated 395 companies in southwestern Pennsylvania and West Virginia, assessing more than $10 million in back wages, civil penalties and liquidated damages. Of that, it has collected more than $3 million.
Fifteen companies were found to owe more than $100,000 and two owe more than $1 million, according to the agency.
If the preliminary estimate of $2.1 million in back wages and liquidated damages hold — and that is uncertain — Team Environmental of Millwood, W.Va.,would rank at the top of the list. Officials at Team declined to comment as the investigation is still ongoing. Labor Department officials cautioned that amounts can change as the agency continues its evidence gathering. Frequently, what the agency first calculates is revised after discussions with the company further inform its findings.
Another 27 companies are under investigation and the initiative shows no signs of slowing down. The number of firms audited by the Labor Department for such violations has gone up each year and is on pace to set a record high in 2015.
Fair Labor Standards Act violations among these firms tend to fit into two categories: companies that misclassify their workers as exempt from overtime, and companies that give bonuses that aren’t included as part of their wage calculations to help establish a time-and-a-half rate for overtime.
“A lot of times, this isn’t done on purpose,” Mr. Doherty said. “It’s just done.”
He said that nearly all companies change their compensation practices after a Labor Department audit finds violations. But the department is still seeing the same types of violations it encountered at the beginning of its initiative.
Sometimes, the Labor Department’s investigation sparks a civil lawsuit. A group of employees from ProTechnics, a division of Core Laboratories, sued their employer siting the government’s findings that the company owed about $500,000 in back wages after not paying overtime. Core responded that while it began paying overtime to all employees a month after the investigation began, the move was unrelated and the company doesn’t feel it owes back wages.
The Labor Department itself has filed a lawsuit against at least one company it found to be in violation, Horizontal Well Drillers, asking for $115,317.52 in back wages and an equal amount in liquidated damages.
The government agency began its investigation of the Oklahoma-based company’s DuBois office in January 2014. A year later, it filed a lawsuit alleging that employees were promised and paid bonuses for speed and safety and that such bonuses should have been factored into their hourly salary rate from which an overtime rate is calculated.
Excluding them, as Horizontal Well Drillers did, meant paying lower overtime than what the employees were entitled to, the agency argued.
But Horizontal denied that bonuses, which the company said were not guaranteed and weren’t even paid by Horizontal — the oil and gas operators that hired Horizontal as a contractor paid those bonuses and Horizontal simply passed along the cash — aren't salary at all.
The case is in mediation.
While the Fair Labor Standards Act allows the Labor Department to impart liquidated damages on any company found to be in violation of its provisions, investigators have exercised the option only eight times in 141 cases. Half of those targeted subsidiaries of Shaft Drillers International in Mount Morris.
The four companies, MEC Construction, TCB Pipeline, North American Drillers LLC and Coastal Drilling East LLC, were found to owe a combined $143,000 in back wages for paying employees safety bonuses that weren’t incorporated in overtime rate calculations.
Jim Cunningham, general counsel for Shaft, said although the company disagreed with the government interpretation, it was willing to pay the back wages until the Labor Department asked for an additional $143,000 in liquidated damages, which he called “unreasonable and unfair.”
Mr. Doherty and Leni Uddyback-Fortson, regional director for the Labor Department’s office of public affairs, said they couldn’t identify a formula for which companies get hit with liquidated damages.
“Every case is different,” Ms. Uddyback-Fortson said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.