As thousands of Flabeg solar mirrors traveled to a field in Arizona in the spring of 2013, the company that manufactured them went bankrupt.
When the shipper, Mach 1 Global Services, learned of the filing, it used the only leverage it had to get paid: It told the solar developer, NextEra Resources, which desperately needed the mirrors to complete its high-profile Genesis project on federal land in the Mohave Desert, that it would hold on to the merchandise until it received its money.
The solar developer, which had a letter of credit from Flabeg Solar U.S. Corp., tapped into some $3 million of that credit line and handed it over to Mach 1.
The mirrors were installed, NextEra’s project started making electricity in November 2013, and Flabeg’s relationship with one of the nation’s largest solar generators was ruined.
That was inopportune timing as William Otto, the Clinton-based company’s general counsel who became its leader during the bankruptcy, was trying to drum up funding and new business to save the company.
Flabeg’s downfall didn’t hinge on one event, as evidenced by nearly a dozen lawsuits the company has filed against former business partners, U.S. Customs and Border Patrol, and even its own German parent, which itself had become insolvent in April 2013 and was gobbled up by a Saudi energy company in September 2013.
But it didn’t make things any easier that Mach 1, according to Flabeg, violated the halt in payments proscribed by a bankruptcy filing.
Battling in court
Bankruptcy law dictates that when a company files for bankruptcy protection, its vendors can’t demand payments they are owed until the court sorts out who gets paid first and how.
“[Bankruptcy] can make people nervous, but what it's really supposed to do is slow the process down so nobody gets paid before anybody else,” said John Lacher, an attorney at the Downtown office of Robert Lampl, who represents Flabeg. “For the most part, people get it. They stop what they're doing and they wait.”
Flabeg’s current strategy is to sue its way out of debt, blaming its failure to relaunch on a series of moves by business partners who violated bankruptcy protections.
Flabeg says things went south for the company when its German parent, Flabeg GmBH, became insolvent and stopped sending money to its subsidiary, which caused the Clinton-based firm to miss payments to vendors and employees. The company stopped manufacturing in March 2013, and a few weeks later, a group of employees forced it into involuntary bankruptcy under Chapter 7 liquidation.
Mr. Otto had hoped to save the company and had the bankruptcy filing converted into a reorganization proceeding. He sent a salesman to China who came back with a coup: Zhejiang Daming Glass had agreed to buy a $4.3 million unused glass oven for $900,000. The money would give the company a cash infusion to restructure and rebuild, Flabeg said at the time.
The news got better when Daming decided it would fund the reorganization and acquire the solar manufacturer. All this was approved by the bankruptcy court judge in the Western District of Pennsylvania in December.
But the deal fell apart. Daming retracted its offer. Flabeg sued the company and won a $27 million verdict against it, but has not seen a penny of it.
“Having a $27 million judgement is nice if you can collect the money,” said Mr. Lacher. “Otherwise it's something to hang on your wall.”
Even before the Daming blow, Flabeg said it struggled with vendors who wanted to be excused from the automatic stay of bankruptcy.
PPG wanted back the racks it had leased to Flabeg to hold the parabolic mirrors it made. Toyota piled on, saying the Highlander leased by Flabeg’s CEO should be returned immediately.
Buncher Co., which owns the warehouse Flabeg was renting, urged the court to let it evict Flabeg and market the property to other clients. Flabeg objected, claiming it had no other space to store its inventory and equipment and vacating would ruin its chances of staying alive. Buncher eventually won in court. (In February 2014, the Post-Gazette moved some operations into the space).
Even Flabeg’s German parent wanted relief from the bankruptcy stay, claiming Flabeg hadn’t been paying licensing fees for intellectual property and wanting to terminate the licensing agreement.
While the bankruptcy case is still going, Flabeg has sold everything it could. While Mr. Otto declined to talk for this story, Mr. Lacher said he’s still holding out hope for the company restarting in some way.
Preemptive action
Unlike Flabeg, which was forced into bankruptcy and struggled to keep vendors informed and compliant after the fact, Alpha Natural Resources went into its bankruptcy prepared to tackle the fallout.
In its voluminous recent bankruptcy filing, the Virginia-based coal miner anticipated vendors’ panic and asked for a so-called comfort order — a confirmation from the court that it can pay certain suppliers and avoid business interruptions.
“Suppliers … may not understand the impact of [Alpha’s] bankruptcy filing on them,” Alpha wrote, and “may be hesitant to make shipment.”
Alpha highlighted that what it was asking of the court was “noncontroversial and entirely consistent with the applicable provisions of the Bankruptcy Code.”
The court agreed.
“Bankruptcy courts as a rule are inclined to favor a debtor and give it every chance to reorganize at the beginning of the case,” said said Christopher Combest, partner at the Chicago office of Quarles & Brady LLP who works at the firm’s commercial bankruptcy, restructuring and creditors’ rights group.
Counting on that, along with its bankruptcy petition Alpha filed more than a dozen “first day” motions asking for varying degrees of protection for certain business interests: employees, pension recipients, utilities, insurance companies and others.
It also attached a lengthy statement from its CEO, Kevin Crutchfield, outlining why vendors shouldn't panic and, if they do anyway, how the court can make following bankruptcy law more reassuring to them.
“Debtors get very nervous,” Mr. Combest said. “They’re afraid that vendors will stop shipping.”
And even if their violation of the bankruptcy court can be successfully litigated, the immediate impact for a business trying to stay afloat could be fatal, he said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.