It’s the season for oil and gas companies to look at their assets and decide they’re not worth as much as they thought.
Impairments have peppered company earnings over the past year, their mentions getting more frequent and the dollar amounts ballooning as commodity prices continue their descent.
These one-time expenses result from a company’s calculation that the costs it has capitalized to develop its assets are higher than the cash such development would bring in.
The way things are going, 2015 is likely to see the most impairments in the past decade, said Paul O’Donnell, principal equity analyst at IHS Energy.
Already, during the first half of the year, 66 U.S. companies examined by Mr. O’Donnell had nearly $29 billion in impaired assets.
Just one month into the second half of the year, the same group of companies wrote down another $20 billion, which “puts 2015 on track to blow the 2008 peak out of the water,” he said.
When proved reserves — those the company knows are in the ground and have been or can be developed economically — shrink, so does a company’s ability to borrow money, because such reserves are used as collateral for loans, according to Mr. O’Donnell.
“The Marcellus guys actually screened pretty well — they looked safer than the other companies,” he said.
A large part of that is due to the Marcellus’ lower cost to extract gas, as compared to other shale plays around the country.
But “pretty well” is a relative term when it comes to the current state of the oil and gas industry.
Companies react
Chesapeake Energy Corp., once the leading operator in the Marcellus, wrote down $5 billion in assets during the past quarter, bringing its total for the year to $10 billion.
State College-based Rex Energy had an impairment of $117.8 million in the second quarter, writing down dry gas Marcellus assets in Westmoreland and Clearfield counties on lower gas prices.
Consol Energy Inc. usually tests its assets for impairment annually, at the end of each year, but with gas prices falling steadily during the first half of 2015, the Cecil-based energy company began to re-evaluate the value of its reserves during the second quarter and recorded a $828.9 million impairment for those three months, driven by its shallow oil and gas assets in Pennsylvania and West Virginia.
“If gas prices continue to decrease later in 2015, another impairment of these assets, or other natural gas assets, is possible,” the company warned in a public filing.
Consol’s filing was a reminder that several factors can provoke write-downs. Of the $828.9 million charge, about $4 million referred to assets that can’t be developed because New York State has officially banned hydraulic fracturing.
Unlike a state ban, an impairment is irreversible.
“That’s the one thing about an impairment — once you write the asset down, you can never write the asset up,” said Ted Pettko, a shareholder at Schneider Downs. “That’s why a lot of organizations really fight tooth and nail [to avoid them].”
Assessing assets
Taking an impairment doesn’t help a company’s financial situation — it’s not a tactical move cooked up by management to either improve or appear to be improving the balance sheet. Instead, financial regulations require that companies periodically evaluate their assets for impairments, which gives more clarity to investors about the company’s value, the market in which the firm operates and, in some respect, management’s success in picking the right assets to invest in.
Several consecutive quarters of impairments could indicate that a company has a lot of “borderline” assets, Mr. Pettko said. As the price of gas keeps falling and the company’s financial situation keeps worsening, each quarter brings a new standard for what can reasonably be expected to be drilled.
That’s true for the nation as a whole. The Energy Information Administration warned to expect lower reserve estimates for the country’s oil and gas bounty during its 2015 calculation based on lower prices.
Accountants who deal with oil and gas firms estimate that they are pretty evenly split between two methods to capitalize costs that dictate how companies assess impairments. Each formula includes how much has been spent to acquire and develop the assets and how much they’re worth in the market. But one method pins that worth on the projected future price of oil or natural gas and the other uses the average of the previous 12 months.
Because oil and natural gas prices have been falling over the past two years, the companies that use futures prices started recording impairments first. Those that looked backward had the cushion of the previous years.
Southwestern Energy — whose CEO Steven Mueller proudly bucked the trend of cutting rigs in the dry gas Fayetteville Shale, dropped $5 billion to buy more Marcellus acreage, and told the New York Times in December that he’s glad to have all this gas to himself with other operators curbing their enthusiasm — recorded a $1.5 billion impairment in the second quarter. He warned of more to come in the third and fourth quarters.
Mr. Mueller told analysts last month that the Marcellus Shale in West Virginia and, to a lesser extent in Northeastern Pennsylvania, was responsible for about 20 percent of the impairment.
Another variable is expiring leases.
One of the Marcellus’ most prolific producers, the Texas-based company that proved the field’s potential over a decade ago, has written down more nearly $100 million worth of assets over the past two years, with much of it attributed to letting leases expire on acreage that hasn’t been drilled yet.The past quarter was the first time that Range Resources didn’t post such an impairment in the past two years.
Downtown-based EQT Corp. attributed about half of its $28.4 million impairment during the first half of this year to leases that lapsed.
And despite boasting the best producing well ever drilled in the Utica Shale — EQT announced in July that its first dry Utica well in Greene County had the highest initial rate of production in the industry — the company has also recorded a $4.3 million impairment for its Utica reserves in Ohio.
This follows a $162 million Utica write-down from the last three months of 2014, when EQT executives said they were changing course in the Utica and dropping their drilling program on low gas prices and significantly worse results than they originally expected.
Banks weigh in
There’s another threat looming for oil and gas companies, warned Wade Stubblefield, managing director at Texas-based Opportune LLP.
Twice a year, banks redetermine the borrowing base for oil and gas companies, and that calculation relies heavily on what prices are expected to be in the future and how much of a company’s reserves could be developed at those prices.
That’s a lot more likely to weigh on a company’s share price than an impairment, he said, because it will impact how much capital is available to an operator to keep operating and pay down escalating debt.
“We’ve been seeing a lot of borrowing base redeterminations,” he said. “What the banks are doing is saying — most of the borrowing base is based on producing reserves.”
Now, with prices dropping, those producing reserves aren’t yielding the same revenue as before. Plus, companies are finally starting to curb drilling so they’re not replacing depleting production at the same rate.
“People are going to start getting some exponential haircuts on how much they can borrow,” Mr. Stubblefield said. “They’re going to be in a credit crunch.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.