A Westinghouse project — most likely the nuclear company’s construction of the first AP1000 reactors in China — was among the most egregious examples of how Toshiba overstated profits and downplayed losses, according to investigators.

The Japanese giant, which owns 87 percent of Cranberry-based Westinghouse Electric Co., released the results of an independent investigation into its accounting practices last week, but the report was only recently translated into English. Toshiba hired an independent team to perform the investigation.

The much anticipated document revealed that Toshiba overstated profits by $1.2 billion over a six-year period ended in 2014. More than half a dozen company executives and board members resigned as a result, including the CEO.

The Westinghouse project that is examined in the report began in 2007 and was supposed to become operational starting 2013. Investigators did not name the project but the dates given match closely the timeline for AP1000 construction at Sanmen, China. The contract was for $7.6 billion.

Advertise with us

Westinghouse told its parent that design changes and delays added $385 million to the budget during the second quarter of 2013 and another $401 million in the third quarter.

Toshiba instead booked the additional costs at $69 million and $293 million for the two quarters for no apparent reason, according to the investigators.

The company’s auditor, Ernst & Young ShinNihon, noticed the discrepancy but treated it as an uncorrected misstatement, which means that correcting it would not have a material effect on the company’s finances and therefore was not required.

In the independent report, investigators raised the possibility that Toshiba’s president, upon seeing Westinghouse’s overruns, ordered a cost review of the project’s spending, motivating corporate finance and accounting staff to reduce the amount “through unsubstantiated cost reduction measures, based on an intention to avoid recording losses in the consolidated financial statements of that quarter and postpone that until a subsequent period.”

The company’s president and CFO wanted the cost increases to be limited to $69 million in the second quarter.

Advertise with us

The following quarter, the president and CFO, likely wanting to avoid recording a loss, essentially made up a figure — $293 million.

“A corporate culture existed at Toshiba whereby employees could not act contrary to the intent of their superiors,” the investigators wrote in reference to all of Toshiba’s inappropriate accounting practices.

Company leaders issued “challenges” to their subordinates to bring costs in line with the budget at the end of each quarter, motivating some businesses to delay booking losses.

The revisions for Westinghouse postponed recording losses but didn’t impact year-end financial statements, investigators noted.

At a press conference earlier this month, Toshiba’s CFO stressed that Westinghouse profits have grown in the nine years since it was acquired, due to the nuclear company’s maintenance and fuel supply businesses.

Advertise with us

With $14.7 billion in sales last year, Toshiba’s energy and infrastructure segment, which includes Westinghouse, makes up 26 percent of the company’s revenue. Toshiba paid $5.4 billion for Westinghouse in 2006 and has insisted that the acquisition has been good for its business.

But in light of the investigation’s results, analysts contend it might be necessary to write down what they view are inflated assets and goodwill for the nuclear company.

In an earnings call in January, Keizo Maeda, an executive and board member who resigned after the investigation report was made public July 20, said that Westinghouse has yielded about $2 billion for Toshiba.

“The maintenance service will grow and the share of our fuel business will expand as well,” he promised. “So, we are sure that our operating income and the margin will continue to expand.”

He said on the conference call that a “one-time cost overrun, which was a loss from last year” associated with construction in China wasn’t likely to recur.

Advertise with us

“Once we get the acceptance of the customers, we can just copy and make more. So, the first unit could be challenging, because it will be a first of a kind,” he said. “So, we are confident that from unit two and onward, the costs would be lower and stabilized.”

That has, so far, not been the case with Westinghouse’s second batch of AP1000 nuclear reactors currently under construction in Georgia. That project is more than $1 billion over budget, with Westinghouse and the utility that commissioned the reactor fighting in court over who will bear the extra cost.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.