Non-petroleum fuels are being used for transportation in amounts not seen in 60 years, according to federal data.
Alternative fuels — ethanol, natural gas and electricity — have more than doubled their share of the transportation sector since the mid-2000s and now make up 8.5 percent of the market, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.
But trends have changed in the last six decades. In the 1950s, the petroleum use soared along with the popularity of cars while the use of coal in locomotives declined. Now, growth in non-petroleum fuels is being spurred by federal mandates on alternative fuels.
Ethanol is now a standard addition to gasoline — about 13 billion gallons of ethanol were added in the U.S. last year, according to the EIA. The Environmental Protection Agency in May announced further goals to require refiners to up the use of biofuels to 16.3 billion gallons this year.
Yet in the case of other fuels — natural gas and electricity — passenger cars are not the ones driving growth. In fact, sales have stalled, some of which can be explained by competition from lower gasoline prices.
Natural gas vehicle adoption slow
In general, natural gas used for transportation has been climbing. Usage neared 1 quadrillion British thermal units last year, beating previous records and making up about 3.5 percent of all natural gas used, according to government data. But that trend isn’t necessarily being seen in personal vehicles. Those levels can be largely attributed to pipelines and compressor stations that use natural gas to operate while shipping the commodity from the wellhead to market, according to the EIA.
While natural gas used in vehicles has doubled since 2000, according to the report, adoption of such vehicles has been slow.
There are about 153,000 natural gas vehicles on U.S. roads, of which 87,000 are light-duty vehicles like passenger cars, mostly comprising business and government fleets, according to Natural Gas Vehicles for America (NGVAmerica), a Washington, D.C.-based advocacy organization.
Overall, the production and sale of natural gas vehicles fell by 6.5 percent in 2014. While larger vehicles like shuttles, box trucks and garbage trucks sold well, producers sold only 6,650 light-duty vehicles in 2014, 3,500 less than in 2013, NGVAmerica noted.
Pushing into sales of alternative vehicles is competition from plummeting gasoline prices.
“The price of oil has sort of hurt the marketplace this year,” said Matthew Godlewski, NGVAmerica president. “Where oil has fallen, there’s been a corresponding drop in diesel and gasoline prices. That’s certainly put some people on the sidelines in the [marketplace].”
Despite lower oil prices, Mr. Godlewski sees promise in a market where natural gas prices are largely determined by the U.S.’s own production, rather than an oil market in which prices are more dependent on the world stage.
“The future’s bright, and a lot of this is based on the long-term availability and affordability of natural gas in the U.S.,” Mr. Godlewski said.
Still, it’s a rocky road.
“We don’t see a lot of interest in [natural gas vehicles],” said Jessica Caldwell, director of industry analysis at Edmunds.com, a website providing tools and analysis on buying vehicles. “[It’s] not something that is on consumers’ minds.”
Another hurdle is the relative lack of natural gas fueling stations compared to the abundance of gasoline stations.
In the U.S., there are 833 public compressed natural gas stations, 33 of which are in Pennsylvania, according to the U.S. Department of Energy’s Alternative Fuel Data Center.
Of those public stations, nine are in the Pittsburgh area, according to Rick Price, executive director of the DOE’s Pittsburgh Region Clean Cities coalition, an organization that works to reduce U.S. reliance on petroleum for transportation.
Electric vehicle sales decline
Retail sales of electricity for transportation grew more than 40 percent between 2000 and 2014, according to the EIA. Operations related to railways and railroads make up a significant portion of these sales, but the report does not break down the amount of electricity used to actually power vehicles, as it does in the case for ethanol and natural gas.
Within 25 miles of Pittsburgh alone, there are more than 55 different public electric stations with almost 100 public charging hookups, according to Mr. Price. Electricity use in cars is a bit harder to gauge because electric charging stations are often connected to meters on sites where charging vehicles isn’t separated from other uses, EIA noted.
But recent sales are lagging. While sales of fully electric and hybrid vehicles made up 3.3 percent of new car sales in the first quarter of 2014, they made up only 2.7 percent of sales in the same time this year, according to Edmunds.com.
In 2015, only 45 percent of trade-ins of hybrid or electric vehicles have seen swaps for other vehicles using alternative fuels, falling below 50 percent for the first time, Edmunds.com noted.
“[Lower gasoline prices have] taken the sheen off of these vehicles, but … it’s also taken the sheen off small cars in general,” Ms. Caldwell said. “That’s kind of where it is right now. Automakers are having trouble selling all cars.”
In Pennsylvania, the Department of Environmental Protection has also seen declining numbers of rebates that it offers to residents who purchase new alternative fuel vehicles, such as plug-in electric, natural gas, and propane vehicles.
In 2013, about 700 rebates were claimed, of which almost 500 were given for plug-in hybrid Chevy Volts and electric-powered Teslas. In 2014, that number dropped to just over 460 rebates, of which almost 300 were for Volts and Teslas. So far in 2015, distributed rebates are hovering at just over 140, of which almost 100 are for Volts and Teslas.
“People seem unwilling to buy a car that only goes 40 or 50 miles to a charge, even people whose commute is 8 miles,” said Illah Nourbakhsh, a professor of robotics at Carnegie Mellon University. Mr. Nourbakhsh, the director of the university’s CREATE Lab, works to make electric vehicles more practical and affordable through a project called ChargeCar.
“We have a cultural problem in which we expect every car in our family to serve all purposes,” Mr. Nourbakhsh said. “We need people to remember that when you buy a pickup truck, you’re buying a pickup truck for hauling things. You don’t buy it for all five of you to go comfortably to the Grand Canyon.”
Even so, in the long-term, electric vehicle sales are expected to rise.
According to the EIA’s 2015 Annual Energy Outlook, vehicles using electricity will capture about 7 percent of new car sales by 2040.
Braden Kelner: bradenkelner@gmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.