As shale gas operators in the Marcellus have been saying for the past year, more sand is going into the ground in Pennsylvania to keep fractures open while gas flows out. And, consequently, more sand is coming out of the ground, along with the gush of flowback water that streams out of wells just after they're fracked.

That’s evident from the latest waste production data released by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection.

In 2011, companies reported disposing of about 14,500 tons of flowback sand, DEP records show. Last year, that number exceeded 43,000 tons.

That's despite the fact that 1,957 shale wells were started in 2011, while only 1,373 began development in 2014.

Advertise with us

“Our people are using more sand, everybody is using more sand,” said Rodney Waller, senior vice president with Texas-based Range Resources, at an industry conference in October.

Fracturing sand, extracted from silica mines in states including Wisconsin and Minnesota, is a fine grain that can withstand a certain amount of pressure, as set by industry standards.

Several Marcellus Shale players have begun to put numbers on their sand use growth.

Rex Energy Corp., a State College company whose main focus is in Butler County, has more than doubled the amount of sand it uses for each foot of its horizontal wells, while at the same time increasing how long those horizontal sections stretch out by 30 percent in the last five years.

The operator also reported a significant improvement in how wells produced during their first month on the job and a decrease in how quickly their production tapered off during the first year.

Advertise with us

Improvement did come at a price though, Rex said. While an average, conventional frack job cost the company about $4.7 million in 2010, its “Super-Frac” strategy is running closer to $6 million a pop this year.

Companies now measure well economics by the foot and, for all the Marcellus operators that talk about it, the cost to complete a new well has decreased — even one with much longer horizontal sections, many more frack stages and a lot more sand.

Cabot Oil & Gas Corp., for example, boosted its sand use by 71 percent, on a per foot basis, since 2011, while decreasing completion costs by 32 percent, the Texas-based operator reported late last year.

Over the past year, increased sand usage has predictably spurred logistical issues — not just in getting the fine mesh sand to well sites, which requires more truck and train trips, but also in hauling the resulting flowback sand to disposal facilities.

The vast majority of the sand recovered from shale wells last year went to landfills, and of that, about 51 percent traveled to out-of-state facilities. About 500 tons, a small fraction, was shipped to landfills in Utah and Michigan, which specialize in handling low-level radioactive waste.

Advertise with us

The newly-released DEP data likely underestimates the volume of sand that is flowing back from well sites, as some operators may include sand in their flowback fluid reporting rather than breaking it out as a separate item.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.