The unusual custody battle between North Shore Energy Services and Texas-based Jordan Manufacturing Consulting revolves around two 17-ton boxes that each party has accused the other of kidnapping at various points during their rocky relationship.

That conflict culminated with North Shore’s bankruptcy earlier this month, after Jordan asked a federal court to assign possession of the so-called Brine Boxes to the manufacturer that built them, in the hope that it would be more successful at marketing the products to shale gas producers than North Shore has been over the past year.

North Shore, the Pittsburgh-based inventor of the technology behind these mobile treatment units to handle water produced during the hydraulic fracturing process, has been focusing on the Eagle Ford and Utica shales recently. To date, it hasn’t seen a penny in revenue, though it has tested the units at several sites and operated some of them either at a loss or in exchange for in-kind services at others.

Ray Jordan, president of Jordan Manufacturing Consulting (JMC), says if North Shore couldn’t find paying customers during the height of shale exploration in Texas in late 2013, it isn’t likely to succeed now that oil has dropped 50 percent in the last six months, and oil and gas companies have drastically cut their drilling programs.

Advertise with us

“Both of those boxes were out there during the peak time of oil exploration,” Mr. Jordan said.

If not then, then when, he asked.

North Shore’s founder and chief technology officer Michael Havelka predictably sees the situation from a completely different angle.

“When there’s plenty of money to drill, they don’t really watch their ‘P’s and ‘Q’s and how much [they spend] on water,” he said. “Before this downturn in pricing, people were less likely to think about water recycling. When everybody’s looking your shoulder, we start to look better.”

That’s why North Shore filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on Feb. 6, Mr. Havelka said, so that its protracted dispute with JMC would finally be forced to resolve, and it can take advantage of the opportunities in the field without the legal threat from its manufacturer.

Advertise with us

“It’s difficult to attract investors, it’s difficult to attract customers when you have this lawsuit hanging over your head,” he said.

Mr. Havelka said the lawsuit, filed last year in a federal court in Texas, and North Shore’s bankruptcy aren’t about industry dynamics but rather a standard contract dispute between two business partners who stopped seeing eye-to-eye.

Their relationship began in 2013, when Mr. Havelka was introduced to Mr. Jordan through a mutual acquaintance.

North Shore, which Mr. Havelka founded after a similar company, Sweetwater Resources dissolved without results, was looking for both a fabricator and for financing for its Brine Box idea. Mr. Jordan, who’s said he’s been working in the oil and gas industry his entire career, agreed to serve in both roles. He agreed to loan North Shore $800,000, most of which was supposed to go right back to him for the cost of manufacturing, and $240,000 of which would go to North Shore for overhead and operational expenses. The loan was in the form of a convertible note, meaning Mr. Jordan could convert the debt into a 20 percent interest in North Shore.

The Brine Box is designed to remove solids, hydrocarbons and bacteria out of flowback and produced water in the hydraulic fracturing process, leaving only dissolved salt that is used to weigh down the fluid.

Advertise with us

Companies typically add agents to their fluid to make it heavier, which helps in drilling and in fracking at high depths.

The first unit was completed in October 2013. North Shore built a relationship with a Midland, Texas water service firm Big D Companies, which had master service agreements with at least half a dozen shale gas operators that North Shore said were interested in trying out its Brine Boxes. The first box was moved onto a site owned by Pioneer Natural Resources in the Permian Basin and ran there for a month.

The second Brine Box was finished in December 2013, but Mr. Jordan, who had become suspicious of North Shore’s business dealings with potential clients and how they were represented to him, did not give it up.

“The only reason I did this was they told me they had business lined up to put the boxes to work,” Mr. Jordan said. “And nothing ever materialized. I kept asking who were they talking to, and the story kept changing.”

In early spring of last year, Mr. Jordan went to visit the owner of Big D and, according to North Shore, set out to destroy the relationship between the two companies. Court documents allege that Mr. Jordan blamed a leak in the Brine Box on faulty design, said that North Shore owed him more than $900,000 and that the Pittsburgh company lied to him about pricing and contracts.

Advertise with us

When he returned from that trip, Mr. Jordan convinced a court to confiscate the Brine Box from the Pioneer-run site, which North Shore claims destroyed its relationship with the operator, Big D, and, by extension, dimmed any prospects for contracts with other operators in the region.

After a few more months of legal fights, a federal judge ordered both Brine Boxes released to North Shore, which now has one stationed in the Eagle Ford shale in Texas and another, dormant, in Ohio’s Utica Shale.

Neither has yielded any revenue, Mr. Jordan complained, so earlier this month, he asked the court for custody.

“Let us have the boxes. Let me see what I can do with them. That’s what we’re asking the judge,” Mr. Jordan said. “I think that’s what spurred the bankruptcy filing.”

North Shore’s bankruptcy petition, intended to halt Mr. Jordan’s request and give the company time to reorganize, lists 20 investors, many of them local individuals, and total debts of about $1.3 million.

Advertise with us

Mr. Havelka sees the move as a way to gain some distance from JMC and Mr. Jordan and strengthen the relationships he’s said he’s been building with operators and service companies in Pennsylvania, Ohio and Texas.

“We want to move forward, so the only way to do it is the known versus the unknown,” Mr. Havelka said. “You make the filing, you reorganize and you move forward.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.