A few months ago, I got called out on the opinion page of The Wall Street Journal for engaging in “grade inflation” when it comes to attributing evil to former president and unindicted insurrectionist Donald Trump.
Conservative columnist Lance Morrow accused me, other progressive writers and even Mr. Trump himself of “toss[ing] around the word evil in a mindless way” like Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck “disputing whether it is ‘duck season’ or ‘wabbit season.’ ”
Mr. Morrow devoted an entire paragraph to my Aug. 13 column “Sympathy for the Devil,” so it only seems right that I quote him in full and reciprocate:
“The other day, Tony Norman, a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette columnist, got warmed up by referring to Mr. Trump as ‘the twice-impeached abomination of desolation.’ In his next reference, the former U.S. president was ‘Satan’ (a bit of a letdown) and, after that, ‘the Antichrist.’ He left out ‘Prince of Darkness.’ Gasping down the home stretch, he described Mr. Trump’s base as a “death cult,” subscribers to his ‘End Times fever dream.’”
Earlier in his column, Mr. Morrow dismissed the Rolling Stones and Joan Didion during an equally weird tangent, so I guess I’m in good company. He quoted me correctly, but only in the way someone who does the minimal amount required to be technically truthful quotes someone they disagree with.
Perhaps Mr. Morrow was in such a rush to get back to the ridiculous premise of his column (don’t call anyone evil unless they have a body count as high as Hitler’s) that he completely missed the fact that I was satirizing the End Times lingo and hypocrisy of Trump’s QAnon-curious evangelical base. He missed the whole conceit of the column, which was a sendup of the pin-the-tail-on-the-Antichrist theology so many Christians are obsessed with.
Let me put it this way: What I was saying is that by the standards of End Times preachers and prophets who predicted his re-election, Donald Trump, whose son-in-law owns the 666 Fifth Avenue Building in midtown Manhattan, would be considered the literal Antichrist of a premillennial soap opera.
For those who fail to get my sarcasm, I’m fully aware that the Antichrist is a fictitious character and a construct of American civil religion crossed with bad 19th-century theology. I don’t believe there is a literal Antichrist, past, present or future. Mr. Trump simply displays all of the characteristics of that cartoonish, uniquely American character.
When I refer to Mr. Trump as the Abomination of Desolation, I’m simply borrowing hyperbolic language from the Bible to make a point folks with an End Times mentality or a modicum of biblical literacy will be amused or scandalized by. Donald Trump isn’t clever enough to be the Antichrist, the False Prophet or the Whore of Babylon if any of those characters actually existed. By coincidence, he fits the shoes of the fictional Antichrist better than any other candidate of the last 40 years has, but many conservative Christians are reluctant to call him out because they like his anti-Christian policies.
Generally, I think biblical language is tailor-made for exploitation by columnists because it is hyperbolic, full of wonderful imagery and powerful psychic associations that reverberate for thousands of years. Why reinvent the wheel when I can steal an image or phrase from Isaiah or Revelation?
I take my cues from a certain itinerant preacher who referred to the religious hypocrites of his day as “whitewashed tombs” and a “brood of vipers” when he wasn’t calling them “blind guides,” “sons of Satan” or, in Peter’s case — “Satan.”
Jesus, who was obviously engaging in first-century-grade inflation hyperbole, didn’t have to worry about the random yapping of a Wall Street Journal opinion writer taking him literally when he excoriated Jerusalem’s religious leaders for walking around with logs in their eyes while trying remove specks from their brothers’.
Mr. Morrow is correct that I never got around to referring to Donald Trump in my August column as “The Prince of Darkness.” That’s only because I consider that term among the hoariest of cliches.
Had Mr. Morrow bothered to Google my columns over the last five years, he would’ve seen that I have managed to compare Mr. Trump to Beelzebub, Mephistopheles, Baal, Lucifer, the Golden Calf, the Lord of the Flies, a failed Faustian deal-maker, a Manchurian candidate, and anything else I could think of that remotely rhymes with “orange.”
Once I’ve completely run out of biblical and literary references and my thesaurus has turned to dust, maybe I’ll circle back to “Prince of Darkness” if I can’t think of any other words or phrases that combine Trumpian mendacity with spiritual depravity.
But I take Lance Morrow’s overall point that, in general, those of us on the left as well as the right are far too quick to use the term “evil.” I disagree with his conclusion that a body count on par with Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot or Mao is the only legitimate basis for such a comparison and that every other reference is too glib. It’s ridiculous to suggest that only a select number of people in history are worthy of being called evil.
Evil is a hyperlocal phenomena these days and comes in all dimensions and sizes. It’s everywhere. It’s especially prevalent in the American evangelical subculture that supports Mr. Trump’s “Big Lie” that the election was stolen by Satan-worshipping Democrats. This QAnon-influenced personality cult also believes Mr. Trump will be reinstated to office with the late John Kennedy Jr., who died in a plane crash decades ago, as his vice president.
I can tick off a bunch of evil things that just happened in the evangelical world in the last year that I consider evil with a capital “E.” These are the sorts of things to which Jesus would have said, “Physician, heal thyself” had they happened in Palestine 2,000 years ago.
• A quarter of white evangelicals believe the core QAnon conspiracy theory is true, and that percentage is growing.
• A handful of influential megachurch preachers who cast doubt on vaccinations have succumbed to COVID-19.
• Franklin Graham and a very small group of ministry leaders have been denounced for advocating vaccines. Even Donald Trump has been dissed by the normally fawning Candace Owens for not understanding how to do “independent research” into vaccine efficacy. Alex Jones sneered that Trump is either “ignorant or the most evil man who has ever lived” just because he wants people to get vaccinated. That’s evil.
• Moral failures (re: adultery, financial chicanery, racism, exploitation of congregations, bullying congregants) are finally catching up to once unaccountable leaders who really shouldn’t have been wagging their fingers at the Catholic Church for its pedophile priests scandal. Google Christian apologetics star Ravi Zacharias if you want to be amazed by the range of the criminality he got away with. Right now, an alleged gang rape that took place at Liberty University in 2005 is finally being taken seriously enough to be investigated. Leaders have been forced to step down from big name ministries like Hillsong and Mars Hill over the last year. It’s disgusting how long these creeps were tolerated and protected. That’s evil.
• The fact that some churches have begun to have gun giveaways to attract more men to services. One pastor has offered to provide COVID vaccine exemption paperwork to the unvaccinated in exchange for tithes. It’s too dumb to even be called the selling of indulgences.
• The mingling of Jesus and Trump 2020 flags at the Capitol insurrection on Jan. 6. The fact that a centaur led the insurrectionists in prayer in the ransacked Senate chamber and that a majority of conservative Christians consider the attempt to topple the government a righteous act by Christian patriots.
• Churches hosting political rallies where “Let’s go, Brandon” is chanted to the rafters. Pastors sentenced to many years in prison for stealing PPP money and spending it on luxury cars and property. A prominent Seventh Day Adventist pastor who tells his congregants that raping one’s wife is scripturally approved. A website devoted to the celebrity clothing and sneakers of materialistic pastors.
And last but not least: Donald Trump Jr. telling young conservatives at a recent rally that turning the other cheek as Jesus instructed has “gotten us nothing.” The younger Mr. Trump suggests a more muscular, masculine version of Christianity that kicks butt and takes names is called for. Of course, he’s too clueless to realize that that’s a message millions of American Christians have already assimilated. That’s why they love the Abomination of Desolation so much.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.