There was plenty of chardonnay and pinot grigio, but no absinthe at the Wednesday evening preview for the “Immersive Van Gogh” exhibit. There were hors d’oeuvres for every Yinzer taste, but no truffles as hundreds of people — many decked in their most elegant finery — filled a section of the North Side’s Lighthouse Artspace Pittsburgh while the show in the main gallery was being prepared for them.

Just inside the entrance, VIPs posed for selfies and group shots in front of a cleverly shaped reproduction of a Steelers’ football helmet composed of vibrant yellow sunflowers with the legend “Gogh Pittsburgh” spelled out. A few feet away is a reproduction of “Starry Night Over the Rhone” featuring one of the imposing yellow towers of the Roberto Clemente Bridge superimposed on that iconic landscape.

Many witty things were said in the hour before the show officially began, but nothing happened that would’ve evoked a scene from a decadent Parisian salon in the 1870s. Instead of spontaneous recitations of Baudelaire or Rimbaud by pretentious scoundrels determined to scandalize the vaccinated bourgeoisie, we learned that Pittsburgh is the 14th American city to host this show and that 3.2 million tickets have been sold, making it more popular than a Taylor Swift tour, a spokesperson for the show assured us.

Even those who have a hard time differentiating a Van Gogh from a Norman Rockwell know that the famed painter sold only one canvas during his lifetime and that was to his enthusiastic patron and brother, Theo. Van Gogh would not have been able to wrap his head around the fact that the rejection he experienced from the art establishment and the public during the waning years of the 19th-century would eventually give way to mass adulation and record-setting bidding wars that have generated hundreds of millions, if not billions at auction houses since his death.

Advertise with us

And even if the Dutch-born painter had foreseen that the combined worth of paintings he stuffed carelessly in closets, under his bed or stored at his brother’s home would eventually rival the GNP of small nations, he wouldn’t have had any frame of reference for dealing with his work being projected onto the walls of a 33,000-square-foot warehouse and synced to music that approximates the various moods of his paintings.

An experience like “Immersive Van Gogh” would’ve simultaneously thrilled and disconcerted Van Gogh because he understood more than anyone how each brush stroke represents an unintended glimpse into the volatility and terror of his inner world. To see them magnified for all the world to see would’ve triggered him to no end. Van Gogh’s mental illness may have given him the visual language to bestow the priceless gift of his paintings to the world, but his brushstrokes weren’t beautiful abstractions to him. Each brushstroke represents the relentless stabbing of his own soul necessary to speak deeper truths. It also left him incredibly vulnerable.

“Immersive Van Gogh” is a beautiful and technically impressive show that somehow tames the original chaos just enough for a generation of admirers safely ensconced in bubbles of irony more than a century removed to relate to those paintings in new ways. While it pales in comparison to the experience of standing before and marveling at actual Van Gogh paintings, it delivers similar thrills in its ability to synthesize and deconstruct what is most interesting about that singular experience.

It is a thrill to see the swirling sun of “Wheat Fields with a Reaper” rolling slowly across the horizon of the exhibit’s walls, but what would the original painter have thought of seeing what was formerly fixed on the surface of a canvas liberated so definitively from its own sky? What would he have thought of seeing “Cypresses” in a new context or elements from “The Bedroom” remixed and reorganized?

Whatever his feelings about the intervention of technology into the sacred space of his fever dreams, Van Gogh surely would’ve been gratified by the iconic role his “Starry Night” plays in the show and in the imaginations of millions of people. He would’ve recognized the despair and malaise in the faces of the dispossessed in “The Potato Eaters” and been outraged again. He would have marveled at the casual beauty of the woman’s face extracted from the canvas of “In the Cafe: Agostina Segatori in Le Tambourin.” The recurring images of “Sunflowers” and “Still Life with Bible” might have prompted him to thank God for allowing him to retain his capacity for wonder even in the modern world.

Advertise with us

Van Gogh was never a cool and detached observer. He was a man of faith and many, many doubts who struggled with the contradictory passions that ran through his brain like a violent river overflowing its banks. He gave the unruly spirits that bedeviled him space to express reality as he saw it beneath the neurosis of respectability. For Van Gogh, the world was constantly ablaze in halos of swirling primary and secondary colors. His brushstrokes acted as a medium to that world; to paint was to participate in a fiery seance where the invisible spirits always have the upper hand.

It’s amazing to see how fast all of the usual banalities of a visit to a major art exhibition fade once a show of this magnitude grips you. The sight of folks with cell phones trying to snatch their piece of a simulacra that is itself a copy many generations removed is goofy to the point of irritation, but it isn’t long before everyone settles into a posture of quiet reverence.

Maybe the artful soundtrack by Luca Longobardi manages an act of mass hypnosis. Perhaps the sheer spectacle of the exhibit’s designer Massimiliano Siccardi is enough to subliminally beat the self-centeredness out of us, leaving us little choice but to slowly allow the paintings to overwhelm us in that new context.

It occurred to me at one point that I was surrounded by people who would’ve put their hands on a stack of bibles and swore that they would’ve been the other person besides Theo who would’ve instantly recognized Van Gogh’s genius in real time. What’s not to love about those brushstrokes? What’s not to celebrate in those vivid, violent and beautiful colors? The truth is that before we were taught to love Van Gogh, his work would’ve repelled us because it was too real, too alive and too intense.

The irony of Vincent Van Gogh is that everyone is always fated to love him after he’s dead and no longer capable of confronting us in real time with his dour Calvinism, his boorishness and his manic insights into the human condition. We can only deal with him if he “shuts up and paints.”

Advertise with us

It never occurs to us that our appetite for Van Gogh has been mediated through decades of rationalizing, curation and reassessment by an art establishment shamed that it misunderstood the Impressionists and the Post-Impressionists the first time around. Subsequently, the art world, aided by auction houses, museum networks and wealthy collectors have made Van Gogh, Degas, Monet, Renoir, Manet, Gauguin and their 19th-century contemporaries the avatars of the most popular art movement of the last two centuries.

Driving home from the North Side to the East End on Wednesday night, I sorted through my feelings about the show. A full moon hung high over the city. I imagined the swirls Van Gogh saw when he looked at that same moon more than a century ago while traipsing late at night through the golden wheat fields of Arles, lost in thought about his purpose in life and wondering why he was cursed with the ability to spot all the burning fires in the bones of the world.

I kept thinking about Van Gogh’s brushstrokes as I marveled at the moon’s radiant majesty. It suddenly hit me that roughly 4-5 billion years ago, our sun emerged from the mass of swirling gas in the still young universe that exploded into existence 9 billion years earlier and that our planet, an amalgam of dust and fire was born shortly after that.

It would take hundreds of millions of years for the creatures that arose from primordial dust and a long gestation in the seas to develop the ability to perceive and appreciate that starry firmament that so captivated Van Gogh. But there’s no mistaking the tell-tale signature of reality that Van Gogh taught us to look for. If you look intently enough, you can’t miss the reality that the night skies are ablaze with the brushstrokes of the infinite.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.