Everything about Marlin Woods, the 48-year-old East Liberty resident who entered the race for mayor of Pittsburgh in early June, feels spontaneous, intentional and accidental at the same time.

While pundits and oddsmakers pronounced state Rep. Ed Gainey the likely next mayor of Pittsburgh after his upset win over incumbent Bill Peduto in the Democratic primary in May, Mr. Woods, the CEO of BenefitsPLUS, a health benefits consulting firm he founded, chose to enter the race as an Independent with little name recognition outside of business and corporate circles.

Mr. Woods still has paperwork to get out of the way despite his declaration of intent to become Pittsburgh’s next mayor. He has yet to file nomination papers and petitions by the Aug. 2 deadline to get on the ballot with the names of at least 1,167 residents — 2% of the highest vote cast during the last election. William Parker, another mayoral candidate tweeted out a copy of his filing receipt last week laying claim to the Independent slot on the November ballot. Mr. Woods said he will have more than enough signatures soon and will rebrand his candidacy as “Your Pittsburgh Choice.” His campaign literature and website will reflect this change.

The hiccup of how he previously described himself aside, Mr. Woods believes he will join Mr. Gainey, Republican candidate Tony Moreno and Mr. Parker on the ballot as the moderate alternative to all of them. Whatever name his campaign settles on, he retains an unshakeable faith in himself and his place in the grand scheme of regional politics. That’s what makes Marlin Woods such a fascinating character despite the long odds against him. He’s unknown, but he acts as if he’s waited his turn for years to be mayor.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh last elected a mayor who wasn’t endorsed or backed by the Democratic machine in 1977, when Richard Caliguiri ran and won as an Independent Democrat. By contrast, a Republican hasn’t ascended to the mayor’s office in Pittsburgh since 1933 when John S. Herron did the honors, a factoid that should keep newly-declared Republican Mr. Moreno up at night.

Mr. Woods, who has never sought or held elected office, is challenging Mr. Gainey as a virtual unknown who insists he’s driven more by a sense of mission than career aspiration.

Mr. Woods insists he’s not running as a Democrat-turned-Independent like Caliguiri did more than 40 years ago. He’s adamant that what seems like an act of hubris rooted in opportunism to bemused observers on social media is pure conviction on his part.

Marlin Woods says he first began having what he calls ‘sensations’ or ‘premonitions’ about the mayor’s office back in 2016, so jumping into the mayoral race isn’t a response to Mr. Gainey’s upset victory over Mr. Peduto per se. Whether it was Mr. Peduto or Mr. Gainey or someone else, he said he was determined to make a run for the office.

Marlin Woods, independent candidate for Pittsburgh mayor, kisses son Marlin Jr.’s hand at the family’s East Liberty home on Thursday evening with his family. Also in the picture are, from left, wife Jessica Brooks Woods; daughter Zi, 7; son Jessie, 14; daughter Jace, 9. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

What looks spontaneous from afar is actually the latest stage of a plan Mr. Woods says he’s followed for half a decade. If anything he says only half joking, Mr. Gainey is the late comer to the mayoral race.

Advertise with us

“I’ve been committed to running as an independent candidate for mayor of Pittsburgh since 2017,” Mr. Woods said after being prompted by his wife, Jessica Brooks-Woods in the living room of their spacious East Liberty home.

“My good friend, Ed Gainey, was one of the first to know I was running. He’s known for three years — since 2018,” Mr. Woods said, intent on debunking what he calls the false narrative that he’s been put up to run by white business interests as a foil against Mr. Gainey, a politician he’s supported as a constituent and at the ballot box.

“I’ve been running before anyone else in this race,” he said, adding that he has been “quietly, but actively campaigning” ever since he became convinced that his moment had arrived.

Mr. Woods also rejects the conventional wisdom that he’s a spoiler candidate who will split the Black vote and make it possible for Mr. Moreno now running as a Republican after losing the Democratic primary, to slip into office on a tide of white voter alarm over the possibility of Pittsburgh electing its first Black mayor. Mr. Woods has heard these scenarios before and rejects them all.

“The notion that white Republicans or white business leaders put me up against Ed [Gainey] is entirely false,” he said. “I’m not running to make a statement or to raise my profile for another run later on,” he said addressing another rumor that he’s engaging in a test-run for the office. “I’m in it to win. I’m going to win.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Woods believes the path to the mayor’s office begins with asking what Pittsburghers want from their leader. He says it is presumptuous to dictate to the people from on high. “It’s about community conversation with people,” he said. “I’m here to do the listening. Leadership is first a vision — and that [also] requires listening. Service is built on the foundation of understanding someone else’s needs and aspirations.”

What sounds like a listening tour to some will strike his opponents in the fight for the mayor’s office as aimlessness. What, exactly does Marlin Woods believe and what does he stand for?

Mr. Woods does not speak in pithy soundbites that are easily digestible on the evening news. His verbal mannerism are idiosyncratic and somewhat formal. He likes big words. That may become a problem when he has to connect with audiences that lack the patience to wrestle with his arguments, which tend unspool at their own unique speed.

For someone who did not go to college, Mr. Woods is wonkish and sounds like he is extremely well-read. He has an autodidact’s knack for learning and retaining a lot about subjects he’s interested in, which has made him a sought after speaker and board member in Pittsburgh’s business community. It has also made him a believer in the intelligence of common people who are the ones to suffer most under the bad policy initiatives of the city’s educated elites.

*

Advertise with us

On the evening of June 10, Marlin Woods, his family, including his father, Eric Woods, a retired civil engineer who lives in Atlanta, staged a campaign rally at Highland Park Reservoir surrounded by dozens of supporters holding and waving the distinctive black and gold signs of his candidacy.

Buttoned down in a blue suit and matching tie despite the humidity, he launched into a brief roundup of the themes he plans to emphasize throughout his campaign. In most photos of Mr. Woods on his website and in televised interviews, he is tieless and closer to business casual in style, but for his inaugural kickoff, he was all business including a tie.

Drawing on his experience as a business owner, motivational speaker and house preacher, Mr. Woods code-switched between his various identities for a crowd that seemed already familiar with him.

Finding his rhythm while his wife stood by, Mr. Woods invited the crowd to imagine a new kind of leadership on Grant Street. Without explaining how, he promised that every citizen would have input into the city’s governance and benefit from its growth.

He spoke of “customizable solutions” and gathering Pittsburghers together at the “table of discussion” and collaboration “which is what community looks like.” He spoke with conviction, but was vague on specifics. But like the practiced speechmaker he is, Marlin Woods projected a persona as a compassionate businessman with deep roots in the community.

Advertise with us

After an election that amounted to a referendum on the current mayor and revolved around issues of police reform, gentrification, corporate responsibility and the slow rate of racial progress city wide, will Mr. Woods’ appeal to “common sense leadership” as he calls it, be enough to make a dent in Mr. Gainey’s appeal to Black voters, white progressives and Democrats of all stripes who were not interested in giving Mr. Peduto a third term?

In contrast to the opaqueness of his first public rollout where he sounded more like a philosopher than a candidate for political office, the Marlin Woods for Mayor website was updated to provide clearer and more succinct answers about the candidate’s positions on the issues that concern most Pittsburghers. It’s as if Mr. Woods suddenly realized that voters weren’t interested in electing the most articulate candidate to the city’s highest office. Pittsburghers want the candidate most in touch with and engaged with the realities of their daily struggles to become mayor.

Jessica Brooks Woods, left, and Marlin Woods, independent candidate for Pittsburgh mayor, at the family’s East Liberty home on Thursday evening, July 1, 2021. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In subsequent interviews with political reporters on KDKA and WTAE, Mr. Woods has been more intentional about moving away from the abstractions of his early rhetoric, though he is far from ever being mistaken for a populist. Still, he’s learning to tell his story in ways that could potentially connect with ordinary people.

When KDKA’s political editor Jon Delano asked him his thoughts about the dramatic increase in shootings across the city, he didn’t resort to abstractions. “This hit our house, Jon,” he said forcefully. “My niece was at a high school graduation party recently and was shot in the abdomen.”

It was a strikingly vulnerable moment for the candidate who then circled back with an intensity that would have been unusual for the Marlin Woods of June 10. “When my wife calls the police, I want them to show up, and I want police to be on the beat and available to show up,” he told Mr. Delano. “So it’s not necessarily defunding the police, but it’s more so shifting the allocation of funds into other areas. Police are overworked and underpaid.”

Advertise with us

Who is Marlin Woods?

“I was born and raised in this city,” Mr. Woods told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last month. “I love this city. My wife, Jessica and [our] four young children, Jesse, Jace, Zi and Marlin, Jr., live around the corner from the high school [Peabody] I attended.”

For all of his polish and business savvy, Mr. Woods did not attend college. “I had a plan for how I wanted to live my life and I executed it,” he said when asked about skipping what many consider one of life’s most formative experiences. It doesn’t seem to have hurt the businessman who lives a solidly upper middle class life with a family he started with his high-powered wife, Jessica Brooks-Woods, President and CEO of Pittsburgh Business Group on Health.

Mr. Woods has lived in other cities, including Los Angeles, Atlanta and Miami, but felt compelled to return and start his health consulting business in the city he credits with “making him” during his formative years. He said he wants his children to experience what he calls “a quality of life” that Pittsburgh provides along with opportunities he believes are here for everyone inside and outside his household.

Mr. Woods said that he hasn’t always thought about running for office, but after a series of ‘strong sensations’ first pointed him in that direction in 2016, he began seriously contemplating the role of mayor in 2017 when various community and business leaders approached him about the possibility unprompted.

Advertise with us

“I’ve not always been a registered independent,” he said. “Like most people, I followed my family’s traditional voting affiliation, which was Democrat until I realized my values had evolved and were no longer habitual. I had a choice, and I identified freedom with independence.”

Asked how his skills as a businessman, motivational speaker and preacher transfer to running a city despite never having held elected office, Mr. Woods said that his various callings aren’t as far removed from the job he seeks as they might appear on paper. “Each align and directly transfer to the responsibility of service, stewardship, decision-making, integrity, critical thinking, emotional intelligence and the facilitation of well-being while elevating the quality of life of others [and] ultimately leadership,” he said.

Marlin Woods, independent candidate for Pittsburgh mayor, gets a fist bump from son Marlin Jr., 4, as the family gathers in the living room of Woods’ East Liberty home on Thursday evening, July 1, 2021. From rom left are son Jessie, 14; daughter Jace, 9; daughter Zi, 7; Marlin Jr.; wife Jessica Brooks Woods; Marlin Woods. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Mr. Woods describes the race for mayor as a solution to a burden, not the burden itself. It is a subtle distinction he tries to be clear about. “The burden is not an ambition,” he said. “It’s not a dream — it’s a mandate. How do I know? It’s that thing that keeps me up at night pondering solutions that are specific to each Pittsburgher.”

He insists that having never held political office doesn’t put him at a disadvantage in terms of civic leadership. “I am not a career politician nor a novice at effective leadership,” he said. “I don’t believe this office calls for a career politician. This post-COVID era requires an unconventional approach. I’m as connected to the issues and challenges in corporate and non-profit boardrooms as I am to matters in the neighborhood.”

How Marlin Woods plans to win in November.

Advertise with us

Asked how he plans to appeal to the voters who voted for Gainey over Peduto and Moreno in May, Mr. Woods is blunt.

“Of 306,000 [registered voters], less than 50,000 voted. That’s a disinterested population. I’m here to galvanize Pittsburgh and bring them back to the table to hear their voice. My responsibility is to listen and act on the concerns and expectations of each resident,” he said. “Again, only 10% of voters participated in the Democratic primary, which tells us that there are too many residents who are not at the table.”

Mr. Woods is only half joking when he says he plans to knock on every door in town if necessary to get the votes he needs. He’s been hitting the gym for the last few years and looks like he could actually do it. Asked what his biggest ambition is for the city, he gets personal about his own feelings. “I want the city of Pittsburgh to become a community again,” he said. “I remember the ‘79 Pirates. Their theme song was ‘We Are Family.’ That did something to me that never left. I want us to return to that concept of community, family. We want Pittsburgh to be the standard.

“This city requires customizable solutions that respond to the next generation of opportunity. This is so much bigger than being the first Black mayor or being an Independent. It’s about people who care about the city and want to see it thrive without losing the fundamental aspects that make us uniquely Pittsburgh.”

Marlin Woods has positions on practically everything, but he insists he’s focused on listening for now and pursuing the office of mayor as a candidate who is truly in touch with the hopes and dreams of his would-be constituents. He says he knows it won’t be easy, but he’s confident of the outcome. If he listens to Pittsburgh, he says, the people will vote for the one who listens to what they have to say, not the one who tells them what they want to hear.

Advertise with us

For information about campaign appearances and his stances on the issues go to www.marlinewoods.com or download the Marlin Woods app for the calendar of public appearances.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631; Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.