When Donald J. Trump descended the gaudy gold escalator at Trump Tower to announce his presidential run in 2015, American punditry could scarcely contain its glee.

Here was a man who would run as a guaranteed font of ignorance and bigotry judging by his tweets at the time. He had already proved through 14 seasons of “The Apprentice” that he knew how to keep a freak show going.

At best, Mr. Trump would be an entertaining warmup act for the long expected Jeb Bush vs. Hillary Clinton battle-of-the-dynasties expected the following year.

Mr. Trump did not disappoint in that inaugural speech. It was there that he made his infamous comment about Mexican “rapists” and other themes he would later use to whip up crowds at his rallies going forward.

Advertise with us

It was also on that day that Mr. Trump claimed that he was the leader America most needed to put its economic house in order. He audaciously laid claim to a track record in business that he didn’t have and a financial acumen he didn’t possess to justify his run.

Most political journalists, especially the New York-based reporters who had covered his serial business failures and self-dealing hype for years, howled with laughter at Mr. Trump’s audacity.

How, these reporters and pundits wondered, did he think he was going to get away with such revisionist nonsense when even a casual check through the financial press would reveal the Potemkin village-like nature of his “real estate empire”?

If anything, Donald Trump was a stupid person’s idea of what a rich person looked like, just as the conventional wisdom in financial reporting circles that regularly covered him had decided. His ritual groveling for loans to cover payments to other banks just as those loan payments were coming due was well known and mocked. He was the king of shell games and other high-interest cons.

But when Americans who didn’t read the financial trades or “Spy” or any of the regular exposes of Donald Trump saw him promising to run America the way he ran his own businesses, they heard the subliminal promptings of the chorus to the O’Jays song that served as the theme song to “The Apprentice” — “money, money, money, money, money.” They liked what they heard.

Advertise with us

These very uninformed future voters who would sweep him into the White House with roughly a 77,000 vote margin that swung the Electoral College in his favor in 2016 assumed they knew what the O’Jays’ “For the Love of Money” was all about.

They assumed the Donald Trump who sat in the fake boardroom of “The Apprentice” somehow embodied the so-called self-made millionaire/​billionaire capitalist ethos they aspired to emulate and take to the next level when they got their shot. They would not begrudge Mr. Trump his lies and exaggerations if that was deemed necessary to get to the top.

Meanwhile, the know-it-all reporters of the financial press made an equally disastrous assumption. They assumed that Mr. Trump’s financial medicine show, along with its xenophobic circus, would be derailed as soon as he was compelled by custom to reveal his tax returns to the public before he took the Republican nomination.

In a dramatic break with precedent that had been established since Watergate, Mr. Trump refused to release his tax documents because he was being “audited.” Ironically, as we found out from The New York Times’ blockbusting reporting over the weekend on the ill-health of Mr. Trump’s finances, he really is being audited. That’s the only thing he hasn’t been lying about.

Still, the fact that he’s being audited doesn’t preclude him from releasing his tax info. Say what one will about the fact that Mr. Trump has a grade schooler’s comprehension of civics, economics and the human condition, he’s not stupid. He knows that the perception of his “success” rests upon sleight of hand and the willingness of the public to take his word that he’s a billionaire when he’s barely a millionaire on paper when all of his debts are taken into account. He has no wiggle room. He’s a man in hock and that wouldn’t have made an impressive selling point to his hoodwinked supporters.

Advertise with us

Mr. Trump is in debt to international banks and who-knows-who else given his shady dealings. That’s why his foreign policy is so suspicious. Who Mr. Trump is indebted to would explain why he cozies up to tyrants and dictators and makes the strange foreign policy decisions that he does.

It’s not too much of a stretch to say Mr. Trump would already be sitting in prison had he tried many of the same shenanigans he’s gotten away with since the 1980s during a more scrupulous era of financial fraud enforcement and investigation.

The fact that a self-proclaimed billionaire paid only $750 in personal income tax in 2016 and 2017 and none at all in 10 of the preceding 15 years is a shock to the conscience. Well, except for the consciences of Trump stooges who are already reliably defending him as “wise” for avoiding the payment of taxes by every “legal” means at his disposal.

The fact that Mr. Trump criticized President Barack Obama for allegedly not paying enough federal income tax several years ago doesn’t cause the president to blink back tears of shame over his own hypocrisy, of course. He’s just moving his lips and tweeting without any regard for truth or consistency. He knows none of this matters to his supporters. They never hear the rest of that O’Jays song: “For the love of money / People will lie, Lord, they will cheat / for the love of money / People don’t care who they hurt or beat.”

Rick Santorum, a former U.S. senator from Pennsylvania, argued on CNN this week that rich people hire tax attorneys who “game the system” for them, so there’s nothing wrong with what Mr. Trump did as far as he’s concerned.

Advertise with us

At least Mr. Santorum is forthright about the fact that religious conservatives like himself abandoned concerns about “morality” and “fairness” a long time ago. Now, it’s all about the Dear Leader’s power to do anything he wants retroactively and far into the future.

I’m hoping that Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden can make hay of the fact that Mr. Trump is either a fake billionaire or a lowdown scammer who claims millions in losses on his tax returns to avoid paying his fair share. If he’s broke but inflating his wealth to get loans — that’s a crime. It may be business as usual in New York real estate, but it isn’t legal, much less ethical.

Oh, America! Instead of the competent, decisive boss of the TV show simulacrum many envied, we got a tax cheat and common hustler who loses more money than he makes. Do we really want to give another four years to a carnival barker who isn’t even competent enough to run a mom-and-pop real estate shop without losing more money than any other American ever has in American history?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.