Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the dignity and legal rights of Native Americans in a 5-4 decision no one saw coming.
The Supreme Court majority agreed with Native American plaintiffs that Congress left critical paperwork regarding borders of reservations undone when it made Oklahoma a state in 1907. This oversight means that whole swaths of Tulsa and Eastern Oklahoma, remnants of the reservation secured by treaty, are still technically Native American land in the eyes of American law.
It was a rare win before a high court that has consistently ruled against Native American interests in disputes about tribal sovereignty and a state’s right to continue an unjust status quo, even if land rights were acquired crookedly.
That landmark decision was followed by an announcement on Monday that Washington’s NFL franchise is finally retiring the most racially offensive name in sports — the Washington Redskins.
Though the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision regarding Oklahoma’s boundaries will have long-term implications that will be fought in tribal court and the state’s legislature for decades, future generations of historians and sports fans will marvel at how quickly brand loyalty to such a degrading symbol evaporated once corporate America decided enough was enough!
Team owner Dan Snyder didn’t suddenly succumb to a bout of moral suasion in dropping a franchise name he once swore in capital letters that he would never change. Since acquiring the team two decades ago, he’s proved to be immune to all appeals to conscience, decorum, morality and common sense.
Read More
Mr. Snyder, who fondly recalls attending games with his father as a child, has nothing but the gauziest of memories of the team name and its mascot. Because it is associated with some of his earliest and most pleasant memories of an old America, it is difficult for him, as a privileged and very rich white guy, to see it as a slur, contrary to all the offense taken by Native Americans. He continued to see it as a tribute to Native Americans and not an insult regardless of how many people in a better position to know insisted otherwise.
In fact, Mr. Snyder was insulted that Native Americans were insulted; he wondered why they didn’t take his word at face value that no offense was meant no matter how many decades they had nursed a grievance against his team’s name.
Caught in a tangled web of ego, racist paternalism and sentimentality, Mr. Snyder was determined to hold onto the name until something even more powerful than the moral arguments he had effortlessly swatted away for years changed his mind — the loss of corporate sponsorship and support on a mass scale.
When it became clear to him that FedEx, Nike, PepsiCo and Bank of America didn’t care that the 87-year-old team’s name made him feel warm and fuzzy inside, Mr. Snyder knew the game was up.
Nationwide protests ignited by the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis in May sparked intense national introspection about the role of racial discrimination in America, but that wouldn’t have changed Mr. Snyder’s mind if tens of thousands of corporate shareholders and employees weren’t leaning on their own companies to do the right thing at the Fortune 500 level.
Instead of trying to appeal to Mr. Snyder’s conscience — always a losing proposition — people went over his head and leaned on the companies that underwrite Washington’s shaky franchise. That worked.
Ultimately, Black Lives Matter is entitled to credit for the name change as a case of collateral damage, but it was the combination of outside corporate pressure and the District of Columbia’s refusal to allow the franchise to build a new stadium on the federally owned RFK Stadium site unless there was a name change that put all of Mr. Snyder’s schemes in check. There was no way he would be allowed to do the equivalent of a quarterback sneak into the old RFK site, where he desperately wants to build a state-of-the-art stadium guaranteed to make money whether he has a winning team or not.
On Monday, the franchise did not tip its hand what the new name of the team might be, but head coach Ron Rivera is said to be working closely with Mr. Snyder to honor the military and Native Americans, but there are “trademark issues” that have to be worked out.
If a compromise isn’t possible with Native American groups, an emerging favorite among many D.C. fans and sports analysts seems to be the Washington Red Tails. The Red Tails was the nickname of the formidable Tuskegee Airmen, that hard-to-beat squadron of Black fighter pilots who distinguished themselves in the skies above the European theater during World War II.
Despite fighting in a largely segregated military, the Red Tails were respected because they shot down a disproportionate number of German planes and fought with a bravery that made any questioning of their patriotism or their fighting ability look silly. They gleefully shot down arrogant representatives of Hitler’s “Master Race” every day.
The Red Tails were young Black men, mostly from the South, who loved their country and fought for its highest ideals even though they had nothing to look forward to when they returned to America except Jim Crow and second-class citizenship whether they wore their uniforms in public or not.
Mr. Snyder could do a lot worse than naming his team after genuine American heroes, assuming he is able to honor them without resorting to gross caricature or condescension. The story of the Red Tails needs to be included in history books and celebrated in the mainstream of American life.
Because football is arguably America’s primary religion, naming the franchise the Washington Red Tails would spark necessary conversation about those brave men and what happened to them when they returned to a country that despised them because of the color of their skin.
It would also spark an unprecedented demand for team merchandise as Black football fans — and millions of fans and nonfans of all races — purchased the newly redesigned franchise gear to make a statement. It will be interesting to see if Mr. Snyder, who held on to the former logo and mascot with the tenacity of a Mississippi politician holding on to the Confederate flag, is smart enough to recognize the economic windfall that would come from acknowledging the overlooked contributions of the former young lords of the sky. It would be a win-win for football and America.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.