Someone has to explain to me how this works. Here’s the scenario: You’re a 78-year-old retired administrative law judge who used to hear Social Security disability cases in Morgantown, W.Va., so you’re more than familiar with the fine points of the law.
Your boyfriend is a 50-year-old Nazi. Not figuratively, but literally. He’s nothing like the Soup Nazi on “Seinfeld” — tyrannical but harmless. He’s truly an avowed Nazi who wears his Hitler fetish proudly.
He’s a collector of Nazi paraphernalia and has a weapons cache of knives and guns. He collects videos of gun massacres, has a fanboy crush on racist mass killer Dylann Roof and an unhealthy obsession with relitigating the outcome of World War II.
Your Nazi boyfriend is also a violent felon who is not legally allowed to buy or own guns. Still, he has been bugging you for years to be a straw-man purchaser for an AR-15-style rifle, favored by mass killers for whom indiscriminate murder is the point.
You’re obviously aware of your boyfriend’s shady past and penchant for violence, so you initially resist because, well, as an administrative law judge, it would be both illegal and unseemly for you to help a convicted felon acquire a weapon of mass destruction.
So you do the only thing you can do: You wait until you’re officially retired from the bench to help your Sieg-Heiling boyfriend achieve his dream of finally possessing the biggest death-dealing weapon he has ever aspired to own.
Read More
Meanwhile, you split your time between your place in the Grove City area and his place in Troy Hill.
On Sept. 28, 2018, you both make a stop at Ace Sporting Goods in Washington County, where you buy a Ruger .223 caliber AR-15-style rifle after passing a background check. Your Nazi boyfriend has picked out the weapon and writes you a check for $789.
It is literally one month before another Pittsburgh-based Nazi kills 11 people and wounds six at the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill, the deadliest mass attack on American Jews in this country’s history.
If only you had the ability to see the future, you tell yourself. You might’ve held off buying this person — this unstable collector of Hitler posters, this shouter of anti-Semitic slurs, this hater of people darker than himself, this fan of swastika-clinging murderers — another gun to add to his home arsenal.
But your Nazi boyfriend flies under the radar for more than a year after the Tree of Life massacre, or so you think. On Jan. 22, the police stage a raid on your Nazi boyfriend’s Troy Hill home and find the AR-15 you bought for him along with a Ruger .22 caliber revolver, a Harrington & Richardson shotgun, a .38 special revolver, a Colt .38 caliber revolver, a .32 caliber revolver and a large collection of knives.
There was also the usual Nazi apparel and paraphernalia one finds during these kinds of raids. Also found were enough bottles of liquor and alcohol to put a small state store out of business. It turns out your boyfriend is also a connoisseur of massacre porn and likes to watch the video of the 2019 mass shooting of Muslims at a mosque in Christchurch, New Zealand.
The more we learn about him, the worse it gets, it seems. It makes us all wonder how someone as educated and intelligent as we assume judges to be didn’t see this coming. How do you miss the signs that your self-proclaimed Nazi boyfriend is a mass shooter wannabe and an above-the-fold news story in the making?
It’s hard to feel sorry for the couple in this situation. Former Judge Karl Alexander has already pleaded guilty to buying Dennis Alan Riggs the AR-15. He blames Riggs’ constant begging over the years for wearing him down.
Mr. Alexander faces up to a decade in prison, but prosecutors are recommending three years tops, perhaps because of his age. His reputation is effectively shot forever, but if that’s the biggest casualty of helping his boyfriend acquire a weapon he shouldn’t have had, then he’s getting off pretty easy. Riggs conceivably could have been the inspiration for the Tree of Life killer instead of the other way around.
The late author David Foster Wallace wrote more than once that “every love story is a ghost story.” It’s an evocative phrase with an elusive meaning. Wallace’s oft-used phrase occurred to me while contemplating the strange relationship between the retired judge and the Nazi felon.
How did two gay men end up in a situation where Nazi ideology and racial symbolism holds sway over either one of them? Given that they would’ve both been executed under the Third Reich’s rules for “degenerates” if the nature of their relationship had become known, how did Riggs reconcile his romantic relationship with his ideological commitments to organized Nazism?
Is Riggs an openly gay Nazi? It sounds oxymoronic to me that a gay person can even be a Nazi unless he or she is deeply closeted and in denial. Forgive me if I have this completely wrong.
Riggs will have to face charges for possession of firearms as a convicted felon. With any luck, he will be convicted and kept behind bars for many, many years given his willingness to break the law, amass weapons and steep himself in hateful rhetoric and symbols.
The peculiar details of this case aside, there is an unsettling resurgence of Nazi sympathizers and white power fanatics across the country. Last month, FBI Director Christopher Wray told the House Judiciary Committee that far-right domestic extremists have risen to “national threat priority.” Mr. Wray warned the lawmakers that “lone offender attacks” make up the majority of domestic terror incidents and that white supremacist ideologies were the spark and rationale for most of the hate crimes in 2018 and 2019.
The list of domestic terrorists expanded somewhat in recent months to accommodate the spate of black cultists who murdered and attacked Jews in New Jersey and New York, but their numbers pale in comparison to homegrown American Nazis like Riggs still hiding in the shadows.
There’s also the reality of the fact that we’re living in an increasingly incoherent age where ideological consistency and fidelity to one’s former profession as an officer of the court doesn’t mean anything. No one seems interested in hating along strict ideological lines anymore. The easy availability of guns complicates an already bad situation.
David Foster Wallace was probably right about love stories being ghost stories, whatever he ultimately meant by it. Even so, some love stories, it turns out, are even more ghostly than others.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.