It is a cruel thing to know the time and date of one’s own death, especially when it will come courtesy of state prosecution. A Texas jury heard evidence against Rodney Reed in 1998 and pronounced him guilty of murdering 19-year-old Stacey Stites in 1996.
Reed has been on Texas’ notorious death row ever since. He is scheduled to be executed by lethal injection on Nov. 20. Since his original trial two decades ago, evidence has surfaced that would have compelled any honest jury to have freed Reed.
The litany of exculpatory evidence is so overwhelming that if Texas were a human being and not simply a way-station for random injustices, it would recoil at the prospect of killing an innocent man the way anyone with a conscience would.
But this is Texas we’re talking about. Texas officials have always been willing to kill people not truly guilty of crimes for which they may have been convicted, just as long as it was done lawfully and in good order.
Gov. Greg Abbott, as tough as a tough-on-crime Republican governor can be in a state that values toughness over such ephemeral concerns as justice or mercy, has heard the bipartisan cries on Reed’s behalf coming from members of the state legislature.
Rodney Reed will be executed unless Mr. Abbott intervenes after accessing the evidence submitted to him and orders a temporary reprieve. It would be up to the Texas Board of Pardons to do the right thing after that.
Read More
Recently, Texas law enforcement officers have stepped forward to express their skepticism about the evidence presented at Reed’s trial. They say that if he is executed on the basis of that faulty evidence, it will only generate more contempt for Texas law and the men and women who attempt to enforce it.
Meanwhile, the Texas Department of Public Safety has described the testimony of its own expert during Rodney Reed’s murder trial as “erroneous.”
Because the time of Stites’ death was crucial to the dismantling of Reed’s alibi that accounted for his presence somewhere else when she was being murdered, the testimony of the medical examiner was crucial to his conviction. The pathologist has since admitted he was completely wrong about the time frame of Stites’ murder.
Meanwhile, Jimmy Fennell, the victim’s fiance who was convicted and sentenced for rape himself in 2007, allegedly told his cellmate that he was the one who killed Stites. Fennell, a former cop, said he was furious and humiliated by the fact that she was having a consensual affair with a black man: Rodney Reed.
“I had to kill my [n-word]-loving fiancee,” Arthur Snow, Fennell’s cellmate testified the convicted rapist told him via sworn affidavit last month. Snow was one of the leaders of the Aryan Brotherhood at the prison and one of Fennell’s “protectors,” yet he came forward with evidence that indicts Fennell. Even by Texas standards, this case couldn’t get any more twisted.
The fact that Rodney Reed and Stacey Stites, a white woman, were seeing each other on the sly would account for the presence of the convicted man’s DNA in her body, but that wasn’t a story that the convicted man’s lawyer was competent enough to sell to the jury.
The prosecutor presented Reed’s DNA as evidence of a sexual assault that escalated to murder. The fraught racial politics of interracial sex in a tiny Texas town elided easily into the murder trial because the defense failed to present testimony that the victim and her alleged murderer had an ongoing sexual relationship.
It was easier for a Texas jury to believe the state’s case that Reed was a murdering rapist than the defendant’s insistence that Stites was someone he had been sneaking around with.
While Fennell was initially the No. 1 suspect in his live-in fiancee’s murder for a short time, suspicion shifted to Reed once the DNA on the victim was identified as his. After all, Fennell was a cop that, despite his well-documented anger issues, no one wanted to believe could strangle his fiancee and dump her body by the side of the road like garbage.
The calls for a re-examination of all the evidence, including a belt used to strangle Stites that would likely have DNA on it that would implicate Fennell, have been resisted so far.
Even when Fennell was a suspect, the home he shared with Stites was never searched for evidence, and his bizarre and dangerous behavior before and after Reed’s trial never considered a reason to reopen the case. Even his rape conviction, a 10-year sentence failed to raise eyebrows with the court.
Institutional Texas justice is reluctant to rehash death row cases because Texas is a state that prides itself on always executing the right culprits — even when it doesn’t.
The fact that celebrities like Kim Kardashian and rapper Meek Mill, along with hordes of social media activists on Twitter and Facebook, have made Reed’s case their latest cause celebre has only stiffened the spines of those who originally prosecuted the case.
When Mr. Abbott was the state’s attorney general, he fought to uphold Reed’s conviction despite mounting evidence for his innocence. During his dozen years as the state’s top cop and prosecutor, Texas executed 278 people. Mr. Abbott’s record as governor is currently 47 executions by lethal injection under his watch. It will rise to 48 if Reed is executed next week.
Since he became governor in 2015, Mr. Abbott has intervened in a death row case only once, so the odds don’t look good for Rodney Reed. Despite some of the best legal minds in the nation working to spring Reed from death row, whether he lives or dies will depend on whether Mr. Abbott gives in once more to his most callous instincts or decides to follow the higher demands of justice.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.